Since you guys probably get tonnes of upgrade threads I thought I'd present my anguish, as I try to pick the perfect Budget Non-Linear Editing Computer, in the form of a poem.
Before the poem a note of my source of inspiration...
Everyone is talking about fast nowadays, all the reviewers and reviews forecast OCing ability almost in the first page of their reviews. Now there is nothing wrong with that but what about speed AND stability? I don't want a computer that can chug a few months at the highest of high speeds and spit out the biggest benchmarks and then have to be underclocked the rest of its' life due to damage and instability.
I'm trying to build a Budget Non-Linear Editing Rig for Digital Video and everywhere I read is about speed and ability to overclock but I hardly read anything about long term usage that requires speed and stability. Which set-up is better to Upgrade for Stable Speed...
... and now my epic poem...
~ The Upgrade for Stable Speed ~
If overclocking is not for me - And stability is the key
For the love of computer gods - What are my best odds:
For trouble free operations - Seemless component cooperation
No show stopping exasperations - And no frigg'n catastrophications
I wish I could spend - One hundred ga-thousa-tillion dollars
Mr. Gates if ya wanna buy me a computer - Just gimme a holler
So after counting my pennies - And obssessing over performance benchies
I have it down to two, but only one can make
My Digital Video Non-Linear Editing Dreams come true...
.PentiumD 930 3.0GHz. - 800MHz FSB 2x2MB L2
.ASUS P5WD2 Premium. - Intel 955X LGA775/1066FSB Dual-DDR2-800
.OCZ Gold PC2-5400. - 2x1GB DDR2-667 CL4-4-4-8
CPU ($246can) + MOBO ($220can) + RAM ($234can)= $700
.Athlon64 X2 3800+ 2.0GHz. - 1000MHz HT FSB 2x512 L2
.ASUS A8N-SLi DELUXE. - nForce4 SLI S939/1066FSB DDR-400
.Mushkin HP PC-3200. - 2X1GB DDR-400 CL2-3-2
CPU ($330can) + MOBO ($154) + RAM ($257) = $741
.Antec Performance TX1050B. - SmartPower 500W ($134.00)
.Sapphire Radeon X1800XT. - 512MB GDDR3 ($388.00)
.Western Digital WD2500JS 250GB. - 7200RPM 8MB-SATA2 ($98.00)
entiumD 930 Build: - $1320.00 vs :Athlon64 X2 3800+ Build: - $1361.00
I'm looking for satisfaction - In a Budget Non-Linear Editing Computer
Not overclockification - In a Benchmark Scoring Hot-Rod Computer
Gimme smooth video processing - Reasonable timely media encoding
No nonsense rock steady performance - And maybe some gaming
I don't need the best of best of the best that is greater then the rest
I just want something stable but clearly able to handle video tasks
While everyone just wants smoking fast that can be push faster
I need smoking fast and super stable on cleary limited dollars
I'm a wannabe computer geek, who secretly doesn't know it all
And doesn't want to buy stupid crap that will be obsolete by fall
But I can't wait too long because there will always be more
The sleepless anguish and unbearable torment of deciding...
...is now the perfect time for the perfect bargin for... ... ...
...the Upgrade?
- an Epic Poem by PantlessOne
So here you have it.
I'm not waiting for AM2 or Conroe simply because it will take some time for them to iron out the bugs and for people to figure out what was hype and what is for real, and most importantly what is the best deal. By then the companies will have complicated the issue by announce even better stuff to consider and what was yesterdays news will become affordable for me.
They, being the companies, will always have something in the works that is a better deal then the other guy, that is faster then the other guy, that is better then the other guy, and you can go out and buy it before anyone figures out if what they are saying is really true... or you can wait until real world experience sorts it out and then make a buying decision.
I'm speculating that the PentiumD 930 3.0GHz and the Athlon X2 3800+ is in that sweet spot of maximizing my Cost-to-Perfomance Ratio and they are damn close in many ways (I consider 2-8% difference close) when they are compared in benchmarks... I just need to know which one is proven to be not only fast but incredibly stable...
PantlessOne
Before the poem a note of my source of inspiration...
Everyone is talking about fast nowadays, all the reviewers and reviews forecast OCing ability almost in the first page of their reviews. Now there is nothing wrong with that but what about speed AND stability? I don't want a computer that can chug a few months at the highest of high speeds and spit out the biggest benchmarks and then have to be underclocked the rest of its' life due to damage and instability.
I'm trying to build a Budget Non-Linear Editing Rig for Digital Video and everywhere I read is about speed and ability to overclock but I hardly read anything about long term usage that requires speed and stability. Which set-up is better to Upgrade for Stable Speed...
... and now my epic poem...
~ The Upgrade for Stable Speed ~
If overclocking is not for me - And stability is the key
For the love of computer gods - What are my best odds:
For trouble free operations - Seemless component cooperation
No show stopping exasperations - And no frigg'n catastrophications
I wish I could spend - One hundred ga-thousa-tillion dollars
Mr. Gates if ya wanna buy me a computer - Just gimme a holler
So after counting my pennies - And obssessing over performance benchies
I have it down to two, but only one can make
My Digital Video Non-Linear Editing Dreams come true...
.PentiumD 930 3.0GHz. - 800MHz FSB 2x2MB L2
.ASUS P5WD2 Premium. - Intel 955X LGA775/1066FSB Dual-DDR2-800
.OCZ Gold PC2-5400. - 2x1GB DDR2-667 CL4-4-4-8
CPU ($246can) + MOBO ($220can) + RAM ($234can)= $700
.Athlon64 X2 3800+ 2.0GHz. - 1000MHz HT FSB 2x512 L2
.ASUS A8N-SLi DELUXE. - nForce4 SLI S939/1066FSB DDR-400
.Mushkin HP PC-3200. - 2X1GB DDR-400 CL2-3-2
CPU ($330can) + MOBO ($154) + RAM ($257) = $741
.Antec Performance TX1050B. - SmartPower 500W ($134.00)
.Sapphire Radeon X1800XT. - 512MB GDDR3 ($388.00)
.Western Digital WD2500JS 250GB. - 7200RPM 8MB-SATA2 ($98.00)
entiumD 930 Build: - $1320.00 vs :Athlon64 X2 3800+ Build: - $1361.00
I'm looking for satisfaction - In a Budget Non-Linear Editing Computer
Not overclockification - In a Benchmark Scoring Hot-Rod Computer
Gimme smooth video processing - Reasonable timely media encoding
No nonsense rock steady performance - And maybe some gaming
I don't need the best of best of the best that is greater then the rest
I just want something stable but clearly able to handle video tasks
While everyone just wants smoking fast that can be push faster
I need smoking fast and super stable on cleary limited dollars
I'm a wannabe computer geek, who secretly doesn't know it all
And doesn't want to buy stupid crap that will be obsolete by fall
But I can't wait too long because there will always be more
The sleepless anguish and unbearable torment of deciding...
...is now the perfect time for the perfect bargin for... ... ...
...the Upgrade?
- an Epic Poem by PantlessOne
So here you have it.
I'm not waiting for AM2 or Conroe simply because it will take some time for them to iron out the bugs and for people to figure out what was hype and what is for real, and most importantly what is the best deal. By then the companies will have complicated the issue by announce even better stuff to consider and what was yesterdays news will become affordable for me.
They, being the companies, will always have something in the works that is a better deal then the other guy, that is faster then the other guy, that is better then the other guy, and you can go out and buy it before anyone figures out if what they are saying is really true... or you can wait until real world experience sorts it out and then make a buying decision.
I'm speculating that the PentiumD 930 3.0GHz and the Athlon X2 3800+ is in that sweet spot of maximizing my Cost-to-Perfomance Ratio and they are damn close in many ways (I consider 2-8% difference close) when they are compared in benchmarks... I just need to know which one is proven to be not only fast but incredibly stable...
PantlessOne