Archived from groups: alt.comp.periphs.mainboard.asus (
More info?)
Thanks Roger, for your quick reply!
I spent the last couple of hours crawling under my desk, and here are a
few observations:
> First comment, you should never run a PC PSU without load.
Thanks! I didn't know that. Hopefully the old PS was not damaged. At
least all voltages were correct last time I checked them...
> The -12v line on many machines is not used at all by the motherboard
> (it is not one of the main regulated lines from the switcher), the
> only thing left on a modern machine that may use it is the serial
> port, and many do not.
I'm pretty sure it's used for serial on mine, because one of the symptoms
I had with old PS - my PC could not communicate with GPS, which is
connected through a serial port.. read on on this...
> The -5v rail is also generally not used (it was
> originally a bias voltage for the memory, that was required on older
> systems). These two rails are possibly alone, in normally using a
> seperate linear regulator chip, and not relying on the main switching
> inverter. The -5v is often derived from the -12v, which explains the
> behaviour on the new supply.
Ok, from this I can derive that whatever is going on is affecting the
PS's ability to generate appropriate voltage, rather than it being lost
somewhere between PS and the sensor. Correct me if I'm wrong.
> Some PCI cards do use this rail. Try
> running without any PCI cards. Unplug the SBLive card first. This is
> one of the few cards that used a reasonable current on the -12v rail,
> and my first suspicion would be that the audio amp chip on this has
> blown, and is overloading the regulator on the -ve rail. I don't know
> about the 'TV Wonder' card (some UHF modulators use these rails), so
> if removing the SB, does not let the rail run as it should, try this
> next.
I unplugged all PCI cards one by one starting with SB then TV Wonder.
Nothing changed. Still getting -2V... Now a few other things that did
change between the old and new power supplies, which I observed why
messing around:
1. I am now able to use the serial port even with -2v. Something that
didn't work on the old PS, while it was providing less than -1v. In fact,
while I was downloading a track from GPS, the voltage dropped to -1.91,
and reverted back to -2 afterwards. This tells me that indeed that -12
rail is used for serial port... And that -2v is enough for it to operate
but not -0.86...
2. SoundBlaster is also usable now (I had no sound when -12v dropped down
on old PS). However, it seems to output less power than before. I can't
tell for sure, but I used to have to set the main volume control to about
second mark from the bottom to avoid getting red bars on the stereo
system through witch it outputs sound. Now I had to slide it all the way
up. But it's not main concern, since I don't have a way to really measure
that, or maybe I'm even wrong about what was before. But sometimes
(usually right after reboot) it does this: System comes up, the welcome
sound is played (normally). Then, as soon as things finish loading I
start playing an mp3 file using winamp. The first 1/2 a second is played
at normal volume, and then it drops dramatically, so that I can only
barely hear. Closing winamp and re-opening it gets normal sound again...
Sooooo... if it is the Sound Blaster giving me trouble it may have
already burned something and now just fooling around. Other thing I did -
pulled out the SB and enabled onboard sound chip. No problems with sound
at all, although I still have to pull the volume slider all the way up.
3. When rebooting I noticed that hardware monitor did not complain. So, I
broke into the BIOS set-up and looked there. It showed a perfect -12.33v
on that one (with old PS it still showed -0.86 when rebooting and
triggered error). As soon as the system booted up and MBM loaded - it
shows -2.03v +/- 0.1 (mostly minus).
4. Not related to new PS, but while digging inside the case I noticed
that the North Bridge fan is dead. Since it's not supposed to be involved
with -12v, I suppose it won't affect this problem, if I understand your
explanation about nothing on MB using that -12v -- but I'm including this
observation just in case.
So in the end, I have to ask myself this question: did I ever have that
dreaded -12v at full power on my PC? If everything seems to work (apart
from strange SB behavior with that sudden output drops that sometimes
occur), then maybe it's been that way for a while now? But something made
it drop to unacceptable levels, and I am pretty certain it happened if
not suddenly, then at pretty fast rate, because I never had problems
communicating with GPS or using sound until that one day last week when
both problems showed up...
I am still open to all and any suggestions, as to what would be the next
step to try apart from starting to look for a new MB (and if the later
will solve the problem, provided that some of the peripherals may be
responsible here).
Thanks again for any help!
LEM
(NG reply preferred. For correct e-mail address remove all digits)