Sign in with
Sign up | Sign in
Your question

Lots of posts on big CPU Heatsinks/Fans, but whats the best?

Tags:
  • Heatsinks
  • Cooling
  • CPUs
  • Overclocking
  • Product
Last response: in Overclocking
Share
November 6, 2006 4:50:21 PM

Been doing research on CPU cooling, and found these were among favorites among users in no particular order:

-Tuniq Tower 120 possibly paired with SILVERSTONE FM120
-Zalman CNPS9700 LED - comes with fan
-Arctic Cooling Freezer 7 Pro - comes with fan, or maybe pair it with the Silverstone?
-Scythe "Infinity" - comes with fan

There are more that just aren't coming to the top of my head right now.

I'm building a new computer for the holiday season and since I'm not going water-cooling, I pretty much want the best air-cooling I can get(considering i'm not that talented on how to set up a water-cooling system).

Unless someone might have some extra time on their hands and could possibly help me out with finding exactly what parts I would need to buy(seems like a hassle) I would probably end up getting one of these.

So which Heat sink/fan combo around is the best? Regardless if it's anything I listed or not.

Going to go for the Core 2 Duo E6600 processor.

EDIT: Also, how would this compare to an easy watercooling installation kit such as the Gigabyte 3d Galaxy II, or something similar?

Thanks!

More about : lots posts big cpu heatsinks fans whats

November 6, 2006 5:51:44 PM

im guessing top air coolers are within a few c of a cheaper water cooler.

the zalman gets less performance than the others

the tuniq is supposed to be the best, and with the silverstone, it would out perform the others.

get the freezer 7 pro if you cant afford the others.

id say tuniq if you can find one, if not scythe ninja or infinity. (they are within 1c of eachother)

pick one that looks the coolesT! :) 

google for some reviews and there are some pretty good comparions. try link scythe ninja vs. scythe infinity etc to find some tests.
November 7, 2006 1:58:12 AM

The Tuniq Tower 120 is undoubtfully the king, Newegg is expecting a shipment in a couple of days.
The Scythe Inifiny is a top performer, but it might be too tall for some cases.
The budget range has a new king, the Cooler Master Hyper TX, it has even outperformed a Ultra-120 in some benchmarks (can get myself to understand how). So this definetly leaves the Arctic Cooling Freezer series out of the game for now.
The Zalman 9500/9700 are simply overpriced for their performance, not worth looking at IMO.
Related resources
November 7, 2006 3:00:09 AM

the scythe would not seat right on my Asus P5B mobo - it touched capacitors.

The zalman CNPS9500 is doing a good job cooling it though.

something to think about - the bigger it is, the more of a b*tch it is to install - always worth the hassle though.
November 7, 2006 4:03:04 AM

On your selection the Tuniq Tower 120 is the best one.Thermalright Ultra 120 would be a good cooler and pair that with the FM121 fan then you got a very good and silent cpu cooler. I highly recommend the FM121 for the Tuniq or Thermalright, it's quite and high cfm. I used it myself for my Big Typhoon and now for my radiator. Both are very good cooler.

Check out it's review. (Thermalright Ultra-120)
http://frostytech.com/articleview.cfm?articleid=2001&pa...

But if you don't overclock or not going to, then any of your on the four you listed selection would be good enough for the E6600. Make sure you use a good thermal paste like AS5.

As for watercooling well, if you don't overclock then go for the air cooling since it's way more reliable and low maintenance. Make have used Thermaltake Big Water kit and have said it's a good water cooling kit for it's price.
November 7, 2006 4:37:50 AM

Thermalright 128. Panaflo fan.

Two names of top performance.

The thermalright might look to big, but it'll fit.
November 7, 2006 4:45:41 AM

Yea i agree the Scythe heatsinks are very nice. I personally own the Zalaman CNPS9500, mainly because i was not a fan of the retention clip design used by Scythe. It is the same designed used my intel for the stock hsf. But considering the Intel HSF do not have the weight and size issues of the Scythe. Price wise you can get the Zalman CNPS9500 for a little less then some of the Scythe. I can say though I thought my Zalman was a huge heatsink it doesn't have anything on the Scythe Ninja and Infinity. From just about all the reviews i have read recently these heatsinks run very close to each other in performance.
November 7, 2006 12:05:14 PM

Thanks alot guys, I will probably end up getting the Tuniq Tower with the FM121 fan to go with it.

I'm assuming nobody recommends that Giga-byte 3d Galaxy II watercooling system? According to http://www.legionhardware.com/document.php?id=584&p=2 the benchmarks are really nice.

How would this watercooled setup compare to the Tuniq Tower?
a b à CPUs
November 7, 2006 1:08:40 PM

My 2 cents on the subject - I am currently running stock cooling on a E6600 which resides on an Asus P5B. With no overclock(266x9), I barely reach 45C at load, with a 14% overclock (310x9) I touch 55C.

I only run a 10% overclock, and the stock cooling is just fine. I would NOT trust it for anything beyond that as an operational setting - as I am a bit conservative.

The only reason you would need an aftermarket cooler is if you get an OEM processor or you wish to safely overclock beyond 10%. The Core2Duo has done a fine job of thermal management - and is a quantum leap above the Prescot series (which I have a Zalman 9500 on a P4 3.2Mhz).

I am quite happy with the slight overclock - and honestly do not see much of a performance increase - just better benchmark scores.

It's your decision - get the big bad cooler - but you will hard pressed to find an application which requires a serious overclock of the E6600.

(I just upgraded my cooling to the AC Freezer Pro 7 - I am very happy with this - as I have dropped about 8-12 degrees on both idle and Load)

Cheers
a b à CPUs
a b K Overclocking
November 16, 2006 8:38:02 AM

I use the Thermaltake Big Typhoon. What a pain in the buttocks. But it's cool and quiet. You could probably make it downright cold if you added a faster fan.
November 16, 2006 10:03:16 AM

I have used the Big Typhoon with FM121 on my 840, overclocked. Then I switch to water cooling.
a b à CPUs
a b K Overclocking
November 16, 2006 10:41:15 AM

LOL, I used the Big Typhoon to replace my water cooler, which had become plugged with all kinds of nasty stuff after not changing the water for 3 years.

I did have some good anti-microbial stuff in it. The water had thickened slightly with white microfibers (some of which had clumped into visible strings) and some sort of metalic oxide chunks.

I got the thing clean and working perfectly, but decided not to re-instal it.
November 16, 2006 12:19:58 PM

They have a new revision to the Big Typhoon which shows some promise, the Big Typhoon VX...

http://www.pcmoddingmy.com/e107_plugins/content/content...

Or you could look at the Titan Amanda, I heard tell it was only 70 bucks, but it performs as well as entry level watercooling setups:

http://www.driverheaven.net/reviews/Titan%20Amanda%20Co...

http://www.tweak3d.net/reviews/Titan/Amanda/TECCooler/C...

http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1099746&page=...

There's where I got the 70 dollar pricetag and availability info from.
a b à CPUs
a b K Overclocking
November 16, 2006 1:05:15 PM

d00d, the new Typhoon is the same as the old Typhoon. They changed the mounting kit and added a fan controller, but it's the same sink.

Now, changing the mounting kit is a HUGE improvement, but not a PERFORMANCE improvement.
November 16, 2006 1:43:23 PM

Hmmm... you are right, never noticed that...

Sigh, damn companies and their naming conventions...
November 16, 2006 1:43:42 PM

WTF double post...
November 16, 2006 2:47:18 PM

Bastards...I wonder how much further they can extend the technology of air cooling.
November 17, 2006 3:12:47 AM

Quote:
d00d, the new Typhoon is the same as the old Typhoon. They changed the mounting kit and added a fan controller, but it's the same sink.

Now, changing the mounting kit is a HUGE improvement, but not a PERFORMANCE improvement.
That is correct. The BT is one of only a few original designs/ideas TT has come up with. They're going to milk it for everything it's worth, and then some. :wink:
!