G
Guest
Guest
Archived from groups: alt.comp.hardware.homebuilt (More info?)
Both Dell and an experminter have apparently found that
vent holes in a flat plate, such as at the front of an
electronic enclosure (i.e. PC case) produce turbulence
in the entering air. This turbulence can be used to aid
in bringing the air that flows through the case into better
contact with the surfaces of warm component inside the
case.
DELL SERVERS
Take a look at the Dell PowerEdge servers:
<http://www1.us.dell.com/content/products/productdetails.aspx/pedge_400sc?c=us&c
s=04&l=en&s=bsd&~tab=viewstab>
<http://www1.us.dell.com/content/products/productdetails.aspx/pedge_1600sc?c=us&
cs=04&l=en&s=bsd&~tab=viewstab>
If you prefer .pdf files and shorter links, here they are again:
<http://www.dell.com/downloads/global/products/pedge/en/400sc_specs.pdf>
<http://www.dell.com/downloads/global/products/pedge/en/1600sc_specs.pdf>
Those bezels (fascias) are plastic. Those circular vent holes weren't put
there
to maximize flow - there would be a smooth intake ramp for the air if minimal
air resistance were the goal. Those circular vent holes weren't sized to
minimize
escaping Electromagnetic Interference (EMI) because the bezels are *plastic*
and any EMI would go right through them regardless of the size or shape of the
holes. Those circular vent holes are there to maximize TURBULENCE of the
air entering the case.
Why don't all of Dell's desktop computers have a bank of circular vent
holes in their bezels? Because the turbulence emits white sound, i.e. noise.
Noise is more expected and tolerable coming from a server (which can be
in a dedicated closet) rather than from a workstation sitting on one's
work desk.
AN EXPERIMENTER'S EXPERIENCE
But what evidence is there at all that the turbulence produced by circuler
vent holes in a flat plate aid in cooling? How about this:
http://www.benchtest.com/way2cool3.html
In the above project, the author notices that with the front bezel off and
a box obstructing the front intake fan, the temperatures inside the case drop.
He later finds that 1/4" holes drilled on the edges of the bezel cause the
temperatures inside the case to be one-to-two degrees lower with the bezel
on than with bezel off!
The author has no clear idea why "obstructing" the air intake would lower
temperatures, but could it be turbulence? With the box, the air velocity is
increased parallel to the face of the chassis, forcing it to make a sharp right
angle turn as it enters the fan. With the holes drilled in the bezel, more
turbulence is generated in the incoming air than with no bezel in place. It
seems pretty clear that this author has discovered exactly what Dell and some
heatsink manufacturers have discovered - that turbulent air cools better than
smoothly flowing air.
*TimDaniels*
Both Dell and an experminter have apparently found that
vent holes in a flat plate, such as at the front of an
electronic enclosure (i.e. PC case) produce turbulence
in the entering air. This turbulence can be used to aid
in bringing the air that flows through the case into better
contact with the surfaces of warm component inside the
case.
DELL SERVERS
Take a look at the Dell PowerEdge servers:
<http://www1.us.dell.com/content/products/productdetails.aspx/pedge_400sc?c=us&c
s=04&l=en&s=bsd&~tab=viewstab>
<http://www1.us.dell.com/content/products/productdetails.aspx/pedge_1600sc?c=us&
cs=04&l=en&s=bsd&~tab=viewstab>
If you prefer .pdf files and shorter links, here they are again:
<http://www.dell.com/downloads/global/products/pedge/en/400sc_specs.pdf>
<http://www.dell.com/downloads/global/products/pedge/en/1600sc_specs.pdf>
Those bezels (fascias) are plastic. Those circular vent holes weren't put
there
to maximize flow - there would be a smooth intake ramp for the air if minimal
air resistance were the goal. Those circular vent holes weren't sized to
minimize
escaping Electromagnetic Interference (EMI) because the bezels are *plastic*
and any EMI would go right through them regardless of the size or shape of the
holes. Those circular vent holes are there to maximize TURBULENCE of the
air entering the case.
Why don't all of Dell's desktop computers have a bank of circular vent
holes in their bezels? Because the turbulence emits white sound, i.e. noise.
Noise is more expected and tolerable coming from a server (which can be
in a dedicated closet) rather than from a workstation sitting on one's
work desk.
AN EXPERIMENTER'S EXPERIENCE
But what evidence is there at all that the turbulence produced by circuler
vent holes in a flat plate aid in cooling? How about this:
http://www.benchtest.com/way2cool3.html
In the above project, the author notices that with the front bezel off and
a box obstructing the front intake fan, the temperatures inside the case drop.
He later finds that 1/4" holes drilled on the edges of the bezel cause the
temperatures inside the case to be one-to-two degrees lower with the bezel
on than with bezel off!
The author has no clear idea why "obstructing" the air intake would lower
temperatures, but could it be turbulence? With the box, the air velocity is
increased parallel to the face of the chassis, forcing it to make a sharp right
angle turn as it enters the fan. With the holes drilled in the bezel, more
turbulence is generated in the incoming air than with no bezel in place. It
seems pretty clear that this author has discovered exactly what Dell and some
heatsink manufacturers have discovered - that turbulent air cools better than
smoothly flowing air.
*TimDaniels*