Tom's Hardware > Forum > Old Man/Woman's Club > Other > Warning: Computer Question

Warning: Computer Question

Forum Old Man/Woman's Club : Other - Warning: Computer Question

Tom's Hardware: Over 1.4 million members in 6 different countries available to answer all your high-tech questions. Sign up now! Its free!
Page:    Previous 1 2 3 4 Next Bottom Search this thread
Word :    Username :           
 

I'm looking at this motherboard: Foxconn P45A-S LGA 775 Intel P45

I have 4 GB of CORSAIR 4GB (2 x 2GB) 240-Pin DDR2 SDRAM DDR2 800 (PC2 6400)

I want to drop in an E8400/E8500 or one of the newer quads (Q9450/Q9550) CPU. Foxconn tech rep said that board is tested "ok" with the Yorkfields or Wolfdales. The RAM is certified too.

OS: XP Pro

So my question is: Why not? It's only $110 for a pretty full featured P45 board. All newegg reviews were good (one guy fcuked up - but I'm blaming him, since there is an idiot in every 25 builders ...

I know, I know ... buy a gigabyte or asus ... but why? This board looks good to me and will run those chips and RAM fine (so it's reported).

Please don't ask me what I'm going to use it for ... for sh|ts and giggles, I guess (I don't know yet). I just have this itch to build.

Opinions, without flames would be appreciated.

------------------------------
The Edge... There is no honest way to explain it because the only people who really know where it is are the ones who have gone over. - HST

Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.
- 0 +

thats nice.

Reply to Flakes

Fcuking helpful, Flakes ... :sarcastic:

------------------------------
The Edge... There is no honest way to explain it because the only people who really know where it is are the ones who have gone over. - HST

Reply to Jake_Barnes
- 0 +

A P45 is a P45, right? I think so, so the Foxconn should be fine provided the MB product page supplies you with a Forum to ask questions about the board with other owners/users. And, is Foxconn's product page up to date with drivers/downloads etc. I never received my rebate for a Foxconn 9600GT. May still show up some months later. I still use an Epox board every day in ther lab and there is no working product page. In fact, there is no company to stand behind their product in any capacity. You'll be fine.

Reply to badge
- 0 +

itll be fine bro. as long as you dont void the warranty right? ;P

ive actually gone away from both asus and giga, just to let you know.

its msi for me now. :)

but to answer your question i dont see it really being a problem for you.

------------------------------ "For years my dad struggled with alcoholism, I have perfected it."
"Lonely once the drugs are gone, I feel like..."
Roll Tide!

 

Reply to mrface

Well, if its an opinion of Foxconn you're looking for, there's nothing wrong with them. They're an OEM provider that made the jump to end-user / enthusiast type stuff. Like ECS / PCChips, but better.

Seems a shame to "waste" the RAM on a 32-bit OS, but hey what can you do? Wow. I mean we really reached the limit of 32-bit. Amazing. 4 GB just seems so. . . small.

Reply to dwellman

Aren't the P45's the new wonder boards? Go for it, you've got nothing to lose but cash, time, and fingers (Depending how badly the installation goes :))

Reply to Richie_W

dwellman wrote :


Seems a shame to "waste" the RAM on a 32-bit OS, but hey what can you do? Wow. I mean we really reached the limit of 32-bit. Amazing. 4 GB just seems so. . . small.



He'll get 3.2GB accessable to the OS, so it is a shame to lose .8GB. Perhaps he should dabble in the black arts of 64Bit Linux? www.ubuntu.com FTW.

Reply to Richie_W
- 0 +

Foxconn fupped duck when they hired Robin Williams to promote their end user stuff.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ygq [...] re=related

Reply to badge
- 0 +

Well, Id answer one of the Asus P5Qs, but you already kinda nixed that.

Foxconn has a solid rep......among the overclocking kiddies, so take that for what you will. Me...I want rock solid reliability and solid support. Asus has rarely disappointed me.



On another note, I think it was Jeff that was talking about getting a new video card...an ATI 4850?

If so....I just installed the asus 4850 to replace my X1900 yesterday. Mugz that thing is mind blowing.

The X1900 was handling the new Dell 30inch LCD respectably....or so I thought. Im not much of a gamer, dont have the time, but I loaded up C&C 3 to see if there would be a noticable difference. The X1900 handled C&C3 respectably; it was smooth with seemingly good frame rates. With the 4850, the latest drivers, all the options including AA turned up to max at 2560 x1600, that game was so fast it was bytch slaping me like a red headed step child. I might actually have to load another game or 2 to see how they run.

I will say this about the 4850 though. There is an update through MS windows update for "ATI Function Driver for High Definition Audio - ATI AA01" drivers on the 4850....they screwed up video play via the AC3 audio decoding. Both winamp and MS MP (yeah, yeah I know, MP sux and only tards use it, but I was testing to identify the problem so I loaded up vers 9, 11 and the old standby, 6.4) were screwed. Without the AC3 codecs installed, the video would playback normally, but obviously without sound. Installing the AC3 codecs enabled sound, but the video would become choppy, then freeze alltogether while the sound continued normally. So beware of the "High Definition Audio " option should you buy one of these.

edited for high-ayne-ous speeling airorrs

Message quoted 1 times
Message edited by turpit on 09-10-2008 at 04:56:55 AM
------------------------------ http://i249.photobucket.com/albums/gg233/turpit/SIG2A.jpg
Reply to turpit

turpit wrote :

Well, Id answer one of the Asus P5Qs, but you already kinda nixed that....



You buy me one and, I swear to god, I'll use it ... ;)

------------------------------
The Edge... There is no honest way to explain it because the only people who really know where it is are the ones who have gone over. - HST

Reply to Jake_Barnes
- 0 +

Pfft...you buy me one and I'll let you know if was worth your money or not :kaola:

Heres the P5Q SE for $104

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6813131335

or for $129, you can get me an extra onboard lan, and 2 extra sata ports. I'll take all the sata ports I can get....all my transcoded movies are in the full mpeg 2 for max quality so they take up a bunch of space. The 3.25 TB on my system is steadily filling, so you can go with the package deal and get me an extra WD 1TB drive, unless you want to spring for an SSD for a pri drive.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6813131295

------------------------------ http://i249.photobucket.com/albums/gg233/turpit/SIG2A.jpg
Reply to turpit

Jake_Barnes wrote :

You buy me one and, I swear to god, I'll use it ... ;)


Just look at the problems you have when you start paying for stuff.[/Scouse]
[sig]
http://i192.photobucket.com/albums/z14/twathat/liverpool.gifhttp://i192.photobucket.com/albums/z14/twathat/liverpool.gifhttp://i192.photobucket.com/albums/z14/twathat/liverpool.gifhttp://i192.photobucket.com/albums/z14/twathat/liverpool.gifhttp://i192.photobucket.com/albums/z14/twathat/liverpool.gifhttp://i192.photobucket.com/albums/z14/twathat/liverpool.gif
........1977...................1978....................1981..................1984.....................2005....................????...........
....................................................So far five times European Champions.....................................................
[/sig]

Reply to Tom_Smart

Jake_Barnes wrote :

Fcuking helpful, Flakes ... :sarcastic:



LMFAO!!!

I got nothing against Foxcon. They did (last time I was around) supply ATi ref boards which in all honesty I thought were good build quality.

I know Biostar released a ripper of a mobo (at a good price point) but my shoddy memory will only help me provide it's model number tomorrow.

Reply to Vokofpolisiekar
- 0 +

Jake_Barnes wrote :

Fcuking helpful, Flakes ... :sarcastic:



Quote :

Opinions, without flames would be appreciated.



thats what i gave u. an opinion (thats nice) and no flame. :lol:

Reply to Flakes

never used foxconn although i believe in the last few years they have had a growing reputation. not too sure about the newegg specs as it list 16GB support but i think it would be 8 max and i thought p45's supported 1600fsb native but it list it as an OC value, won't matter for 1333fsb models though and the q9550 for me is fine.

sticking with xp i see, any reason for being a luddite :D

------------------------------ I'm a git, deal with it.

Antec 1200,PC Power & Cooling 750,Gigabyte DS4-x48,Intel Q9550@3.4 W/Xigmatek S1283,8GB OCZ DDR2 800,ATI 4870X2,X-FI>CA 640C amp>Tannoy R300/Senn 595's
Reply to strangestranger

dwellman wrote :

Well, if its an opinion of Foxconn you're looking for, there's nothing wrong with them. They're an OEM provider that made the jump to end-user / enthusiast type stuff. Like ECS / PCChips, but better.

 

Seems a shame to "waste" the RAM on a 32-bit OS, but hey what can you do? Wow. I mean we really reached the limit of 32-bit. Amazing. 4 GB just seems so. . . small.

 


I was watching my new system boot up the other day, and I forget if this was on the stat pages that fly by or if it was actually in the BIOS menu itself, but I have to ask....

Are we STILL using a 640K kernel? (Forgive me if "kernel" is not the proper term).

I remember that being an issue WAY back with my old PS2, that "upgrading" to a full whopping meg of memory did not do jack because the handlers needed to manage it pretty much filled most of the usable space above 640.....

Is windows still starting up on a base 640K? Is there anything that still needs/uses this? (Why would I see this?).

Holy Time Warp batman....



PS, I agree about the memory thing. 64 still has not come up to speed (it is sure taking them long enough). I guess they are spending their time (MS) on Vista, trying to get that monstrocity to play nice rather than just taking something that they had working pretty well and tooling with that.

Well whatever.

I am still reeling over the fact that the DOS format for drives is proprietary! That's like copyrighting the english language, WTF is up wit dat?


Anywhoo... back to...whatever.

------------------------------ Mmmmmmmm...Beer.......
Reply to Ninjahedge

Richie_W wrote :

He'll get 3.2GB accessable to the OS, so it is a shame to lose .8GB. Perhaps he should dabble in the black arts of 64Bit Linux? www.ubuntu.com FTW.

 


Tried Kubuntu - Gutsy.

Not bad, really. Very smooth. The problem came when I tried to boot back into XP. I had partitioned the drive using Kubuntu, and it would boot to Linux just fine, but when it tried to start up XP, it said it could not read "C" and could not start the GUI.

It would work if I started XP at a prompt (no GUI, but still DOS...).

So I said "to heck with it" and just reformatted using XP. Thing is, it could not "see" the other partician anymore! My drive is 1/2 the size! (It is only a HTPC, so I am not worried about the space, and I can always ghost/swap it sometime later....).

The only thing that kept me from keeping Kubuntu was the lack of a great MM player. Windows Classic with the CCCP works great! And you can queue up a bunch in advance w/o having to text edit a playlist....

Maybe there was something similar in Kubuntu, but I tried the 4 top rated players and either they would not read some of the more unusual formats OR they would not queue....


Would anyone have any clue on that? I will eventually do ashuffle and I may take the last sheep in the herd out to be Linux'd to play with......

------------------------------ Mmmmmmmm...Beer.......
Reply to Ninjahedge

Ninjahedge wrote :

Tried Kubuntu - Gutsy.

Not bad, really. Very smooth. The problem came when I tried to boot back into XP. I had partitioned the drive using Kubuntu, and it would boot to Linux just fine, but when it tried to start up XP, it said it could not read "C" and could not start the GUI.

It would work if I started XP at a prompt (no GUI, but still DOS...).

So I said "to heck with it" and just reformatted using XP. Thing is, it could not "see" the other partician anymore! My drive is 1/2 the size! (It is only a HTPC, so I am not worried about the space, and I can always ghost/swap it sometime later....).

The only thing that kept me from keeping Kubuntu was the lack of a great MM player. Windows Classic with the CCCP works great! And you can queue up a bunch in advance w/o having to text edit a playlist....

Maybe there was something similar in Kubuntu, but I tried the 4 top rated players and either they would not read some of the more unusual formats OR they would not queue....


Would anyone have any clue on that? I will eventually do ashuffle and I may take the last sheep in the herd out to be Linux'd to play with......



You most likely partitioned the drive incorrectly and accidentally wiped windows. I'm dual booting Ubuntu (I'm not a big fan of the KDE desktop) and Windows XP just fine - I'm hardly in Windows unless I need to dock my iPod or play a game.

Regarding the media player issue, I've never had a single problem using VLC (which is available for both Linux and Windows) or Totem (Preinstalled with Ubuntu). Both have some playlist function.

Reply to Richie_W

Ninjahedge wrote :

Are we STILL using a 640K kernel?

Simply, the memory management scheme is still pretty much a victim of the x86 architecture. 640k for programs and 348K for ISA / PCI and other devices (remember DEVICEHIGH and LOADHIGH?. Anyway, this is why, as you approach 4GB on a 32 bit operating system the BIOS will show the whole RAM but 32-bit windows will show you between 2.7 and 3.5 depending on the SP level and the amount of PCI devices installed and the quality of your device drivers-- memory mapping and virtual address space and all that.

32-bit linux suffers from pretty much the same thing although it functions more like windows with the /3gb switch-- 3 GB of user space and 1 GB of kernel/system space. Furthermore processes on both OSes are pretty much limited to 2.8 GB even with PAE (although linix kernels won't complain too loudly if you push them over the 2.8 as with windows, you might get an WILOM when you pass 512 MB (thank you Visual C), but this is where one can see a definite disctinction between Windows Server and Windows XP. Windows Server won't throw an WILLOM until you are out of contiguous pages-- then again so does linux, but its more graceful about it.


------------------------------ Do you not know that in a race all the runners run, but only one gets the prize? Run in such a way as to get the prize.
PRs:
-5K: 24:29
-10K: 53:50
Reply to dwellman

I remember LOADHIGH


/me sulks.


Teh other acronyms have me lost though. I was a heavy user, but not a dealer when it came to techies 10-20 years ago. So WILOM has me at a loss.

Is there any real sense in pushing the 64 yet, or is compatibility still crappy?

Can 32 run on a 64 OS? I remember WAY back in the day running analysys programs that were still (I forget if it was 8 or 16) switching to a 32 bit algorithm and seeing the difference like nigt and day, but the lower bit kernel program still ran on the higher OS... What is making 64 so much harder to integrate with 32?

------------------------------ Mmmmmmmm...Beer.......
Reply to Ninjahedge

WILOM - Windows is low on memory

PAE - Physical Address Extension

Move to 64 bit was more or less hindered by crappy 32-bit performance on the Itanium. AMD licked that problem when it created AMD64, but I suppose, in the Windows world, 64-bit is still soured by the "botched" Itanium and the less than stellar 64-bit XP and Server 2003.

Vista 64 is much better supported.

But as far as 64-bit computing goes, linux (along with other *nix-es, including BSDs) is still king. 386 and x86-64 are esentially identical. Anything that is available for 386 is available for x86-64 (hello source code!).

[EDIT] Oh, right. 32-bit is kinda sorta emulated in 64-bit OS. Sometimes it works. Sometimes it doesn't. gvim, for example, requires a couple registry hacks, to get it to work in XP-64 exactly like it does on XP. Antivir won't install at all. Niether will Rhapsody. All the Microsoft apps are fine though. Media Player, Internet Explorer, and Office.


Message edited by dwellman on 09-11-2008 at 04:16:26 PM
Reply to dwellman

Hmm.

I was just wondering. I felt like I was wasting some of the computing power of my system by having XP 32 on it (the last two P2D's), but I was not sure it was worth risking an upgrade on something that does not have much running that will utilize the extra BW......

Tanx!

------------------------------ Mmmmmmmm...Beer.......
Reply to Ninjahedge

Really, in my opinion, if you're not running a databse or similar you don't need 64-bit. however if you are running a linux and your HW supports it-- why the hell not?


Message edited by dwellman on 09-11-2008 at 09:00:35 PM
Reply to dwellman

Ninjahedge wrote :

Is there any real sense in pushing the 64 yet



There's no real difference between The wife's Vista 32 and my 64. There are some speed differences here and there doing normal stuff, but I have 4x's the ram.

------------------------------ +35 Wingding approval points +10 Scouse approval +22 Mammary Manipulation
+5 Comedy +15 Belated Holy Points +5 Messianic Approval + 5 penile innovation
+13 Baked Ham creativity +65 Obscure Quote

Reply to KingLoftusXII

One of these days. . .

Reply to dwellman

You only gave her 128K??!?!?!?!?


Or are you referring to your night life? :confused:

------------------------------ Mmmmmmmm...Beer.......
Reply to Ninjahedge

The only issues I've had with my 64-bit so far is the drivers for my NetGear StorageCentral 101. They were very late with Vista drivers and they aren't making 64bit drivers...

------------------------------ No more promise no more sorrow,
No longer will I follow.
Can anybody hear me?
I just want to be me.
Reply to JustPlainJef

perhaps you should send them a mail bomb

------------------------------ I'm a git, deal with it.

Antec 1200,PC Power & Cooling 750,Gigabyte DS4-x48,Intel Q9550@3.4 W/Xigmatek S1283,8GB OCZ DDR2 800,ATI 4870X2,X-FI>CA 640C amp>Tannoy R300/Senn 595's
Reply to strangestranger

I prefer femail let-her bombs.

------------------------------ Mmmmmmmm...Beer.......
Reply to Ninjahedge
- 0 +

i don't have any win 95 machines anymore but dam those were fast

Reply to pike

Ninjahedge wrote :

You only gave her 128K??!?!?!?!?

:confused:




I'd say so. 128k...on Vista?

1GB vs. 4GB. Silly man.

------------------------------ +35 Wingding approval points +10 Scouse approval +22 Mammary Manipulation
+5 Comedy +15 Belated Holy Points +5 Messianic Approval + 5 penile innovation
+13 Baked Ham creativity +65 Obscure Quote

Reply to KingLoftusXII

JustPlainJef wrote :

The only issues I've had with my 64-bit so far is the drivers for my NetGear StorageCentral 101. They were very late with Vista drivers and they aren't making 64bit drivers...



Only driver issue is Creative apparently not supporting my cards midi. Maybe they have now. Don't care...

------------------------------ +35 Wingding approval points +10 Scouse approval +22 Mammary Manipulation
+5 Comedy +15 Belated Holy Points +5 Messianic Approval + 5 penile innovation
+13 Baked Ham creativity +65 Obscure Quote

Reply to KingLoftusXII
- 0 +

KingLoftusXII wrote :

Only driver issue is Creative apparently not supporting my cards midi. Maybe they have now. Don't care...




ROLF :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

creative......support...... :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

Man, KL, you are tooooooooooo funny! :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

------------------------------ http://i249.photobucket.com/albums/gg233/turpit/SIG2A.jpg
Reply to turpit

No...mine's different. See, the inputs are gold-plated. You hear me? Gold! It's the best eva'! It's gotta' be real gold, right? Right??? Creative rulez!

------------------------------ +35 Wingding approval points +10 Scouse approval +22 Mammary Manipulation
+5 Comedy +15 Belated Holy Points +5 Messianic Approval + 5 penile innovation
+13 Baked Ham creativity +65 Obscure Quote

Reply to KingLoftusXII
- 0 +

Sadly, Im old enough to remember the days when creative really did "rule", and their support was unparalleled.

------------------------------ http://i249.photobucket.com/albums/gg233/turpit/SIG2A.jpg
Reply to turpit

Turtle Beach, yo!

Reply to dwellman

I have a Turtle Beach audio card - loved it.

------------------------------
The Edge... There is no honest way to explain it because the only people who really know where it is are the ones who have gone over. - HST

Reply to Jake_Barnes

Worst controllers ever.

Reply to Tom_Smart

turpit wrote :

Sadly, Im old enough to remember the days when creative really did "rule", and their support was unparalleled.



That's the way it goes. A person/people have a vision, then eventually, the business people take over.

------------------------------ +35 Wingding approval points +10 Scouse approval +22 Mammary Manipulation
+5 Comedy +15 Belated Holy Points +5 Messianic Approval + 5 penile innovation
+13 Baked Ham creativity +65 Obscure Quote

Reply to KingLoftusXII
- 0 +

True.

But I cant remember any other component company that provided the support and freeware creative used too....I used to think they were nuts for the stuff they gave away. Now, theyre on the verge of CH 11.

------------------------------ http://i249.photobucket.com/albums/gg233/turpit/SIG2A.jpg
Reply to turpit

Their problem, aside from the obvious, is CPU's now have an abundance of power and for 90% of the users, maybe more, on board sound is more than they'll ever need. Even if some dorko options up for the top-o-da-line card, he ain't gonna notice any difference on his 2.1 Altec's...

------------------------------ +35 Wingding approval points +10 Scouse approval +22 Mammary Manipulation
+5 Comedy +15 Belated Holy Points +5 Messianic Approval + 5 penile innovation
+13 Baked Ham creativity +65 Obscure Quote

Reply to KingLoftusXII
- 0 +

Concur.

It doesnt hert that the mobo manufacturers and M$ got their sh!t together, started producing reasonable onboard audio components and most importantly, got their driver/sw interfaces squared away.

I remember when onboard sound made its debut, and the several years following.....you never used embeded audio....to many driver/IRQ/resource conflicts....nowadays with all the problems resolved and the experiance base built, as you point out, most people wouldnt even notice the difference.

------------------------------ http://i249.photobucket.com/albums/gg233/turpit/SIG2A.jpg
Reply to turpit

strangestranger wrote :

... sticking with xp i see, any reason for being a luddite :D



You got a credible reason why I should use Vista?

------------------------------
The Edge... There is no honest way to explain it because the only people who really know where it is are the ones who have gone over. - HST

Reply to Jake_Barnes

You got a credible reason for assuming Vista is the only alternative?
[sig]
http://i192.photobucket.com/albums/z14/twathat/liverpool.gifhttp://i192.photobucket.com/albums/z14/twathat/liverpool.gifhttp://i192.photobucket.com/albums/z14/twathat/liverpool.gifhttp://i192.photobucket.com/albums/z14/twathat/liverpool.gifhttp://i192.photobucket.com/albums/z14/twathat/liverpool.gifhttp://i192.photobucket.com/albums/z14/twathat/liverpool.gif
[/sig]

Reply to Tom_Smart

what else you got? This ain't no linux or apple machine ...

------------------------------
The Edge... There is no honest way to explain it because the only people who really know where it is are the ones who have gone over. - HST

Reply to Jake_Barnes

I'm on a Timex Sinclair 1000. Sh*t rocks. Get with the program will ya' guys. Update your stuff, man. You're all a bunch of hippies.

------------------------------ +35 Wingding approval points +10 Scouse approval +22 Mammary Manipulation
+5 Comedy +15 Belated Holy Points +5 Messianic Approval + 5 penile innovation
+13 Baked Ham creativity +65 Obscure Quote

Reply to KingLoftusXII

Jake_Barnes wrote :

what else you got? This ain't no linux or apple machine ...


GooOS, the Google operating system.
[sig]
http://i192.photobucket.com/albums/z14/twathat/liverpool.gifhttp://i192.photobucket.com/albums/z14/twathat/liverpool.gifhttp://i192.photobucket.com/albums/z14/twathat/liverpool.gifhttp://i192.photobucket.com/albums/z14/twathat/liverpool.gifhttp://i192.photobucket.com/albums/z14/twathat/liverpool.gif
[/sig]


Message edited by Tom_Smart on 09-14-2008 at 12:48:16 PM
Reply to Tom_Smart
Previous
1 2 3 4
Tom's Hardware > Forum > Old Man/Woman's Club > Other > Warning: Computer Question
Go to:

There are 1187 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Please mind

You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.

Add a reply Cancel
Sponsored links
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them