G
Guest
Guest
Archived from groups: alt.cellular.cingular,alt.cellular.data,alt.cellular.motorola (More info?)
Location: Burlingame, California (San Francisco Bay Area)
Signal: Good (3+ bars)
Carrier: Cingular Wireless
Data package: MEdia Works
Computer: IBM ThinkPad 600X (Pentium III 650 MHz, 320 MB)
OS: Windows XP Pro SP2
App: Windows FTP commandline client, binary mode
Bluetooth stack: Windows XP SP2
Bluetooth dongle: Belkin F8T003
Compressed test file from my regular ISP (Sonic.net)
Only downlink tested
* Motorola V551 (EDGE Class 4, brand new):
Bluetooth virtual serial port at 460 Kbps, Windows DUN
ftp: 1048576 bytes received in 96.66Seconds 10.85Kbytes/sec.
ftp: 1048576 bytes received in 98.93Seconds 10.60Kbytes/sec.
* Sony Ericsson GC82 (EDGE Class 10, latest firmware):
PC Card with Sony Ericsson Wireless Manager
ftp: 1048576 bytes received in 104.60Seconds 10.02Kbytes/sec.
ftp: 1048576 bytes received in 95.85Seconds 10.94Kbytes/sec.
* Sony Ericsson Z600 (GPRS Class 10, not latest firmware):
Bluetooth virtual serial port at 230 Kbps, Windows DUN
ftp: 1048576 bytes received in 194.63Seconds 5.39Kbytes/sec.
CONCLUSIONS:
* The V551 performed well with EDGE, on par with the benchmark GC82
* EDGE was only 2x GPRS (Z600), suggesting it's not (yet) fully optimized
I plan to test uplink sometime soon.
--
Best regards, HELP FOR CINGULAR GSM & SONY ERICSSON PHONES:
John Navas <http://navasgrp.home.att.net/#Cingular>
Location: Burlingame, California (San Francisco Bay Area)
Signal: Good (3+ bars)
Carrier: Cingular Wireless
Data package: MEdia Works
Computer: IBM ThinkPad 600X (Pentium III 650 MHz, 320 MB)
OS: Windows XP Pro SP2
App: Windows FTP commandline client, binary mode
Bluetooth stack: Windows XP SP2
Bluetooth dongle: Belkin F8T003
Compressed test file from my regular ISP (Sonic.net)
Only downlink tested
* Motorola V551 (EDGE Class 4, brand new):
Bluetooth virtual serial port at 460 Kbps, Windows DUN
ftp: 1048576 bytes received in 96.66Seconds 10.85Kbytes/sec.
ftp: 1048576 bytes received in 98.93Seconds 10.60Kbytes/sec.
* Sony Ericsson GC82 (EDGE Class 10, latest firmware):
PC Card with Sony Ericsson Wireless Manager
ftp: 1048576 bytes received in 104.60Seconds 10.02Kbytes/sec.
ftp: 1048576 bytes received in 95.85Seconds 10.94Kbytes/sec.
* Sony Ericsson Z600 (GPRS Class 10, not latest firmware):
Bluetooth virtual serial port at 230 Kbps, Windows DUN
ftp: 1048576 bytes received in 194.63Seconds 5.39Kbytes/sec.
CONCLUSIONS:
* The V551 performed well with EDGE, on par with the benchmark GC82
* EDGE was only 2x GPRS (Z600), suggesting it's not (yet) fully optimized
I plan to test uplink sometime soon.
--
Best regards, HELP FOR CINGULAR GSM & SONY ERICSSON PHONES:
John Navas <http://navasgrp.home.att.net/#Cingular>