Tom's Hardware > Forum > Graphic & Displays > Nvidia > Who makes the best 8800 GTS?

Who makes the best 8800 GTS?

Forum Graphic & Displays : Nvidia - Who makes the best 8800 GTS?

Tom's Hardware: Over 1.4 million members in 6 different countries available to answer all your high-tech questions. Sign up now! Its free!
Page:    Previous 1 2 Next Bottom Search this thread
Word :    Username :           
 

So are all the 8800 GTS's out there the same, or do some perform better than others?

The Leadtek is the cheapest right now AR, followed by the EVGA, which comes with software. Looks like the XFX comes with a headset that I don't want.

Are they all equally hot, power consumers, etc? (Aside from the factory OC's, which I'm not interested in anyway because I can OC myself and save a few bucks).

What's the verdict people? Anyone want to relay their experiences with the 8800 GTS?

:?: :trophy: :?:

Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.
- 0 +

Hmmm not really sure but they are almost the same. Some have higher core clocks others have higher memory clocks but thats by 10mhz max.

You should go by the most known brand, like eVGA or XFX. Avoid PNY which has the worst customer support as I have heard.

Reply to slim142
- 0 +

I have to agree with what Slim said 100%. I am personally getting the EVGA.

Reply to XrayMan

Quote :

I have to agree with what Slim said 100%. I am personally getting the EVGA.



Sounds wise. The BFG's are more expensive than the rest... or at least I don't see many rebates for them at the moment.

I would sure like to see a better game than Dark Messiah (no offense fans) bundled on the evga. Or a decent gamepad would be nice.

I'm trying to make myself wait until they drop below $350 AR, but I just sold my old Celeron rig for $200 and it's burning a whole in my wallet.

Reply to methimpikehoses
- 0 +

Go with eVga, BFG, XFX. I personaly own and like eVga because of thier step-up program and overclocking the card wont void the warranty.

Reply to sarsoft
- 0 +

I prefer and own evga, because of their step-up program and warranty

Reply to Assman
- 0 +

Didnt know there were so many evga fans in here :D

Reply to slim142

eVGA do a good overclocket version of the GTS.

Reply to harty23690
- 0 +

BFG has the best warranty, and reportedly very good customer support.

Reply to Wabbit
- 0 +

Right now there is an overclocked version of the GTS called 8800 GTS Superclocked which is the best option right now (I believe)

Reply to slim142

So I looked around, here are some options now:

PNY: not sure but it's cheap (relatively speaking) ~400

XFX: comes with a gaming headset. You can also get the XXX overclocked version for more money. ~400 - ~460(OC) AR

BFG: not sure, people seem to like the warranty. oh, you get some stickers to "customize" your card or case. and a t-shirt. :roll:

MSI: serious sam packaged ~390 AR

eVga: step-up program for 90 days, Dark Mess., you can OC w/o voiding warranty. ~370AR, ~409OC, ~460 watercooled [edit: it's not watercooled, it's ACS3 cooling]

Leadtek: card looks cool, Spellforce(?), Trackmania Nations ~365 AR

Asus: probably the best package I've seen so far: you get GRAW, GTR racing, and 3dmark06 complete. Who knows about the actual card though. ~440

Foxconn: overclocked, you get a cheap-looking gamepad ~430

gigabyte: ~460

Reply to methimpikehoses
- 0 +

I've always thought that the XFX cards were slightly better.

Reply to skud
- 0 +

Go with any that makes you feel safe. Thats all I can say.

Reply to slim142

Go with the Superclocked EVGA Gts, its on newegg.com for $409 and its Oc'ed by EVGA to near stock GTX numbers...Im ordering it this weekend upgrading from my 2.5 year old X800 Pro. Looking forward to seeing the difference on my new Gateway 24 inch flat panel at 1920 x 1200 res...

Reply to soldier37
- 0 +

Thats gonna be crazy ;)

Reply to slim142

Quote :

Go with the Superclocked EVGA Gts, its on newegg.com for $409 and its Oc'ed by EVGA to near stock GTX numbers...Im ordering it this weekend upgrading from my 2.5 year old X800 Pro. Looking forward to seeing the difference on my new Gateway 24 inch flat panel at 1920 x 1200 res...



You will be loving that.

I kind of like the sound of the KO version:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6814130081

Anything that will keep the heat down in my case will probably be good... and it's overclocked. The price is almost $100 more than the vanilla-EVGA GTS after rebate though.

I wonder how much it will be in a month... :?:

Reply to methimpikehoses

whats the biggest difference from the KO than the superclocked one, the numbers look the same and $50 more? Is it any better?

Reply to soldier37
- 0 +

Is it me? cuz I think that card looks smaller than any other 8800 I have seen... weird...

Reply to slim142

Quote :

I have to agree with what Slim said 100%. I am personally getting the EVGA.



Wait, the gts drops to $300 soon, when that happens if your not satisfied with the power of it, you could sli the card and probably beat an oc'd gtx's performance for a simular price. As for evga, I like them, but I have found xfx to offer better clocks in general, but evga is much cheaper too for most gfx cards

Reply to I_Love_Tacos
- 0 +

superclocked has always higher clocks than KO cards :wink:

Reply to slim142

I have usually found that xfx beats both super clocked and ko for most gfx cards, but the gts may be an exception

Reply to I_Love_Tacos
- 0 +

idk, but I like that evga gives you many choices to choose from like

KO
KO AC3
KO superclocked
GT
GT KO
GTX
GTX KO
GTX KO AC3

etc etc etc

Reply to slim142

true, and they have great prices, which is one of my favorite aspects about evga (plus teh step up program, and I believe a lifetime warranty-but I can't remember if it was evga or a different company with the warranty)

Reply to I_Love_Tacos
- 0 +

Doesnt matter, I think with 3 years of warranty is enough. You wont use the same card for 3 years... will ya? :lol:

Reply to slim142

you knowme, 6600gt all the way :lol: - inside joke to all others who don't understand

Reply to I_Love_Tacos

Quote :

whats the biggest difference from the KO than the superclocked one, the numbers look the same and $50 more? Is it any better?



The numbers are almost the same out of the box. I think the extra $50 is for the ACS3 fan. Supposedly will keep the heat down somewhat, which would make it worth it to me if that cooling unit really is effective. I wonder if it's the same size. I don't see a physical dimension for it. Says it still needs 400W and 26A like the other evga's.

Reply to methimpikehoses

Quote :

I have to agree with what Slim said 100%. I am personally getting the EVGA.



Wait, the gts drops to $300 soon,

O RLY?

Reply to methimpikehoses

yes, its all over the internet, just google $300 8800gts, since so many sites have supported this, I am betting on this will actually happen

Reply to I_Love_Tacos

Quote :

Doesnt matter, I think with 3 years of warranty is enough. You wont use the same card for 3 years... will ya? :lol:



That's what the video card companies are counting on, isn't it? I am hoping that a 8800 card will keep me happy for a year. Hard to imagine tho.

Reply to methimpikehoses

just remember, the taco has a 6600gt and any of you that have a 8800gtx that want to sell in the next year or so, taco is your man (yes, my 6600gt is that awesome)

As for warranty's, I think that is a deciding factor, but not big enough to sway me away from a higher clocked card

Reply to I_Love_Tacos

Quote :

yes, its all over the internet, just google $300 8800gts, since so many sites have supported this, I am betting on this will actually happen



Oh, you mean the new version with 320mb instead of 640? Supposed to retail for $299...

Reply to methimpikehoses

Yeh thats what Ive been reading, Im just going with the superclocked, its a steal at $409 at newegg. I still cant believe my X800 pro is playing Bf 2142 at 1920 x 1200 res, its been a awesome card the last couple years worth the $416 I paid for it when it was released in May 2004. .. but its time for Direct X 10 and Vista

Heres what Im going with...

Athlon 64 5200+
Evga superclocked 8800 gts(will buy second one this summer for SLI setup)
Asus M2n Sli deluxe
2 x 1Gb sticks of Corsair Xms2 DDR2 800(will have 4gb total by summer)
240 gb WD Sata Raid 0
750 W Thermaltake PS
24 inch Gateway widescreen Flat panel DVI D connection 1920 x 1200 Res
Audigy Xfi extreme gamer sound card
Logitech Z-5300 5.1 speakers
3 memorex Dvd burners at 16x
and 7 cooling fans all glowing green in my Antec Atx Case

Any thoughts on this setup.....

Reply to soldier37

Quote :

Yeh thats what Ive been reading, Im just going with the superclocked, its a steal at $409 at newegg. I still cant believe my X800 pro is playing Bf 2142 at 1920 x 1200 res, its been a awesome card the last couple years worth the $416 I paid for it when it was released in May 2004. .. but its time for Direct X 10 and Vista

Heres what Im going with...

Athlon 64 5200+
Evga superclocked 8800 gts(will buy second one this summer for SLI setup)
Asus M2n Sli deluxe
2 x 1Gb sticks of Corsair Xms2 DDR2 800(will have 4gb total by summer)
240 gb WD Sata Raid 0
750 W Thermaltake PS
24 inch Gateway widescreen Flat panel DVI D connection 1920 x 1200 Res
Audigy Xfi extreme gamer sound card
Logitech Z-5300 5.1 speakers
3 memorex Dvd burners at 16x
and 7 cooling fans all glowing green in my Antec Atx Case

Any thoughts on this setup.....



Nice setup... so you've gone the distance with everything else in there, why not splurge on the 8800GTX, and then get another when the prices drop? Might be worth it for the 24" screen. Hold off on the 4gb of DDR2 and get the very top card!

Reply to methimpikehoses

Quote :

yes, its all over the internet, just google $300 8800gts, since so many sites have supported this, I am betting on this will actually happen



Oh, you mean the new version with 320mb instead of 640? Supposed to retail for $299...
yeah, it has the same pipelines and everything, only half the ram, and tests show that the amount of memory doesn't make too much difference above 256mb for current gaming, when crysis and dx10 come, once again, everything may change, but until then, this will be the card to get

Reply to I_Love_Tacos

Well I pulled the trigger yesterday and went with the standard evga 8800gts. I had a gift certificate for Amazon, so I had to get the $414.00 version to save some money. Hopefully the Tigerdirect will get my rebate to me as well. I've been off of work for the last few days because of snow, so this is what happens!

Anyhow, I'm looking forward to playing Medieval 2 and Oblivion with the eye candy turned up... and I can OC if I need to...

The evga does have a lifetime warranty, pretty good tech support in their forums (I checked it out yesterday), and the stepup program if the 89's come out in the next 3 months and smoke the 88's.

Reply to methimpikehoses

I don't know if you can step up if you oc the gpu, but I think the rules are just that it can't be damaged in any way, so have fun with your gts and enjoy it, as tests have shown that the gts oc'd to the gtx has almost the same performance, but a gtx oc'd is a totally different story, so if nvidia can unleash something that kills the 8800gtx, than ati is really in trouble, we can get insane gfx :D

Reply to I_Love_Tacos
- 0 +

Quote :

you knowme, 6600gt all the way :lol: - inside joke to all others who don't understand



VIVA LA GEFORCE 6600 (and GT too) :D

Reply to slim142

I'm telling you, I get over 90 fps ( no lie, I use fraps to count) with hl2 at 1600*1200 with 2 aa. I know the 2 aa is pathetic, but I haven't tried more yet, and the fact I can get 90 fps like that with a 6600gt really says the 6600gt is better than most people think xD

Reply to I_Love_Tacos
- 0 +

is not a bad card, I use the 6600 in agp 4x mode and is not that bad. Although you are using PCI express and the gt so I supposed the you had a good perfomance.

Reply to slim142
- 0 +

Just purchased a GTS from eVGA. Before them, I always went with BFG because of their warranty and I've had such great customer support multiple times with them (you cant beat getting 4600 replaced by a 5900xt because the fan was dying, even though its a 5xxx Geforce). I went out on a limb this time with eVGA because 1) they had basically the same warranty and 2) BFG was $40 w/o the $30 MIR.

I've only thrown COH at full settings at the card so car - flawless. No complaints.

Reply to Fulmar
- 0 +

evga has won the respect of a lot of people :wink: I just hope they continue their good work.

Reply to slim142

very true, I have an evga 6600gt, but I don't think its all that great because xfx gives you a shit load of more free software and accessories that evga forgoes. They have made it up with their warranty and step up, but the prices on their website are insane, and you have to buy it from there, so many people just end up selling them on ebay anyways. Other than that, i have nothing to complain about
http://evga.com/products/moreinfo. [...] &family=23
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6814130072
Though their superclocked version is worth the price, only $10 more than newegg

Reply to I_Love_Tacos
- 0 +

I heard Leadtek support was Extremly crappy...never had to deal with them, just what Ive read here on the Forums...Avoid them at this point.

Reply to doglips

why would anyone want to go with leadtek when evga is cheaper and has step up though

Reply to I_Love_Tacos
- 0 +

I have never bought anything but evga and that was usually just because they were speced out nice and with nice bundles. I never knew about the step-up program until i bought dual 7900gs's and then the 8800 boom dropped and i caved and had to have one. so i sold one 7900gs and step'd up the other one (at 215.99 when they were selling for 145 at the time) and fell in love with their customer service, honesty and candor in helping me get it out before the largest lan party of the year for me. evga will remain my card of choice till the day i die...unless they start bundling stupid shit with their cards then i might go bfg :lol:

AMD X2 4200+ @2.4
ASUS A8N-SLI Deluxe
evga 8800gts
2GB DDR400 (2x1GB G.Skill)
Rosewill 600W PSU
SB Audigy 2 ZS
3DMark03 = 23,101

Reply to jrnyfan

two questions: Why not get the gtx, and why not free software? I mean my mobo came with 3dmark06 advanced edition and some free virus cleaners such as kasperesky. My question about the gtx is when the gtx is only $150 more on newegg and when oc'd kills anything on the market by massive margins, it doesn't seem like a bad deal. This is the main thing I don't like about step up, its nice to be able to do that, but you have to buy it from evga's website, and that's why many people just end up selling their crap on ebay, because the prices are insane there. The only gfx card I found there with only '$10 of mark up was their super clocked 8800gtx, all the other gtx's were the same price of the super clocked, and almost $100 more than the newegg price for some cards.

Reply to I_Love_Tacos
- 0 +

Yeha me too I have always go with evga because of their great services and warranty. I hope that one day Ill have the GTX :P

Reply to slim142
- 0 +

Yeha me too I have always go with evga because of their great services and warranty. I hope that one day Ill have the GTX :P

Reply to slim142

Gainward Cards are good overclockers, I know from personal experience, and from what I've read on the net.
Take a look here:
Gainward Bliss 8800GTS SLI @621/2052
http://forums.slizone.com/lofivers [...] ?t776.html
Somewhere in all of that mess you should see the clock rates(I think). But the 3d mark scores speak for themselves :D

Reply to Mr_Speedy
Previous
1 2
Tom's Hardware > Forum > Graphic & Displays > Nvidia > Who makes the best 8800 GTS?
Go to:

There are 1164 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Please mind

You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.

Add a reply Cancel
Sponsored links
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them