Tom's Hardware: Over 1.4 million members in 6 different countries available to answer all your high-tech questions. Sign up now! Its free!
Word :    Username :           
 

1 will you lose performence if i only have 3 sticks or ram on a motherboard with dual-channel technology than just 2 sticks or 4 sticks

2 what is the difference: PC2 4200 and PC2 4300 (these are DDR2)

2 if my computer has PC2 4300, and i add (mix) PC2 4200 in the system, will i lose performence?

Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.

I have no experience with DDR2 (yet) but as far as I know running 3 sticks is no different than running 2 or 4 if they are the same brand, speed etc... Although I am sure there are some people who will like to work in matched pairs etc...

If you have PC2-4300 and put PC2-4200 in your system in conjunction, you will lose performance (although gain performance due to larger capacity - why don't you just get more 4300?). You can't run different speeds on different slots.

Reply to mesarectifier
- 0 +

You will probably take a nominal performance hit, but it won't be noticeable enough to matter. Maybe 2-5% in frames, at the most. Just make sure to check the specs from the motherboard to be sure it will work with a single stick, which it should, but you never know.

Reply to bweir
- 0 +

Dropping a third stick into a dual channel system is DUMB because it will stop dual channel from working!

In order for DC to work, there must be an even number of memory sticks, and they must be in the correct slots.

You'll be dropping your theoretical bandwidth from 6.4GB/s down to 3.2GB/s.

Reply to Mobius

Does that mean that Dual-Channel only works when there is an even number of sticks installed?

I swear it works with just one stick, but I've never worked directly with it so I'm not sure so correct me if I'm wrong.

Reply to mesarectifier

I don't think you can run dual channel with 3 sticks of memory, you need matching sticks in corresponding slots, if three slots are occupied that third stick doesn't have anything in the corresponding slot and can't be run in dual channel, since the two channels are not equal anymore. Resulting in single channel operations and much less memory bandwidth.

Reply to theboomboomcars

y thanks guys, this is alot better than dell forums

4300 cost more that 4200 but they run at the same speed


from the replies, i will go with buying 2 4300s, each 256, then my system will be 1 gig mem and i will disable virtual memory, i dont want the system writing on my HDD

Reply to derek101700

1. running 3 sticks of ram is a bad choice. the best config for winxp-32bit is 2 1GB dimms in dual channel operation. note. dual channel need 2 gigs of the same type of ram. they do not need to be matched pairs but it helps. runninig 3 sticks may also prevent you from using 1t command rate. i'm not sure on that though as ia haven't used ddr2. thg had an article about ddr2 recently so do a quick article search.

2. with ddr pc3200 means that it has a bandwidth of 3200MB/S. if the same is true of DDR2 4300 will have a 100MB bandwidth advantage over pc4200.

3. afaik ram always runs at the speed of the slowest ram. the performance loss would hardly be noticable in real world situations.


finally don't trust me as im a noob :P

Reply to strangestranger
Tom's Hardware > Forum > CPU & Components > Other Components > ram
Go to:

There are 634 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Please mind

You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.

Add a reply Cancel
Sponsored links
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them