Sign in with
Sign up | Sign in
Your question
Closed

Surface RT Tablet Gets Teardown: Fairly Tough to Repair

Last response: in News comments
Share
October 30, 2012 1:09:35 PM

Who cares about 'fixing' a tablet? I would be happy with just being able to replace the battery, and that scores a 10.
Score
19
October 30, 2012 1:11:50 PM

well at leas tthe abttery is easily replacable... one up on apple there, but yea shame all these tablets can't really easily be repaired, something breaks and liek some laptops it is ruined due to impossibility to replace some parts... though at least in a laptop memory and hdd are replacable... i would love to see a tablet enter the market wit a level or fixability and ability to upgrade some things like imagine a read ssd where you can upgrade to a larger on... oh one can dream
Score
-1
October 30, 2012 1:14:31 PM

The only repair yourself need you'll actually have is to replace the battery, all others fall outside of tablet segment due to highly customized hardware (IE no spare parts to be purchased).
Score
8
October 30, 2012 1:23:07 PM

2kungpaoshizi - straight to the point
Score
4
October 30, 2012 1:50:25 PM

This...
cryogenicThe only repair yourself need you'll actually have is to replace the battery, all others fall outside of tablet segment due to highly customized hardware (IE no spare parts to be purchased).


Yeah, I doubt very many people even here on Tom's would dive into the murky waters of tablet repair on any tablet. There is likely little interest, and similarly little benefit.
Score
3
October 30, 2012 1:55:43 PM

The Article should have listed those other replaceable components
Score
0
October 30, 2012 2:21:52 PM

Typical American design. Slick but impossible to repair down the road.

I had a Lincoln Towncar in the 80s. One of those huge 5mpg jobs.
Fun to drive. The door panel had a dozen switches for everything.
So the first switch stopped working and I opened the door. Turns out all switches where in a big black plastic box that was heatformed together. No opening without breaking it.
Dealer confirmed the whole box and wiring would have to be replaced. Costs more than the car was worth so I did not do it. By the time I junked the car basically all buttons had stopped working...
Shameful engineering; built in obsolescence.


Score
3
October 30, 2012 2:49:24 PM

The parts that are tough - the glass and LCD being securely mounted and requiring special care - in my opinion are good. that is a major part of what makes the device well built and strong.
the units that are easier to repair are also the ones that dont feel so well made.
I think being able to do the modular components and batter are more than enough- after that it should go to a shop that is equiped to handle it.
Score
0
October 30, 2012 3:01:48 PM

Funny I don't see people complaining about how difficult it is to repair an iPad. I also agree with the people commenting here about how the battery is really the critical component that should be user-replaceable. And it's no mystery, tablet computers aren't exactly as modular to fix/repair as desktop or even laptop computers.
Score
0
October 30, 2012 8:36:23 PM

i had one of those too, also a 90's one, you know what i did? i just replaced the whole module from a crashed i got at a junk yard for $5.

had to replace one in my '88 silverado 2500 also after my dog jumped up on to the drivers window when i had it down and dumped by big gulp all over the side panel. did the same thing. the used replacements lasted the entire life of the vehicles which was up til 96-98 for both cars and the truck lasted until i bought a new one and quit driving it every day at the end of 2006

the thing i like about american is it used to be designed to last a long time, and it was easy to work on compared to everything else comparable to it in the world. that changed with the greed when companies couldn't sell new product because the old stuff was still working just fine.
Score
1
October 30, 2012 9:28:39 PM

freggoTypical American design. Slick but impossible to repair down the road.I had a Lincoln Towncar in the 80s. One of those huge 5mpg jobs.Fun to drive. The door panel had a dozen switches for everything.So the first switch stopped working and I opened the door. Turns out all switches where in a big black plastic box that was heatformed together. No opening without breaking it.Dealer confirmed the whole box and wiring would have to be replaced. Costs more than the car was worth so I did not do it. By the time I junked the car basically all buttons had stopped working...Shameful engineering; built in obsolescence.


That's what wrecking yards are for. Also, the components are sealed like that because of the environment they have to operate in.
Score
0
Anonymous
October 31, 2012 12:19:57 AM

Geez
Ifixit is just dont know how to pull the new stuff apart.
Well I do know.
I use a method they will have to pay for if they want to know.
All items will be a 10 on there scale then.
Score
0
October 31, 2012 1:39:12 AM

The level of zoom on that image made my computer blue screen.
Score
0
October 31, 2012 11:17:30 AM

Really one wouldn't expect to be able to easily crack open and replace tablet parts. Easy access to the battery is nice though.
Score
0
!