Tom's Hardware Forums » CPU & Components » CPUs » Unable to make a decision=E6600 or 7950GT
 

Unable to make a decision=E6600 or 7950GT

Add a reply



 Word :   Username :  
 
Bottom
Author
 Thread : Unable to make a decision=E6600 or 7950GT
 
Profile: stranger
More Information

Hey all,
I'm new to posting, but I have been reading these forums for quite some time. Very informative.  Anyway, I recieved some gift cards for Newegg for my birthday, and I can't decide on getting the Core 2 Duo E6600 or an ASUS 7950GT.  My current rig is a Pentium 940 @3.8Ghz, ABIT AW8-Max board, Gigabyte 7600 GT, 2 GB Mushkin Ram, Zalman Cooler.  I've read so much on the Core 2 Duo's and even though I have a somewhat modern CPU, I can't help but think the E6600 would be a huge jump in perfomance.  Any help would be appreciated.
 
Joey
 
PS. I bought a ASUS P5B Motherboard, so it supports either Pentium D or Core 2 Duo.

Related Pr oduct
Register or log in to remove.

Still playing my Dreamcast
Profile: Forum Veteran
More Information

Instead, get an X1800XT 256MB.

Profile: Forum Veteran
More Information

I second the X1800XT for you can get one for $200, it should be good to last you till next year and then go upgrade to a DX10 card.

Profile: Faithful Poster
More Information

The videocard would be a big waste of money when the DX10 are coming up in mid november. I would go for the C2D cpu and start thinking about building a new system.

Profile: enthusiast
More Information

I'd wait for Kentsfield (quad-core) to come out, and then get the cheapest model.  Then, I'd upgrade the video card when DX10 cards come out.

Profile: old hand
More Information

At the moment your motherboard will not support CD2 so unless you have a huge gift card I would go for the better Graphics card.
X1800XT is nice but X1900XT is much nicer and not that expensive.
Its your gift card not ours so enjoy .
And happy Birthday
I didnt see the P5B
that changes things a bit.
the core 2 will give you the biggest boost.
but I still think the graphics would be most noticable (gameing)

C’est magnifique, mais ce n’est pas la guerre.
Profile: Forum Master
More Information

Happy Bithday to you... [/singing]
Get the Core 2...
The 7950...
Is a waste of money...
 
Seriously though, get the E6600.

Profile: enthusiast
More Information

another vote for E6600!

LOUD NOISES!!!!
Profile: enthusiast
More Information

id go for the core 2 duo. wouldnt spend for a vid card till they release dx10s.

Profile: stranger
More Information

yeah, i was leaning toward the E6600, just wanted to get some more opinions (hard to make my own decisions sometimes).  I don't do much gaming, and the 7600GT is an ok card.  Guess waiting for DX10 is probably a good idea.  I appreciate all the help.

Profile: journeyman
More Information

I would get the new cpu and never look back at the Pentium 940.  Leave that in the past!  
Why not wait a lil longer for DX10 ?

Profile: enthusiast
More Information

Quote :

yeah, i was leaning toward the E6600, just wanted to get some more opinions (hard to make my own decisions sometimes).  I don't do much gaming, and the 7600GT is an ok card.  Guess waiting for DX10 is probably a good idea.  I appreciate all the help.


 
I still say to wait for Kensfield; if anything, Core 2 Duo prices will go down.

Profile: journeyman
More Information

E6600
 
As for waiting... You could wait, but then again, you can always wait a few months and then again a few months for something new ... blablabla .  
PC's always change and every few months there are techs that are a lot better...

I personally pwn you
Profile: addict
More Information

that is pretty much untrue, games (at the moment) dont benifit from dual core, not many at least, the benifit from quad core will be even less...
 
even though quad core is truely awsome, I think it would be too long a wait, you'd have to wait until mid-late nexyear to get an *afordable* quad core....
 
I'm getting a core 2 duo E6600 (new build) myself, it should arrive at the start of next week :D ,(i've been waiting a month odd now.. ), i say get the e6600, it's basically the speed of a fx62, the FASTEST CPU AVAILBLE!!!!!!!!!
 
 
well the fastest cpu back in march....  :lol:  
 
e6600, e6600, e6600 *goes off chanting*

Profile: Faithful Poster
More Information

even the E6400 is sometimes faster than the fx-62

Profile: addict
More Information

out of topic, perhaps you will notice significant different in outter look by purchasing BenQ FP241WZ :p
 
yes, go with the core 2 duo, you won't regret it.

Profile: enthusiast
More Information

I find it humorous when people always say wait wait wait, that's the most overused words in all the tech forums when someone asks for advice, "wait".  I think if someone really wanted to wait, they wouldnt be asking for advice.  Waiting to me is useless in the Tech world, You might as well wait forever if you're going to wait 3-6 months on something.  As for DX10, I wouldnt wait on that either, Im thinking its going to be a long time before games are mainstream DX10, look how long it took DX9, and it wasnt as big a jump from DX8 as this is.  The cards, I'd seriously wait until the second batch of DX10 cards, Anyone remember how the first dx9 cards performed?  FX Series anyone?
 
Why not Just got for the best you can afford at the moment, and enjoy the performance now, until it wont suffice any longer.  That's just my opinion, and im sure many will disagree.

I personally pwn you
Profile: addict
More Information

although i guess it does matter what his needs are, as he didnt say what he does mostly..he only said he wanted an upgrade...
 
if he plays games alot then i guess the way to go might be a new graphics card, although getting a e6600 would bag you perhaps 10-25 frames per second more. :)

Profile: Honorary Poster
More Information

Quote :

I find it humorous when people always say wait wait wait, that's the most overused words in all the tech forums when someone asks for advice, "wait".  I think if someone really wanted to wait, they wouldnt be asking for advice.  Waiting to me is useless in the Tech world, You might as well wait forever if you're going to wait 3-6 months on something.  As for DX10, I wouldnt wait on that either, Im thinking its going to be a long time before games are mainstream DX10, look how long it took DX9, and it wasnt as big a jump from DX8 as this is.  The cards, I'd seriously wait until the second batch of DX10 cards, Anyone remember how the first dx9 cards performed?  FX Series anyone?
 
Why not Just got for the best you can afford at the moment, and enjoy the performance now, until it wont suffice any longer.  That's just my opinion, and im sure many will disagree.


 
Bravo! Excellent advice! If your system is lagging, and you want better, do what you can now with the best you can afford now.
I would never buy new technology that has not been out for at least 6 months, too many bugs/compatability issues first time around.

Profile: addict
More Information

The biggest factor limiting your gaming is the 7600GT.  Grant it, the E6600 is sweet but the P940 will do the job for the moment.
 
I would either get the X1900XT 256MB card or the 7900GTO and overclock that baby.
 
The video cards are around 250 at the moment.  If you don't plan on OC'ing, the X1900XT is the better card.
 
Take a look at my price/perf chart, here.  And the X1900XT has the current best price/perf of the "high-end" cards.
 
Chiefvalue currently has the best price for the X1900XT 256MB, here.
 
DX10 probably won't be worth getting for at least 6-9 months.
 
On the other hand, getting the CPU, you will only have to upgrade to DX10 next year.
 
Getting a new video card now, then you will want to get a DX10 card and a C2D next year.  So it depends on what you want for the moment.  Better gaming at the moment or least expensive upgrade route?

I personally pwn you
Profile: addict
More Information

yeah actually either choice is good...  :?

Profile: member