G
Guest
Guest
Archived from groups: comp.dcom.lans.ethernet (More info?)
Hello,
I need some quick advice on upgrading our lan as I am a bit unsure on
a couple of things. We are intending to buy netgear 4 24 10/100
switches and 2 24 gbit port switches to replace our old ones. The
switches I believe all have stack ports and 2 2gbit uplink ports and
was told I can stack up to 4 of them.
I have a couple of questions
1) Someone was suggesting not to use the stack ports but just connect
the gbit ports from the 4 10/100 switches to the gbit switches. I am a
bit wary of this and I think this could cause bottleneck - I am
correct? If 10 machines were trying to talk thorugh the gbit port to
the other switches then wouldnt that saturate the link? - whereas if
you used the stackable ports to interconnect the switches this would
not happen?
2) If you do 'stack the switches' then isnt there a redundancy problem
in that in effect the stack ports are daisy chained so if the middle
switch broke this would affect communication between switch 1 and
switch 4? So for redundancy if you elimetaed the stack method but
connecting each switch to the gbit backplane switch, if one of the
10/100 switches died - it would not affect any of the others?
Thanks for any advice.
Hello,
I need some quick advice on upgrading our lan as I am a bit unsure on
a couple of things. We are intending to buy netgear 4 24 10/100
switches and 2 24 gbit port switches to replace our old ones. The
switches I believe all have stack ports and 2 2gbit uplink ports and
was told I can stack up to 4 of them.
I have a couple of questions
1) Someone was suggesting not to use the stack ports but just connect
the gbit ports from the 4 10/100 switches to the gbit switches. I am a
bit wary of this and I think this could cause bottleneck - I am
correct? If 10 machines were trying to talk thorugh the gbit port to
the other switches then wouldnt that saturate the link? - whereas if
you used the stackable ports to interconnect the switches this would
not happen?
2) If you do 'stack the switches' then isnt there a redundancy problem
in that in effect the stack ports are daisy chained so if the middle
switch broke this would affect communication between switch 1 and
switch 4? So for redundancy if you elimetaed the stack method but
connecting each switch to the gbit backplane switch, if one of the
10/100 switches died - it would not affect any of the others?
Thanks for any advice.