Sign in with
Sign up | Sign in
Your question

Wireless card for Laptop (USB or PCMCIA)??

Last response: in Wireless Networking
January 12, 2006 10:00:25 PM

I have had this question on my mind for a while, and asked tech people at all kinds of computer shops. And had nothing with sales pitches that are irrelavent to my questions.

Is it better to get a wireless card for a laptop that goes into one of the PCMCIA slots or one that hooks up like a USB key??

I'm wondering if the USB keys are better on power consumption, or if that would be the same as the PCMCIA adapter.

I am also wondering if the range on the USB key would be better than that of a PCMCIA wireless network card. Because I have seen the USB key wireless network adapters with these little docking stations (D-link has them) and I am wondering if has anything to do with maximizing range.

If anyone can provide valueable input. please post.
January 14, 2006 12:57:19 PM

Both standards will be able to handle the throughput of the Wireless connection. I can't answer on the power consumption (check on the actual devices themselves; probably pretty close.) The reception is also going to be dependent on individual devices too. I would say find a model of each that catches your eye, then compare power consumption and reception range and make the choice that's best for you...
January 20, 2006 9:01:10 AM

I say it doesn't make a difference. It's basically the same thing in two different packages. So the power consumption will be very close if not identical. So it depends on your taste, USB will occupy a port which you could need, instead PCMCIA are pretty free. But USB adapters are usually a bit cheaper.

One other point that is hard to determine is that the PCMCIA could possibly have a slightly better reception because there is more area to put antennas, so there's a possibility of better antenna diversity. But this is a very slim details.

Conclusion: choose the adapter that suits your needs better.