Archived from groups: rec.video.desktop (
More info?)
The VideoRedo ($50) and Womble Mpg Video Wizard ($100) are two
different types of editors used for different reasons. VideoRedo will
ensure that the captured mpeg file is dvd compliant, while providing
the best trimming interface of any mpeg editor that I have used. The
Womble is great for adding effects, titles, etc... It too will trim,
but it doesn't have that fix the mpeg quality that VR has. Both are
frame accurate mpeg editors.
There are others available as well. I also have Pinnacle Studio. It
works well with mpeg. It, however, is not frame accurate, only
allowing cuts on the I-frame (There are about 2 I-frames per second
using an NTSC DVD compliant max GOP of 15). I am pretty sure that
Ulead and others will work as well.
It appears to me that the camera that you purchased captures directly
to mpeg on the mini dvd disks. I don't believe that the editors will
be your biggest limitation, but rather the maximum capacity of the mini
dvd at the best quality of capture is about 30 minutes, if I remember
correctly. But one can carry along a lot of mini disks. I don't think
that this is a bad way to go if ones final target for the video is DVD
and one captures at the highest quality (high bit rate). It does save
a lot of time. The real time capture quality of mpeg-2 keeps getting
better.
The camera that I am keeping an eye on is one that JVC has announced
which will have a 30gb hard drive in it. It too will capture to mpeg-2
format directly but will hold over 7 hours of high quality mpeg-2
before having to be unloaded to a computer.
Cheers...