specs are: CPU: Intel Core 2 Duo E6400 2.13GHz @ stock MotherBoard: GA-965P-DS3 etc.
More aboutnormal e6400 stock
Use easytune5 instead of the 3rd party applicaiton.
I have the same setup and my idle matches or is sometimes lower than my room temp (77F)
No, do not use Easytune. Easytune doesn't measure the CPU Core temperature (which is the important one), it measures the socket temp. And I hope that your measurement from Easytune is wrong because that'd mean that your cpu core is actually HOTTER than 60c which is bad. Download Coretemp and try that. That will be more accurate. But, hopefully the software is just way off...
*Edit* Oh silly me, you're not using Easytune you're using Everest (from the small version of the pic I saw Easyuntune open). Yeah that's bad. It HAS to be an incorrectly seated hsf and bad thermal paste. I mean, I idle at 41c and goto 55c at load..But, I'm OC'ed to 3 Ghz, which compared to some people is still kinda high. Get yourself some artic silver and $30 hsf.