I have a complicated decision to make, and despite a lot of research am struggling to reach a clear conclusion.
Current system D Yes, I know it's old, but I'm happy with it):
Pentium 4 2.4GHz 800FSB 512KB cache
2 x 256MB PC3200
Asus P4S800 board (no SATA)
40GB Seagate 7200rpm UDMA100 ATA
Soundblaster Live PCI card
Compro TV PCI card
USB/Firewire PCI card
Akasa 400W power supply
Akasa Evo120 CPU cooler
Akasa 80mm intake fan
Akasa 120mm exhaust fan
Windows XP SP2, hyperthreading enabled.
Want I want from my PC (in order of preference)
Stable and reliable; very quiet; able to play games well at 1280 x 1024 resolution (17" TFT native-res); quick when loading and using applications.
The PC's mainly used for word-processing, plot-intensive spreadsheets, web-browsing and C/LaTeX compiling. It's used intermittently for games, but when it is it needs to be able to cope with 1280 x 1024 and high/full detail without lag. The most currently asked of it is Far Cry, all details on high, and it's unlikely to be stretched much more than that over the coming year.
Originally this had a Gigabyte X800XL 256MB Silent-pipe AGPX8 installed which was fast enough and silent and I was perfectly happy. Recently though this card failed within the warranty period, hasn't been repaired and is discontinued, so it looks like I'm just getting back my money on it: £182 (US$340). As a stop-gap Im using a Radeon 7000 32MB AGP that I had lying around, but this is inadequate for any 3D. My question is, what do I do now? Have spent nearly a month reading around this and have narrowed it down to the following:
An AMD/PCI-E upgrade
AMD Athlon 64 3200+ Venice
Asus A8N-SLi Premium
Gigabyte or MSI 7600GT 256MB PCI-E (silent)
Cost: £245 (US$460)
An Intel/PCI-E dual-core upgrade
Pentium D 820 Dual Core 2x1MB 2.8 GHz FSB800
Asus P5LD2 SE i945P
Gigabyte or MSI 7600GT 256MB PCI-E (silent)
Cost: £263 (US$495)
An AGP-only upgrade
Keep the current system and get a Gainward 7800GS+ 512MB AGP card for £233 ($US440)
The AGP-only route is attractive because of the minimal amount of work involved (although there might be issues with my Asus SiS board apparently) and the rest can then be left alone until a major upgrade in early 2008. The other two possibilities will be hassle but give me better future upgradability, though I'm unlikely to do much over the coming year. Note that I'm limited to Skt939 or 775 so I can keep my whisper-quiet Evo120 fan, I have to be quite budget-conscious and that the graphics card has to be silent or whisper-quiet at low load.
I guess the main question is: Would I be happier with a newer CPU and 7600GT or my old CPU and a 7900GS+?
All help gratefully received.
Current system D Yes, I know it's old, but I'm happy with it):
Pentium 4 2.4GHz 800FSB 512KB cache
2 x 256MB PC3200
Asus P4S800 board (no SATA)
40GB Seagate 7200rpm UDMA100 ATA
Soundblaster Live PCI card
Compro TV PCI card
USB/Firewire PCI card
Akasa 400W power supply
Akasa Evo120 CPU cooler
Akasa 80mm intake fan
Akasa 120mm exhaust fan
Windows XP SP2, hyperthreading enabled.
Want I want from my PC (in order of preference)
Stable and reliable; very quiet; able to play games well at 1280 x 1024 resolution (17" TFT native-res); quick when loading and using applications.
The PC's mainly used for word-processing, plot-intensive spreadsheets, web-browsing and C/LaTeX compiling. It's used intermittently for games, but when it is it needs to be able to cope with 1280 x 1024 and high/full detail without lag. The most currently asked of it is Far Cry, all details on high, and it's unlikely to be stretched much more than that over the coming year.
Originally this had a Gigabyte X800XL 256MB Silent-pipe AGPX8 installed which was fast enough and silent and I was perfectly happy. Recently though this card failed within the warranty period, hasn't been repaired and is discontinued, so it looks like I'm just getting back my money on it: £182 (US$340). As a stop-gap Im using a Radeon 7000 32MB AGP that I had lying around, but this is inadequate for any 3D. My question is, what do I do now? Have spent nearly a month reading around this and have narrowed it down to the following:
An AMD/PCI-E upgrade
AMD Athlon 64 3200+ Venice
Asus A8N-SLi Premium
Gigabyte or MSI 7600GT 256MB PCI-E (silent)
Cost: £245 (US$460)
An Intel/PCI-E dual-core upgrade
Pentium D 820 Dual Core 2x1MB 2.8 GHz FSB800
Asus P5LD2 SE i945P
Gigabyte or MSI 7600GT 256MB PCI-E (silent)
Cost: £263 (US$495)
An AGP-only upgrade
Keep the current system and get a Gainward 7800GS+ 512MB AGP card for £233 ($US440)
The AGP-only route is attractive because of the minimal amount of work involved (although there might be issues with my Asus SiS board apparently) and the rest can then be left alone until a major upgrade in early 2008. The other two possibilities will be hassle but give me better future upgradability, though I'm unlikely to do much over the coming year. Note that I'm limited to Skt939 or 775 so I can keep my whisper-quiet Evo120 fan, I have to be quite budget-conscious and that the graphics card has to be silent or whisper-quiet at low load.
I guess the main question is: Would I be happier with a newer CPU and 7600GT or my old CPU and a 7900GS+?
All help gratefully received.