Cpu Choice

Forum CPU & Components : CPUs - Cpu Choice

Tom's Hardware: Over 1.4 million members in 6 different countries available to answer all your high-tech questions. Sign up now! Its free!
Word :    Username :           
 

upgrading from my XP 2800+ asus a7n8x deluxe.

Comparing a few choices here. Deff going with socket 939.

Athlon 64 3700+ is a cpu i have my eye on.

other possibilities are the x2 series.

the 64 3700+ = 89$
the 64 4000+ = 137$
the x2 4200+ = 202$ 202 is a bit pricey for me.

DiDn't really notice that much of a diff from the 3700+ and the 4200+ except the price....the 2800+ was great for what i did.. so i can't even imagine how much better this 3700+ system will run.

89$ retail is really looking like an excellent deal.

Anything im missing here?
Money is an option.. so this 89$ CPU is really looking like a great deal.

Looking to pair this up with a Asus A8N 5x board which is only 74$

Thanks for any tips.

Rob.

Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.

get a AM2 motherboard, its the same price as sckt 939 but faster, and in some instances its cheaper.

then get AM2 3800+ for only $114. It will be faster than the socket 939 with 4000+ for $140

AM2 3800

hope that helps you.

Reply to OEM-NIB-OBO

oh and for a motherboard, I would suggest the Abit kN9 Atx motherboard.

Abit kn9 AM2

This motherboard will work great with your new cpu

Reply to OEM-NIB-OBO

Quote :

get a AM2 motherboard, its the same price as sckt 939 but faster, and in some instances its cheaper



not really faster but more future proof.

to rob: if you go with the 3700 in s939 it is a good cpu
probably the best cpu price/performance wise in singlecore.

i have the 3700 and the x2 4400 and see no difference.
but i game and browse the net. no real multitasking.

Reply to sirheck

anyway the x2 would be the better choice. if you can afford it :)

Reply to sirheck

Quote :

then get AM2 3800+ for only $114. It will be faster than the socket 939 with 4000+ for $140



only in a multithread app.

Reply to sirheck

well...

there are TONS of better cpu's then the 3700+ in performance wise.

so in years to come if i ever really wanted to, i can just buy a new CPU and pop it in.


Where as with the AM2... i don't have the money to buy new RAM.
I could of sworn the AM2 platform doesn't use DDR pc3200 it only uses the new DDR2?

well that's what i thought anyways, cause that's the main thing from stopping me beacuse i don't have that much money for a full upgrade and im saving my memory, drives, cases and psu from my current setup. My mobo just died so this is the reason for the upgrade.

so for what im going with right now ... 3700+ and this a8N 5x board for only 74$ this will leave me room for a fairly decent pci-e graphics card...



am i wrong about the AM2 memory thing? if i am then maybe i might switch over to the AM2.

my price limit is around 500 and under for what i need.

Reply to Rob423

Quote :

well...

there are TONS of better cpu's then the 3700+ in performance wise.



the 3700 is a sandy core same as the fx series.
what i meant to say is they are the fastes single core cpu,s out there.
aside from the optys. :)

yes the am2 uses ddr2 and the 939 uses ddr.
there isnt really any diff in performance between the two.
given you have the same cpu for each socket.

Reply to sirheck

Quote :

if i am then maybe i might switch over to the AM2.



im not sure on the price between the two memory (ddr and ddr2)
they are both outrageous i think.

Reply to sirheck

Go with the AM2 system and buy an asrock MB.They have a particular model that supports bothe DDR and DDR2 as well as bothe the AM2 socket and S-939.This should be in your price range and will allow you to upgrade to an AM2 processor and still use your DDR memory.I believe that's the way it is.Anyways,just a thought i had while I was reading your post.Goodluck.

Dahak

EVGA NF4 SLI MB
X2 4400+ S-939
COOLERMASTER R120 WATER COOLER
2 7800GT'S
2X1GIG SAMSUNG DDR400
WD 300GIG HD
EXTREME 19IN.CRT MONITOR

Reply to Dahak

Dahak has a very good point.

I must admit, even though my system is dated(it is only 5 months old...), I love it. A socket 939 3700+ sandy is a good chip, if you're on a budget. If you have the money to spare, try going for AM2 and/or and X2 series - much more future proof.

Ugh, I didn't really help you make up your mind, did I? The deal you found is a very good one, and if you are on a budget, go for it.

There, maybe that helped.

Reply to Pompeii

Well I guess, if its not possible to buy ddr2, then stick to the socket 939. I mean, after all the speed is nearly equal to that of the Am2 platform.

Dont get the 4000+ 939 unless you REALLY need the extra performance. Because between the 4000+ and the 3800+ theres a diff of about $40. So um .. . just get the 3700+ or the 3800+, whichever is available in your area.

Good Luck :lol:

Reply to OEM-NIB-OBO

If you are dead set on S939, I would suggest the best X2 chip you can afford. Socket 939 is discontinued and will not be getting any cheaper. X2-4800 is already scarce, and others will disappear soon. Dual core is already very nice and will be required soon. Even running single threaded apps, dual core is nice since your work is not getting interrupted for other OS and background stuff like antivirus and whatnot. Modern OS is never really single threaded since you have dozens of background processes that poke their head up now and again. The second core can play whack-a-mole while the first core has undivided concentration on your app.

Reply to MarcusL

Only reason im able to even upgrade is cause my MOBO died.

I have a perfectly good system here, with my 1GB pc3200 Corsair XMS im not going to let it go to waste and buy more memory for a AM2 ..

also AM2 is sorta new, coulda be bugs and issues.. and im not to thrilled with boards that support so many diff things.

Socket 939 been out for awhile now..

i think the

Asus A8N
Athlon 3700+
and my existing 1GB pc3200 Corsair XMS
and my new PCi-E Graphics card will make quite the system.


im sure it's going to blow away my xp2800+ Asus A7n8x Rig i had.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------

When i build this system and pop in my existing Hard Drive... Will it boot?

or am i going to have to RE-format the drive since i made a Mobo, Gfx and CPU change..

I would assume a new Format? Also will i have a problem Re Registering for this XP copy again. it's a legit copy. Oh well i'll figure a way around it if i can't get any info on here.

Thanks a ton for posting fellas.

Rob.

Reply to Rob423

Quote :

When i build this system and pop in my existing Hard Drive... Will it boot?



No.

You will need to reinstall XP on your new 939 build.

Its going to need new MB drivers, and your old installation would prolly just blue screen.

Reply to Grimmy

yea that's what i figured. Thanks alot for the replies.


I'm also thinking of picking up a 4GB flash drive stick..

thinking of loading XP on that as well.


How will the boot speeds or just in general speeds compare to a 7200RPM IDE drive?

Reply to Rob423
Tom's Hardware > Forum > CPU & Components > CPUs > Cpu Choice
Go to:

There are 902 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Please mind

You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.

Add a reply Cancel
Sponsored links
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them