Dudes, 30 000 US Ford America manufacturing jobs to be scrapped.
I find it to be amazing that it took this long, to be honest. Frankly, the losses they've been experiencing were, and are, completely unsustainable (50% decrease in sales on some models with SUVs 30% down and free-falling).
There is a harsh reality that the developed West must and will face: high-tech, high-end service orientated industries are its future and that means re-education and re-training for the masses involved in core and heavy industries; manufacturing now belongs to the developing world.
It just reminds me again and again how important a good education is and unless you're a talented 'tradey' who can cut it with his/her hands then you'd better hit the books my man for otherwise you'll be flippin' burgers for the rest of your life and while that is good, honest, steady work its hardly stimulating is it?
30 000 though? Thats a staggering figure and I'll be extremely interested to see the political fall-out regarding this. Bush is the 'jobs for Americans' man after all. He'll surely eat shit-burgers over this even though its an irrepressible trend that's embracing the world, namely economic globalisation.
I could be wrong, but I think they cut 10,000 jobs last year and 30,000 the year before that. So this isn't new. I might be mixing GM in there but I'm too tired to look it up.
Well MG Rover folded not so long ago and now the Chinese are in picking up what's left. Same is happening to Ford, I suppose - all the jobs are going to China, which is fair enough as they do have a cheaper labour economy. Best not go to war with them for a little while though, as our trucks and even berets are now made over there
It gets to where you can't afford to keep up with the education.... I'm a automotive engineer that was cut 4 years ago.... Ours went to Mexico & China..... I've got 3 degrees & now at 55 they pull another degree out of there ass they want you to get.....
The educated here are the working poor.... Student loans up the ying yang most of my co workers had student loans of over $30,000.... They can't live up to there education standards, because of the loans.... They cut back, these people go bankrupt...... Then the grand finalli is, your education is dated, you need this brand new degree we pulled out of our ass.....
Education is one of the biggest businesses we have & it's running people in the ground trying to keep up with it.... It is sad to me, for the young people here....
In our state the most need workers are trades people.... They have bigger adds than the colleges do.... That's got to say something is wrong with education today, in the US....
Sorry, one of my pet peeves.....
Rc, mate, dont be sorry. I found that a very interesting perspective to read, in fact.
You're statements rang home with me too. I have a Bachelor's in political science, yet its worth a Big Phat woopty doo to me as I'm unable to put it to solid use - not to mention my distinct lack of interest in the area - and I'm now enrolled to do a second degree [this time in business] and I'm scared shitless of the financial position I'll be in when I graduate at the age of 31.
You're right: student loans are a killer and its the good tradeys who are making good money (there are tradeys here pulling six figures easily because their skills are now highly prized).
I will be at least $40 k down after this second degree. Thats an enormous amout that I'll have to make back once inflation and interest is taken into account. I've only just finished paying off my first student loan here and its shit to know that I'll be under the hammer after this next degree.
Some good food for thought that you posted there, RC.
Very similar situation over here. A friend of mine had a physics degree and ended up getting a job..... pumping gas. 6 years of his life in higher education, and he can't get a job to suit.
Funny you should mention tradesmen. Another mate of mine got laid off by our last carmaker when they folded (MGRover, as Aaron mentioned). He decided to retrain and take up a trade. Plumbing courses at all local colleges are on an 18 month waiting list. He met up a with a former middle manager from the company who's now training as a plasterer.
They're pushing further education big time over here, with univeristy placements at an all time high, but what exactly is waiting for people out there when they finish? Not much. Several years ago, IT firms wouldn't so much as look at you if you didn't have at least an MCSE. Now, you can have all the qualifications up the arse, if you don't have experience, you don't get a sniff. Industry has done a 180. Not long before it'll do it again.
| Quote : Well MG Rover folded not so long ago and now the Chinese are in picking up what's left. Same is happening to Ford, I suppose - all the jobs are going to China, which is fair enough as they do have a cheaper labour economy. Best not go to war with them for a little while though, as our trucks and even berets are now made over there |
Its interesting isn't it. I had to buy a new dvd player and because I'm on a strict budget now that I'm back at uni and currently unemployed I had to look at the low-end of the spectrum for a player.
I picked one up for less than $50 Aus which is what, 20 quid and around $35 US. Amazing! The player's good news too, sure it does not have all the features but she plays all formats, has a 12 month warranty and because it was dirt cheap I'm happy, the Chinese capitalist manufacturer is happy, the repressive Communist regime is happy and the worker, albeit on a lesser scale, is happy to be working and getting paid.
I bought furniture too. Yep, you guessed it, some of it was produced in China and while its not the type of gear to win people over for a dinner party, the furniture is comfortable, well made and priced at a level that is all good mate!
Now, you go back 10 years ago and Chinese manufacturing was laughable from a quality perspective but since the communist regime has allowed much more foreign investment into the country and because the big corporations have invested heavily there, we're now seeing quality controls being put in place that are as high in certain regards as their Western couterparts yet their cost structure is incredible courtesy of low labour costs, an inexhaustible labour pool, tax structures that are very appealing etc..
I'm caught up in it because of my age.... A lot of my old credits won't work in a new degree.... So I'd have to do 3 years worth of school to get the degree they want now.... I'd be a grad. again at 58 & starting back out on the bottom again.... I was senior staff before though....
No, I'm getting a little to old to play the next round of the education game..... [shrug]
Even if I did get the new degree, it would be a re hash of what I've already had....... Just another way of getting $$$$ for a new paper / job..... [shrug]
| Quote : Very similar situation over here. A friend of mine had a physics degree and ended up getting a job..... pumping gas. 6 years of his life in higher education, and he can't get a job to suit.
|
Exactly Rob.
Mate, I'm looking at banking and finance as my specialisation by doing a double major in that area. No airy fairy major which was my mistake with the politics degree.
Get this, and this is laughable, my major in that first degree was: 'Societal, cultural, and governmental philosophy'.
WTF???
Mate, I loved it but in truth that major was only a philosophy type major and its next to focking useless in the real world.
Now get this: over here, as I think it is over there where you are, Nursing, Doctors and teaching [particularly for male teachers] is at crisis point. The government will help pay your tuition [30% actually] if you choose nursing. Like most Western countries, our nation is ageing rapidly and nurses here are now demanding higher wages and getting it easily because goverments simply cant afford to lose them.
I'm focked if I do and I'm focked if I dont with this degree. I'll be broke for the next 3 years and have a mound of debt when I graduate. Or, I go back to full-time work with my best hope for a team leader role in a call centre with the possibility of moving on to sales management if I can find a half-decent manager to teach me what I need to know. I've got experience in sales management, but because the qualifications aren't there I'm focked.
RC, I hear you mate.
Now if it was me I would tell you this: there's no way I could go back in my late 50s to do another degree. No way in the wide world! I dont know how you can do it, mate. You shouldn't have to, is what I'm saying. You should be able to retire for Christ's sake.
Truly, I'm knocking 28 and I feel a touch too old to go back to uni and if I was any older there's no way I could do it.
Not to mention having a family. When the fock will I manage that?
On the other hand, my sister who is extremely well educated and doing really well for herself rationalised it to me in this sense:
"You never stop learning Brett. Its a fact of life in Western countries that re-training is a constant in the postmodern world we live in and until you can afford to retire you'll have to update your skills as required."
Its going to be hard for me. I'll have to get night-time work which means cleaning shitters or working in a call centre to make ends meet. I was telling Dh that my new apartment, while very nice and comfortable, is bloody expensive and I've already eaten a fair way into my savings and I'm focked if I injure myself and cant work.
I know life's hard and all. Fock, I've slaved at shite jobs before to get by and I'm not afraid to roll the sleaves up and get stuck into it, but if I graduate with this next degree and find that I'm unable to make a go of it then I dont know WTF I'll do.
No, I'm not going back to school again.... I got my last degree in 91 & thought that would cary me through to retirement.....
Oh well, it could always be worse, I always say!!!!!
Education is NZ's second biggest export after sheep
pretty tradgic when you think that for each paper i do the university gets $1600. that is 4 hours a week for 16 weeks for $1600. and to think they have one lecturer for 20 students per class. they are earning $500 an hour (the university)
most of the course is such BS its not funny. i am really really disapointed in education these days. its a lame excuse to rip people off. they have 140 people per every 20 computers or somthing here, its a joke.
i guess its an international issue. (especially in the western countries where education is such a fashion)
Alltaken
True. Very true.
We're similar here in that regard.
I have no illusions regarding what is required though. I'm useless with my hands but could sell sand to the Arabs if given half-a-chance; I've got one degree but its focked because I was half-arsed with it - boozed too much etc., - so I know I'm at a crossroads with this and If I fock it up then I'll be focked for the rest of my life as there wont be a third chance regarding education.
My old man left school at the age of 17 and went into a menial type sales role. He went through that era whereby if you showed some talent a good manager - and there were plenty of good managers back then - would take you under his wing and teach you what you needed to know. He put the family into debt up to our eyeballs and bought his own business and turned it into a multi-million dollar show within 15 years which was a miracle given that it was orginally lucky to scrap together a profit of a 100 k.
I should have followed him into it when I had the chance. He's retired now and I'm semi-focked because I was too stupid to see the writing on teh wall about how the world really is. I chose uni instead and with that choice I chose disablement because all I wanted to do was party my arse off.
I look back and see much stupidity in my life. Too much, actually.
But thats long gone and this semi-fat focker is all thats left so its time to buck the chin up and get on with it and in a positive fashion too because If I cant be happy I know I'll end up blowing my head off out of disappointment.
I find it hard to understand why, and this is a problem all over the world, companies refuse to hire older people. There are, of course, the health risks but medicine is not what it was before and the experience one gains over a life-time of work cannot be replaced by any number of degrees.
It is a sad fact of life now days.....
I hear y'all. A lot of manufacturing jobs and things that have to be made using labour are going overseas for obvious reasons – in return we get cheap consumer goods. A lot of IT jobs are going to India because over there, no matter how poor you are, getting a PhD is like getting a degree is in terms of being an aim here.
Now I'm a stingy bastard, being in journalism – it's a field you can enter with no qualifications (though there are some you can get) and based off of skill. It's one of the few professions like it left in the world, though thankfully so long as there are concerned people buying tabloids I'll be in a job. Otherwise, I'm a bum with not a qualification to my name.
Problem we're facing at the moment is that all the traditional jobs are buggering off and the services sector can require specific training.
However, on the whole as an economic macro thing, this isn't so bad as we've never had such a cheap and high standard of living (yes, cheap is a relative term…) On the other hand there are guys like RC in their 50's and looking for work. Economic booms always leave people behind, and even where the chance to retrain is made available it can be a bitch when it's your third time doing it.
There is no easy answer, I suppose…
I know Jeep pays it's assembly line workers $20-$35/hr. Requirements, GED. And we wonder why the American car is so expensive?
It's not the line workers faults by any means but the company itself. They're over paying their workers... which yeah, it would have been nice had it been the 1950s when a company took care of you but today it's business over taking care of your empoyees - on the level of any major Auto maker.
A line worker should be making 15-18/hr hour after 2-3 years. Unless you're in a more skilled section.
Why should the guy who drives the finished product off the assembly line 100ft get paid $25/hr? (Jeep pays someone to do this for 10 hours a day)
That's his only job. Someone else hops in the vehicle and parks it elsewhere.
Anyone remember the Jeep shooting that happened last year? The guy was making I believe $28/hr, no education, older fellow.
Ford has been trying to take care of their workers like any other American Auto maker. It's time to start realizing that you can employee more people at less pay instead of paying less people more money.
With your education and experience you should just do temp jobs. I doubt they care how old you are and they pay half way decent.
Go into consulting..
I know my former employer, SSOE, is dying to find engineers in a lot of capacities. (www.ssoe.com)
For auto, they design the plants that build the vehicles.. check it out since they have a location in Troy.
| Quote : it's a field you can enter with no qualifications |
Locksmith, very little formal training about. Yet a good demand for skilled personnel. I have a plan for that one.
| Quote : it's a field you can enter with no qualifications |
Locksmith, very little formal training about. Yet a good demand for skilled personnel. I have a plan for that one.
Anything that's a trade over this way is in demand these days methinks.
| Quote : It's not the line workers faults by any means but the company itself. They're over paying their workers |
That and the fact that the people running the company are making millions. How many companies have said they need to reduce workforce or close plants because they arent making money, but yet are paying millions a year to higher ups.
Take HP for example. When Carlie got 'fired' from here job what did she get? $20,000,000 !!!. This was at the same time HP was laying off employees because they werent making enough money. I was one of those that got laid off.
As far as education goes and degrees, How many people have heard this: "You dont have enough experience"?
Thus the paradox, how can you get experience if no one will higher you becuase you dont have experience?
And many companies wont higher you if you dont have a degree even though you may have 5 to 10 years experience.
Pensions? Forget about them. The days of a company taking care of you for your 20-30 years of work are pretty much gone. Heck many people dont even stay with a company long enough to get a pension. 2 to maybe 4 years and their gone.
Companies dont want to "train" you anymore. If you dont have it before hand you can forget about getting the job.
I thought you only got a pension if you worked in an Union these days?
I get 401k matching but that's about it. I think the longest I plan on staying at a company at this point in time is up to 5 years. Recently it was only 2. My current company is taking care of me very well but how long will that last? Who knows.
Maybe you do have to be in a Union, I dont know. I was in one for about 1 year but never did anything with it.
401K is great as long as the stock market stays up. One good crash and were all screwed. My dad lost over 16K on the drop after 9/11. Whats going to happen if it would drop similar to what it did at the Great Depression?
Social Security is a joke. Health costs are outrageous and only going to get worse. Education is going nowhere but UP, UP, and away. Yet the number of good paying jobs are getting less and less.
I was in a restraurant yesterday and they had those Remember When cards.
1975, average income per person was like $12,000 a year. Average new car, $4,000. Tuition at Hardvard was like $3,000. Gas was $.034 or something.
Now a days, average income.. $50,000? New car? 30-35? Hardvard? 150k?
| Quote : I was in a restraurant yesterday and they had those Remember When cards.
|
That's inflation - 12,000 a year then is, essentially, 50k now. That's why they always say "In today's money..." when talking about a fortune 50 years ago. Just look at all the stuff you have now compared to what your parents had growing up and suchlike.
I guess Ford should not have bought Volvo with all that extra $$$$$$ they had. Downhill for them since.
That reminds me. Around 92 or 93. My ex and I where shopping. The two guys in the store where laughing. They where from China. They where talking about a product they where looking at. That was made in ChinaA
Right.. I know inflation. What you missed though was that the average person made $12k while the new car was $4k. Roughly 33% of their yearly income.
Today, $50k average income, $30k average new family car, or even $25k, you're at 50%.
Wages are not on par with inflation. Besides that, companies are growing because they're hoarding more money over less time because they're paying employees less. But their products go up in price.
My cousin worked for GE for a number of years in Managment. He's your age. He got axed awhile back thru GE downsizing. Now he's teaching High School.
| Quote : Right.. I know inflation. What you missed though was that the average person made $12k while the new car was $4k. Roughly 33% of their yearly income.
|
At the same time, when wages go up in industry (like car making) they send them to China.
And also, I take your point on a car costing more, but how much more of our income today is disposable? Although I take your point - in Ireland (not the UK... I know I jump between the two a lot, but our pound and their pound used to be on a fixed 1:1 conversion ratio, to give you an idea of how close we are) I believe these days we work longer than ever before without seeing the same kind of rise in wages. But at the same time, we do have an awful lot more disposable income and we're much better off than we were 10 - 15 years ago.
Actually, Ireland's big economic problems stem from the fact that we got rich too fast - the "Celtic Tiger" grew so fact, we went from a poor nation with net emigration to one of the richest in the world, per capita, in about ten years. Now the average house price is over €250k, for example.
But it is a fact of life, as you earn more you pay more, and it can get murky between which you're getting more of – bills or cheques.
Years ago I saw peice in the newspaper. MD,BS, PHD and so on. But no JOB. It gave a list of all those plus more.
What happened to the old OJT?
Consulting is good, since you need to be close to the customer. Better yet, be an analyst. It's a job that cannot be exported.
For everyone out there on this thread, I highly recommend Tom Friedman's book World is Flat.
It tells you about all the jobs that are going to India and China, and gives you a very good perspective on this entire transtion. For folks that are on this thread and are hurt by this transition, it would is a "must read".
What I fail to understand is this..
They say it's cheaper to build the cars elsewhere or export the work to be elsewhere. Ok. Makes sense.
Why do the prices keep going up then? Shouldn't they stay even, better yet, come down?
I'm slowly working towards becoming a consultant. I'm currentl a *Network Analyst* which works for me.
It's rare when someone actually recommends a book worth reading. I've heard of this book and since you brought it up, I think I'll go out and pick it up. I've heard people talk about it but no one has really explained what it's about so I didn't take much stock in it.
| Quote : What I fail to understand is this..
|
Don't you just love capitalism?
No kidding. Everyone just wants money fast these days. It might as well be a giant pyramid scheme where the rich get all the money and everyone else fails.
Pretty soon money isn't going to be the driving factor anymore at this rate. Things need to get regulated or something in common areas. Gas is regulated since everyone basically needs it. Why not regulate things that are vital to the US structure? Yeah it takes away huge mark ups and what not.. but it's getting out of hand.
How about "curbs" like the Stock Market has? That'd be nice to see.
The prices dont go down because the big wigs are pocketing all the money they save by lowering costs. thats the main reason to move a company to a different country.
When RCA moved to Mexico did the prices drop? Hell no
When GE moved their frig plant to mexico did the prices drop? Hell no.
But I can tell you for a fact that the quality of the products dropped. I was working for a semi-large appliance company at the time. After the moves we had a lot more problems with both GE and RCA. Had more DOAs, parts missing, dead product after only weeks of running.
GE was paying mexicans $8 a day compared to $15-$20 an hour in the US.
Where did all the "saved" money go to?
It truly is the downfall of this country. The stucture of this country is being outsourced to countries we can't rely on.
I was talking to someone last night and they referenced America turning in the the old Roman Empire and how it's going to collapse. Everything is going out and we're forgetting about the structure.
Greed for money is over coming the common idea that we need to stay self sufficient yet still support global operations. While businesses aren't exactly in our politics/gov't.. I think the gov't needs to step up and do something to keep at least one brand all American and can sustain the US should something come up.
Build it in the US, no business tax. That alone would generate jobs which I would assume could generate considerable tax based on the mass amount of workers being hired.
We started the year with layoffs... Roughly 60 people in the North IL area could be affected... 26 at the help desk that is closing, but that leaves another 35 jobs going bye bye... All the temps in the offices were fired, all the admins were promoted or released, many of our BD folk were moved around...
Oh, did I mention that we had record profits and sales last year...
It's all stupid...
:x
26 help desk? For computers?
How many people do 26 people support!?
Figuring 1 person should be able to support 250 users.. My current place of employment I support roughly 500 a piece but the network/PC isn't used extensively or anything.
Actaul help desk supports all of IL, KY, IN, OH, MI, and WI. I don't know how many users... We have 350 or so PC's in this building, but most of our buildings aren't this big...
There are 7 techs in our building, but we provide support from 3:00 AM until 11:30 PM, and we do have 1 remote building appx. 25 miles away, with only like 30 or so PC's.
We have 51 locations all across the US and a few in Canada. Total IT staff of 15.
5 are trainers, 7 are developers, and 3 of us handle all the hardware, servers, software, network, etc.
We support 24x7x365.
Roughly 1300 computers/3000 users.
26 seems to he a huge amount of helpdesk people. I know my local hospital system has an IT staff of 140 people to support their entire organization which has like 20,000 users and 8,000 computers in 7 locations across the city.
I hate to say it but it sounds like there might be a case of poor management and resource allocation which resulted in the layoffs..
Ok, I want to blow your mind a little
The person who takes your order at McDonald drive in (the Voice), can they be sitting in India? (this is actually happening, but so far, not outsourced to India).
The person who is actually doing your taxes (not the guy you go to, but the backroom guy) could they be in India?
What is stopping top indian surgeons from parking a cruise ship turned into a hospital off the international waters in LA, and doing a bunch of operations at 25% of the cost (and better quality).
Take TGP, where are the staff, everywhere on the globe.
The point of all this is that dynasaurs die, and that is inevitable. One has to adapt or die. A nation works exactly the same way. Ireland used to export people to America, now they export s/w and articles (Aaron, he he).
Capital will move where it will move. No government can stop that, it cannot be regulated effectively (sorry Lu Dubbs, you're barking off the wrong tree).
We get back to it. The key is education. It would actually be nice if goverments put some huge resources in education and retraining (instead of into guns, but that is another thread
), so we don't hear all the horror stories on this thread about how much it costs to go to uni. There is NO other way.
| Quote : The person who takes your order at McDonald drive in (the Voice), can they be sitting in India? (this is actually happening, but so far, not outsourced to India).
|
The McDonalds thing is possible.. but that person also has hands on duties - cleaning the floors, accepting money, etc.
While technically possible, economicly it's not feasible. But you make a vaid point without a doubt.
I think there is a law that states you have to live in the US to do taxes or something - so you can be held accountable by US laws if for tax reasons. There are hundreds of careers that can be done elsewhere for less though.
Not sure what's stopping them from parking the cruise ship. That's a good diea though. Maybe there's an international law against it or something? haha I'm sure there's some reasoning behind it.
You have good points..
I do admit though.. I like what Bush has done for the educational system though. Under Clinton, I couldn't get a penny to go to school. Under Bush, I got all the money I needed but I still had a spend a little to go to school - consider it my portion to guarentee I followed through since I had to invest my own money.
Bush has been pushing community colleges hard. I like that because it's not 4 years, it's 2 years. You can get your accounting, nursing, computers, business management and fill the gaps of the good jobs. Those who go on for 4 year degrees, Ph.D's, Masters, etc. Let them have the higher jobs.
Actually, I found out last night that my friend's wife who has her PhD is only making $33,000 a year as a professor at a university. How sad is that? The low end tech job I almost took back in '99 paid $36,000.
McDonald may outsource drive-thru orders
All of I saying that the ones who are whining should stop, since no one is going to 'protect' them. We just have to get on with the program.
Guess the one with PhD got a PhD in something that really does not matter much, otherwise she would be pulling in $100k+.
Glad that there is improvement at the college level.
PhD in business management or something like that. She teaches business courses and stuff. I guess there isn't much demand in business for someone who knows what ethics are these days.
| Quote : Call center professionals with "very strong communication skills" could help boost order accuracy and ultimately speed up the time it takes customers to get in and out of the drive-thrus, the company said.
|
Seriously now. I speak to the damn person with a 4 year degree and they still screw my orders up. I don't even use the drive through for that reason. I like to look eye to eye with the people when I order anything. Yeah, people think I'm weird cause I'll park, go in just to get my order to go. I like the little connection of standing there and talking to the person who is going to make my food. I like to see what it looks like.
How truly sad is that.. we already have 90 second drive through windows, give me a damn break. Why don't they just do call ahead so you just drive up, say your order number or name, pay and leave? Or just use a credit card over the phone.
We're filling the world with push button monkeys and morons.
Take the McDonald example...
Which one is better for the CUSTOMER?
- a minimum wage person at 10:00 PM, half sleepy, taking orders, and sweeping the floor the other half of the time
or
- a person sitting somewhere (their home?) maybe 10 PM for them is 10 AM (not sleepy), and specializing in taking such orders (and maybe having a bachelor's degree, and being more than happy that they have such a great 'opportunity').
Such jobs are going away since digital bandwidth is essentially free. You could be in India or USA, all the same from communication standpoint.
But you're still going to have that sleepy person making the food. Either way, someone still has to be physically present.
Now you're just investing in technology, call centers or equipment to answer the phones.. from a guy in India who I can't even understand on a good day.
It honestly want to see the run down on the numbers to see how much they plan on saving and how much they're going to speed their 90 second line up.
There are 1275 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.
You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.
