So I put a bid on this house this morning. I did walk through, figuring it needs $12k in cosmetic repairs - carpet, hardwood floor, redo bathroom, replace doors, trim work. Nothing major.
The houses around it sold in 2000 for $120k. This house happens to be foreclosed and very deeply discounted. Asking price is $99,900.
Cool. The listing agency calls me back to ask me if I know who a certain fella is. I have no clue who he is. They proceed to fill me in without asking if I really wanted to know:
From the article: (from 1999)
| Quote : Between Tuesday afternoon and Thursday morning, police believe, Thomas Craft murdered his wife, Lynette, and dismembered her body. Then, they say, he loaded the parts into a vehicle and drove north to Washtenaw County from their home in Swanton, Ohio, west of Toledo. Just west of Ann Arbor, along I-94 in Scio Township, police believe, Craft, 36, began dropping pieces of his wife's corpse in trash bins along the freeway between Zeeb and Baker roads. At about 10:30 a.m. |
Who cares what the previous owners did in it?
| Quote : Who cares what the previous owners did in it? |
You and I both think that. But the female mind doesn't. I'm targeting reselling to a family since the size of the house and everything in it. I have to disclose this information to the potential buyers. That can drive people away.
I mean, seriously. This guy murdered his wife and hacked her up in the house. Do you know how many people I know that don't like to go into a house where their grandparents had passed away naturally?
All the neighbors moved in 2000 after it happened, so the area is new. The girl I was talking to last night at the bar asked me why I was in the area since she lived right down the street. I told her I was looking at a house there and all that. She didn't mention it nor seemed to know about it.
I figure if it happened in '99 and I turn to sell in '08/'09, it's old news and no one will care. But I'm looking for opinions on the ability to sell this house.
i say if someone ecides not to buy the house because of that information, you should:
hack them into pieces with a hatchet and bury them under the house...
Hell no! I just bought a house not to long ago and all the lady stuff was in it. She died in a nursing home. My mother, sister, girl friend and self all had the creeps like a presents. I didn’t care too much to work on the house alone, especially in the basement. My brother just came up from CA. and as he walked up the stairs in the basement said he seen someone standing in the door way. I personally think if you think you are possessed, then you are. I try as hard as hell to say I’m not and keep my mind busy and not to think of any weird shit. If there is more out there I sure as hell don’t want to see it. What is this house appraised at? A super deal would be to pick it up for half of what the house could sell for. Say it could sell for $120 k, then $60 would be a super deal. If you had to sell the house the next day, would you be able to get your money back, hell why not make a profit.
Make an offer for 80k.
The house, in good repair, is worth $150-$160k easily.
The houses around it are of the same size, sold for $120ks in 2000. The area is expanding and growing fast, an average house out there now costs $200k to build, as of last year. That's also in a new development.
I'm attempting to pick it up for $90k as the asking price was $99,900.
The benefit to this house is that it's the only house in the cul de sac with a pool - inground pool at that, in great shape. The backyard is fenced in and faces an open field which may later be developed. A few hundred yards out is one of NW Ohio's largest metroparks in full view.
I have on hand approximately $15k to dispose of into this house. Total would be $105k if I get it at $90k. Value of the house at that point would easily be $155 to $170k.
I was told 3 bids have been put in, one yesterday, 2 today. I put my bid in today and I strongly suspect one of my bids to be one of the two submitted today. Others are still able to back out after finding out about the murder. I believe anyone buying this home is looking to do the exact same thing I am, fix it up, turn for a sale in 2-4 years.
Having the person murdered there doesn't really bother me. I mean, people die all the time. So this guy hacked her up and blood was everywhere. Someone else lived there for 4 years and had all the work done.
They were foreclosed and trashed the place. I have to replace all the carpet except in one room. I'm going to put Pergo floors in the kitchen and living room. Repaint the entire inside with high quality/long lasting paint. Invest $1500 into the bathroom alone. Redo the kitchen and add brand new, above midrange appliances into the house. Along with that, nothing we be below midrange since this area tends to be upper middle class.
That is, if my bid is accepted on this house.
I have my game plan, I have the money, the time, and everything accept the bank's Yes.
| Quote : i say if someone ecides not to buy the house because of that information, you should:
|
That sounds like a good buy, particularly if you feel that there's only 12 k in cosmetic changes needed to be made. Remember though, the best estimate is often 20-50% less than what is actually required.
Forget the other shit that went down. Some crime loving freak who is 'fascinated' by sadistic crime in 2015 might want to give you half-a-mil for the joint; even if somebody doesn't, that sounds like a terrific buy.
Thats only $125 000 Aus dollars or so. Crikeys thats cheap. Super cheap!
There's not a joint here under 200k. Not one.
If you are cool with the past history (I would not be), then all is cool.
Since the house is trashed, I would not limit myself to inspectors (who don't know much). I would spend a few hundred bucks and take someone over who is a building contractor, handyman, or something. You never know what lies below that carpet (dry rot, etc. etc.).
The good thing is that if you find some serious stuff that was not stated, you can most likely have that cost deducted in escrow.
I'd post the link to the house but it expired on Thursday for it's listing.
The house was built in '74. The roof is good, I've been up in the attic looking around. Bi-level so the lower level is actually a room and all.
No electric or gas on in the house but the water heater appears to be in working order.
All the carpet has been removed except for in the closests. They removed it upon leaving. No serious drywall damage. Roof is water tight.
I can see all the floor from top and bottom. Outside of the house is vinyl in excellent condition.
I priced out the carpeting per room with good quality padding. That alone came out to $6k but the lower level wouldn't need carpet, dropping it down to $5k. The bathroom will need $1500 for a new vanity, 3 piece tub surround, toilet, and tiling in the floor.
Kitchen cabinets, lower, need replaced or repaired. Repairs would be cheap since it's just the roller tracks that need fixed. They're plastic and broken, not a big deal.
Spackle the small knicks in the wall, fresh coat of a primer/Kils and then a good quality paint, I was looking at stuff around $60-75 a gallon for most rooms - quality that will last.
New deck outside which I didn't include in inital repairs, plus a filter and pump for the pool, also not included.
A few other things.. but roughly $12k for initial, $15-$20k to make it perfect condition. I figure it's a 2 years project for myself.
Cool. Don't know the soil condition in the area, but do take a marble ball and let it roll on the floor (luckily no carpets). If it stands still, cool...
Looks like a good deal. Make sure there are no disclosure requirements of what happened, otherwise you have to discount the price you will sell it at by some amount if/when you sell.
Rise, you sound handy with your hands and Tomsmart has made a small fortune fixing joints up and selling them for a profit.
I have to tell you, that sounds like a helluva deal. If you're into renovating and dont mind a little bit of project management when it comes to tradeys then for sure, get that place bought!
When do you find out?
It's actually built up on higher ground.. a few hundred yards away there is a small creek/stream that runs by.. I'd say it's about 15 feet above the water line.. water table isn't a problem. it's a low one.
Quick look over the concrete floors doesn't show any signs of cracks, no cracking or seperation in the drywall, driveway and garage have no cracks.. looks fairly flat for the most part.. not much I can do in the area though if it's slightly off. slab foundation since it's a bilevel, ground is fairly sound though.
My dad was good doing anything crafty.. I haven't actually touched anything in a while but I'm one of those people that picks up things really fast and can go with it.
I've watched drywalling.. it can be a pain but it's really not that bad. My friend's dad was a finished carp. and taught me how to do things, putting them into practice will be different.. I used to work at an engineering firm that used to do commercial projects. A lot of those guys were once in the trades and I learned a lot of things and how to do them.
I dated a girl and her dad was a 3rd generation master plumber.. his grandfather was one of the first plumbers in this area.. I learned a thing or two there.
My dad is excellent with electrical wiring.. I know someone who does everything basically.
You don't get anywhere working everyday.. I figure if I can pick this up, spend 2 years working my ass off on it.. I can make some money and pick up another house and have smaller payments on it, more cash on hand to do the job quicker.. maybe even pay for other things to get done. Start rolling that cash around.. start getting in the good areas.
I don't want to do it for life.. but I do want a strong nest egg and start investing in the stock market a little bit more. I'm in a good area where I can pick up a good area house for cheap and easily pull $30-50k profits.
One fella picked up a house on the river for $120k. Turned around selling it for $475k 6 months later. Had cash on hand to hire someone to do all the work with him and get it done. Probably easily made $150k on that deal.
Real Estate is the way to go...
You're buying it as an investment. The profit is all you care about. Forget the history. As long as you get it a bit cheaper due to the fact that the value will be diminished by that history.
You're going to have so much fun on Halloween in that joint. I'll come up and help you decorate it. I'll be the crazy husband with a hacksaw and you can be the wife all bloody in a bathtub screaming her head off. We'll get some black lights, some dry ice, and we'll chase people up and down the street throwing candy at them.
I hope you're buying a new tub too btw. Is that the 3 piece tub surround thing?
Is this a small town? If it is then old news never dies.
You plan to put $15 k into it, how do you know it’s not going to be more, by the sound of your spending. What about the unknown that may come up. Do you have to pay taxes on the house? What will that cost for two years. Will you have a water bill? What about electric and heat? Are you going to insure it? Pay anybody to work with you? Pay anybody to do jobs, like professionals. Not to mention the taxes you will have to pay when selling, also the agents commission. With all this included I don’t see much left over for profit, unless you get more then $160 say like $200. But that’s just me. These other bidders are they investor or people that want to live there? Meaning owners will pay more, while investors will try to steal it.
You're an odd one.
Most of the stuff you pointed out is the basic stuff to cover. I've already ran through all that stuff but I'll cover with you for information.
You're required to insure a house, at least her. Insurance is around $400 a year.
Taxes have been rolled into the escrow account, as is standard practice almost anywhere in the US to my knowledge.
Water bill yes, roughly $45 every 3 months. Electric and heat you can call the respective companies and get the last 12-24 months of their service. Also has a woodburner in the house to help reduce costs. After 12 months you can get onto a budget where they take a flat cost year round instead of having a high gas bill in the winter and next to nothing in the summer.
Here's the trick in Ohio, not sure what other states have this. If I buy a house and turn around and sell it within 5 years of the date of purchase, I keep all profits tax free. So I pay 3-7% for my realtor, closing, and listing fees.
I buy it for $90k, invest $15-20k in this house, turn around and sell it in 3 years for $160k. Very feasible and the only reason I'm continuing to look at this property. That's pushing me to $50k in profits before paying a realtor and any fees. In the absolute worst case I pay 7% and give up 10-11k of my 50k for realtor fees. That's all negotiable at listing time though.
I'm going in as an investor. I can invest up to $20k into the house before I have to start worrying about money.
I've walked through enough houses with professionals and have had next to everything pointed out. I've taken them through some really bad houses so they can point everything out. There is no major work needed on this house, I suspect a new roof within the next few years though.
Windows are in great shape, wood with vinyl covering which insulates well and doesn't warp, also double panes, not insulated glass (which sucks anyhow).
I can see the foundation without a problem and know there is no structural damage or concerns there. The ground is clay based. Excellent to build on.
I don't expect to find hardly anything hidden. 200amp breaker, wiring from the mid 70s, plumbing is mostly PVC, etc. This house was not built as a middle class home, it was more towards a upper middle class to low high class. This I can tell based on the woodwork in the house and the quality of materials used.
It'll be my step to get into redoing houses part time and retire before Tom's ripe age.
My thoughts exactly but every female I've talked to on it freaks out when they hear someone was killed there. That'll be the problem when selling as I have to disclose the murder.
It' a 3 piece surround, jetted tub. It was added in by the people who bought the place in 2000 since the motor to pump the jets is dated later 2000. Might still be in working order so I could clean it up, test it out, and replace with another jetted tub. They're only $500-600 though which would be a good investment for the bathroom.
| Quote : My thoughts exactly but every female I've talked to on it freaks out when they hear someone was killed there. That'll be the problem when selling as I have to disclose the murder. |
Just trying to help if i can. So you’re saying you put in $115 and sell for $170 and profit $55. A profit of $55 on $115 is ok in my book, but not great. And this isn’t figuring in any of the other things that will eat at the profit. And this is assuming $170 isn’t a bloated selling price. Not to mention the one minor small detail of someone got cut up in the house. You say after $20 k you may have to start worrying. Is this going to be a second house for you to take care of? Just saying that maybe you should start to worry now.
I also didn’t figure interest you will pay.
How’s the insurance there. Here if you don’t live in the house the insurance just about doubles.
Profit is profit
it's go no matter what the dollar amount is
| Quote : Profit is profit |
The lady that bought my house before me was thinking the same thing, until she lost the house to foreclosure.
To swim with the sharks you have to be a shark or you get eating by the sharks.
profit isn't profit at all.
If you make $5 and I make $100,000 in the same amount of time are you saying that's ok? 8O
With a first home Mike needs to maximize his profit as much as humanly possible.
of course it's not ok
but who's gonna make only a 5 buck profit on a house common be realistic here
I'm saying that making even a 20k profit is pretty damn good in my books, that leaves you some extra cash to start again witha new house, pretty much free cash for new upgrades and additions which in turn will generate even MORE profit if you go all out and high end in the second
If you want to be realistic you can also lose money, espeiciely if you pay to much for a house.
Steve's rule: only buy houses that have 'curable' problems.
Uncurable problems:
-people being cut up, and small town remembering it-- bad for renting it or selling it
-bad location, which is not getting better
-bad earth
-bad economy in the area
There must be at least hundreds of houses one can choose from. Why bother with a incurable problem for a few bucks of savings? Forclosures/bargains are coming up all the time if one does the homework, or expand the geography just a tad.
Site note: You said females get the creeps. Well, the next person buying/renting this house would will likely have a female as the influencer.
There's gotta be some data on this type of issue. Generally, how much does a murder devalue a home? Does a full renovation help?
I would find that out. I doubt it's 25% so if he's thinking it's worth at least $120,000 now and he put a $90,000 bid in he should be in good shape.
Nonetheless, a house is a massive investment so I would find out what experiences other people have had.
| Quote : There's gotta be some data on this type of issue. Generally, how much does a murder devalue a home? Does a full renovation help? Hehe
|
Figuring to buy a house for $90k, invest $15k into it - total of $105k total and sell for $160-170 in 3 years? That's a nice profit considering.
At $160, that's $55k in profit, minus closing costs in most cases.
Everyone in the area moved away that previously lived there. The town is small but the 23 year old girl (who would have been a senior in high school in 2000) and lives within a mile of the house didn't even have a clue about it.
I need to state that that the police 'think' the murder happened in the house. When the house was searched within 2 days of the murder, they found no blood, nothing that would say a murder happened there. The police had no proof but because the guy crossed into Michigan, they "believe" the murder happened at the house in Ohio. If you cross state lines, it becomes Federal and they can pursue the death penalty on the guy.
Honestly, I don't think the murder happened in the house. I would imagine he got her in the car and killed her out in the country where he could dismember her and dispose of body parts anywhere. Which is my theory as to why they were not able to find any blood in the house.
It's up to speculation if she was killed in the house.
As far the house goes.. considering some of the more expensive homes run for about $400-600k for 5-8k sq ft, making that kind of profit in my area is a good amount to make. We have our 1-2-3 million dollar homes that are 3-4 stories, all brick, 5 car garages on 5 acres of land with perfect landscaping. I'm easily eyeing 40-50k profit.
A new house the size of this one, plus the inground pool (which isn't common since it's all clay in the area) easily runs $200k including land.
House insurance is about $400 year and I will be living in it and doing a lot of the work myself. I will be installing the hardwood Pergo floors but will have someone install the carpet for me. I can handle most of the work and have several contractor friends ready to lend a hand in it.
The area is targeting more retired or wealthier families. Ones that have the kids, want the good school district, want away from the city and who tend to work at home or travel for work a lot. Other places of similar houses and what not have twice the taxes. This house has $700/half in taxes, other places are $1100-$1400/half alone on a $100k house.
I definitely would not buy the house. Think about it, why are they selling it for $90,000.00 . Don't you think that if they could get 160K by putting $15,000.00 into it they would buy it themselves?
I think the freak out meter is just too high on this one. If the real estate agent thought it would sell than they would have Bought it themselves at that price.
These $400k and $600 houses are they on the same street or block? Different areas have different value of course and the difference in taxes seems to show this. You should only be concern with the house near by and I would do a check on the houses and see what they sold for previous times, also what the house is appraised at?
I have to admit you paint a pretty picture, but I personally am still skeptical of the whole situation. If you do get the house I would have your layer put in a weasel clause in for you can back out if you decide to.
Buy it. If you can't make a profit on it then I'll limit your loss by buying it back of you for 70% of what you pay.[/personal favour]
And I was hoping you'd have some good input into this... I knew it, you're a flake.
That rumor about you really working at a grocery store as a bagger is true, isn't it??
I have it pending inspection which is something you should always ask for. That way, you can back out if you don't like that you'll have to paint a wall or you don't like the carpet color.
The house is bank owned. The people who bought it before bought the house cheap, for $94k in 2000. The houses around it which were in good condition, all sold for $120k. 6 years later at the going rate of 6-7% appreciation in that particular area, do the math.
This house sold for less because of all the remodeling that needed done. The house is still in the process of being remodeled but based on what I can tell from the previous owners, they were on the trashy side - items found in the backyard and through the house, writings on the walls of rooms. They had at least one teenage son who liked to spray paint drawings and words in the garage and another room.
It's a lot of work which is why I believe it's going for what it is - it's a bank owned property - they bought the house for $64,200 December 2005. That's all that the previous owners owed. They're asking $99,900 because it's a big profit for them and a good portion lower in the area.
I've given you my serious opinion on buying before. Just buy bit to stop wasting cash on rent. I've just grabbed one for 37K needs 12K of work, I know it will sell for 58-60K. Work should take about 8 weeks. All work will be done by builders I regularly supply work for(would be charging others 15k for same job) , no need to pay them up front, always a winner when a bit stretched. Also have my eye on a few here. I'll have to see what they go for on Thursday.
Even with the money conversion, I wish I could pick something up that cheap and turn around to sell for a $10-20k profit.
If I were to pick something up for $60-80k, it's not in a good area, even with repairs, turning around to sell won't be easy and most likely won't yield a profit.
For example, my father lives in a good neighborhood but it's slowly going down hill. The nieghbor's house is 2 doors away from an elementary school. In other areas, the house should go for around $90k. But because the area is going downhill, they're trying to sell the house for $64k.
There are 3 'attached' suburbs to buy in but taxes are insane to keep out the trash. The area I'm looking in is more secluded and away from the city by about 18 miles. Good school district and the work should only take to mid-summer to have fixed - basically I need the summer to get the pool working. The inside I suspect should take 4 weeks for all carpeting, wood flooring, and the bathroom. A 4-8 weeks to patch up the walls, paint, and add in decor. A lot of this I'll do on my own because I have more time than money and I wouldn't mind living there. I don't need to turn an immediate profit.
Would you turn profit at all though? They're selling it cheap for a reason, would you have to do the same down the road?
There was a serial killer that lived in my old neighbourhood. He didn't kill anyone while he lived there though. He was well known in Canada, so they had problems selling the house. They just tore it down after a long time of being vacant.....
Memories fade, all the neighbors are new. I'm checking into if I have to disclose the information after X amount of years and since it's up to speculation that the murder might have happened there, that I have to disclose it.
I'm also checking to see if the only reason it was disclosed to me was because it's a bank owned property. I'm checking all the legal sides. I know that if I have to disclose it and I don't, I'm up for a lawsuit, granted that I had to disclose information about the house.
Have the people that are trying to sell you the house told you anything about it?
That could be an answer right there. If they are the ones that told you about the murder, then they were probably forced by law to tell you. I don't know of any realtor that would use that as their selling tactic.
It's bank owned in which they have the history of it. They know what the place is worth and what not. I have my realtor checking into finding out if that needs to be disclosed or not at the time of sale or if there is a time limit associated to it.
Or if the guy is in jail outside the state if I have to disclose it, etc.
All the neighbors are new and I haven't talked to them yet until my bid is approved.
I hope it works out for you whatever you decide. Just make absolutely sure that you know what you're getting into beforehand. Also ask about resale value increase and decrease.
I don't know about anywhere else, but in Ontario you get a higher resale value on homes if you've made moderate changes to a home you've lived in for minimum one year. Before a year you don't get anything back and after a year isn't worth it.
The house is already under-value. If in good condition it will sell for the same amount as the houses around it.
Add in carpet, wood floor, etc. I can turn and sell for whatever I want within any amount of time- which I want to do within 5 years to avoid taxation.
Most people I believe are passing it up because of the amount of work/money that needs to go into it to really bring it up to a liveable standard.
Fortunately, I talked to my brother who will let me live with him for a few weeks while I get the place fixed up..
But I don't know even where my Bid on this house stands and I have all this discussion on the place!
Banks are closed today for the holiday so I figure I find out Tuesday or Wednesday and work is switching up all my travel dates.
oh that's right, you have a holiday in the States. I forgot.
If it's just the amount of work that's making the sale value so low and not the area or the history, then I say go for it. Still look into it, but it doesn't sound like a bad idea. Make sure you plan out how much it's all going to cost to fix and add a few thousand onto that total. Older houses often have hidden problems that don't come up until after you start repairs. You don't want to fall short on money and end up finishing the house after your 5 year goal.
Regarding disclosure, if the laws are not black and white, then I suspect if it ever goes to court, the court is going to say hey you knew such an important thing and you did not write it down. Also you had it disclosed to you, and you did not disclose it to the next buyer.
I think in this matter, the gray area would not work for you. Not a lawyer, but my gut feel.
My house I bought for $12k and is a three unit. It took about a year and $8k to get all ready. I collect rent and live for FREE. A year ago they were trying to get $65k for it. I got it for $12. It’s appraised at $52k I wouldn’t take less then $50k for it, but why sell its good income. I got a line on it instead for $42k. Again I paid $12k. Another house I paid $5k, it’s appraised at $32 and would sell for $25k. I put $3,500 into it. I’ll rent it and it will pay for it’s self in a year and a half. A friend bought a Brand New House for $65k, worth $150. Did I mention it was brand new and never lived in. Great deals are out there. If you said you were paying $65k I would think that was a better deal, accept for the shit that happens and this is if you could get $160 for it. I do with you the best thought.
I wish I could find something that cheap in a good area. I can buy a $20k house but in 2 years it might be worth $15k or $22k. Depending on if any shootings or major drug deals go down
The area I'm looking at has one of the best school districts, the whole city is good to live in, virtually no crime, closer to the airport, a huge state park next to it, plus two major highways right there.
I'm paying mainly for the land and location, not the physical structure.
| Quote : My house I bought for $12k and is a three unit. It took about a year and $8k to get all ready. I collect rent and live for FREE. A year ago they were trying to get $65k for it. I got it for $12. It’s appraised at $52k I wouldn’t take less then $50k for it, but why sell its good income. I got a line on it instead for $42k. Again I paid $12k. Another house I paid $5k, it’s appraised at $32 and would sell for $25k. I put $3,500 into it. I’ll rent it and it will pay for it’s self in a year and a half. A friend bought a Brand New House for $65k, worth $150. Did I mention it was brand new and never lived in. Great deals are out there. If you said you were paying $65k I would think that was a better deal, accept for the shit that happens and this is if you could get $160 for it. I do with you the best thought. |
Are those numbers accurate or do you mean $650,000, $120,000, etc?
When did you get a $5000 and $12,000 house? Even my parents never got a house that cheap. I think my grandparents got one for $6000 but that was 60+ years ago.
Just called my parents. They bought their first house in 1973 for $30,000. They bought their second house in 1974 for $75,000.
I forgot to ask about my grandparents but I'm fairly sure they had one for $6,000.
For those prices, I think I could be pick up a shanty with a tin roof..
Unless he's talking about years ago.. An acre of farm land here is $2500, just for residential it's $7k.
There are 1340 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.
You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.

