Archived from groups: rec.video.desktop (
More info?)
Ted Kerin wrote:
> "Ron Tock" <rontockPANTS@yahooPANTS.com> wrote in message
> news:0CO8e.4259$26.977@chiapp18.algx.net...
>
>>Is there a way I can directly convert clips from a movie on a DVD
>>to either an AVI or MPEG? The IFO files do not open up in Premiere.
>>I realise I can hook my DVD player to the computer and capture but I
>>really don't want to have to do that.
>>I would like to put the DVD into my reader on the computer and go from
>>there. I already do video capture so the computer is set up for capture.
>>
>>TIA
>
>
>
> The actual video (and audio) content is in the VOB files, not the IFOs.
>
> Premiere does not open or edit MPEGs, and a VOB, as far as I know, is
> basically a DVD-compliant kind of MPEG. As to the part of your question
> which asks about converting DVD clips to an MPEG, you could simply rename
> the VOB files to MPEG files. But, that won't help you with trying to edit
> them in Premiere.
Priemere is, of course lousy with MPEGs for editing but it encodes them
and they play ok.
>
> I use Premiere Elements, but I don't think Premiere Pro is any better in
> this regard. Adobe cutely suggests that you may have problems trying to open
> MPEGs in Premiere, but I suggest read that as , you WILL have problems!
> Don't bother trying -- it's the wrong use for a good tool..
>
> Somebody else might suggest a "DVD2AVI" type tool, but I have no experience
> with that. Depending on what you're trying to do, you might be better off
> with something like TMPGEnc DVD Author (which will open the DVD's whole
> VIDEO_TS folder, and let you make cuts in it -- although not down to exact
> frames -- then create or change the menus); or VideoReDo (which lets you
> import the individual VOB files, then make cuts, then join the VOBs back
> together); or Womble MPEG Video Wizard (which will import VOBs to a
> Premiere-type timeline, then let you make cuts and/or alter the video or
> audio in Premiere-type ways -- at the price of re-encoding, with loss of
> some quality -- or add titles or transitions).
>
> If you're talking about a copy-protected DVD, then don't bother trying any
> of the above til you use DVD Decrypter or DVD Shrink to rip the content to
> your hard drive. Then, proceed as above.
I have and use DVD Decrypter snd DVD Shrink. Excellent programs, both.
>
> Hope this helps. But I suggest you poke around videohelp.com, a great
> resource for this kind of information. Good luck!
That's a good idea. Thanks.