New build, need compatibility check!!!

[Assman]

Hi,

I am putting together a new comp in a week or two, so I need your feedback on my rig 8)

Thermaltake Armor Series VA8000BWS - $154.99

ZALMAN CNPS9500 LED 92mm - $63.99

ASUS P5B - $159.99

E6400 - $299.00

Western Digital Caviar SE16 WD2500KS 250GB 7200 RPM SATA 3.0Gb/s Hard Drive - $79.99

CORSAIR XMS2 2GB (2 x 1GB) 240-Pin DDR2 SDRAM DDR2 800 (PC2 6400) - $219.00

Rosewill RD600-2DB-SL ATX Form Factor 12V V2.2 / SSI standard EPS 12V 600W - $77.99

I have vga, x1600pro 512mb, i know it's not much but i plan to upgrade vga a little later 8)

I'll appreciate your comments :!:

 

[clue69less]

Rosewill RD600-2DB-SL ATX Form Factor 12V V2.2 / SSI standard EPS 12V 600W - $77.99

In that price range, I'd recommend this mushkin. This unit has plenty of power for your planned build and the rail fusion capability may come in handy if you ever put a DX-10 GPU in. Solid unit!

 

[Assman]

Rosewill RD600-2DB-SL ATX Form Factor 12V V2.2 / SSI standard EPS 12V 600W - $77.99

In that price range, I'd recommend this mushkin. This unit has plenty of power for your planned build and the rail fusion capability may come in handy if you ever put a DX-10 GPU in. Solid unit!

i don't see how that mushkin is any better than my choice? am I wrong?

 

[calyn]

I'm not that familiar with Rosewill PSU's, but I haven't seen anyone advise those here. Instead I'd advise this Antec as a PSU. It is a little bit weaker on the 12V rails, but is more than sufficient and it has 3 of them instead of 2.

 

[Assman]

only 500w that's a no no

 

[The_Prophecy]

only 500w that's a no no

Actually it's fine. In fact, he could get away with 450W.

 

[nikolokolus]

only 500w that's a no no

Actually it's fine. In fact, he could get away with 450W.

Word

 

[Assman]

only 500w that's a no no

Actually it's fine. In fact, he could get away with 450W.

You mean I can get away with 450W!
The psu is really not the issue here, i was asking on the compatibility check for mb and memory. XMS2 is a good brand, in your opinion how does it mix in with p5b :?:

 

[clue69less]

Rosewill RD600-2DB-SL ATX Form Factor 12V V2.2 / SSI standard EPS 12V 600W - $77.99

In that price range, I'd recommend this mushkin. This unit has plenty of power for your planned build and the rail fusion capability may come in handy if you ever put a DX-10 GPU in. Solid unit!

i don't see how that mushkin is any better than my choice? am I wrong?

I've actually taken a look at the internals of the mushkin as well as many other popular power supplies. What you can do it to look at components like transistors, capacitors, etc., then go look at their specs. The mushkin uses parts on the order of quality of the PCP&C units. So whereas FSP, mushkin and PCP&C are all made at the same factory, they are not all made with identical parts. In addition, the design of the mushkin includes rail fusion. Go to their web site and check out this feature, look at their +12 volt rail specs, etc. My opinion is that the unit you chose is a level or two down in quality compared to the mushkin, yet is only something like 7 bucks cheaper. It's a no brainer, but I'm willing to pay for a good PS because I've been burned by the mid price stuff too many times.

 

[Assman]

how about my memory and mobo, no issues there right :?: :!:

 

[clue69less]

how about my memory and mobo, no issues there right :?: :!:

I've heard a bunch of people give thumbs up on the RAM. I've decided to wait a while for the mobo waters to clear before buying a Conroe myself. I know I read a positive review of your choice by a couple of Core builders but I have not seen enough recent pro reviews to know how it compares to the ~$250 boards. Have you looked at other forums for more mobo info? Probably worth the effort. I look forward to hearing how your build goes. It should scream!

 

[Assman]

thank you for all the help!!! I will probably go mushkin and I'll order next friday or saturday, I'll keep you posted 8) :lol:

 

[Zorg]

I know this thread is ancient, but I thought I should post for anyone that stumbles on it .

The Mushkin HP-550 (mislabeled as XP-550 on the case, really an HP-550) is junk according to jonnyguru.

JonnyGURU.com - Reviews - Mushkin HP-550 550W