First of all you should take a poll to tally which one is the favorite card amongst gamers and alike. That way you have an idea of what the popular or most desirable brand of graphics card.
Okay, I would go with BFG as I have been using them since the 6200 AGP back in the day. Their cards are pretty stable and with lifetime warranty, so I have no fear of just pushing my cards to the limit with all settings at high. It's been my favorite brand since then and have never use another brand other than ATI's.