Archived from groups: alt.games.neverwinter-nights (
More info?)
"Barry Scott Will" <nwn_usenet@cavecreations.net> wrote in message
news:EEPkd.601091$8_6.225164@attbi_s04...
> vellu wrote:
> > Two handed style Great axe
> > and Great sword deal fairly equal damage (axe 1d12, sword 2d6) but axe
> > has x3 criticals vs. x2 of the sword.
>
>
> Yes; but, the greatsword has a threat range of 2 (19-20), while the
> greataxe has a threat range of only 1 (20). Mathematically, a higher
> threat range beats a higher crit multiplier in average damage over the
> course of combat. This is especially true if you take the Imp Crit feat,
> and/or get a Keen weapon.
> --
> Barry Scott Will
> Pyric RPG Publications
> http://www.pyric.com/
No.
Let's have a look at it: If you score a critical hit with an twohanded axe,
you do 3x damage. When rolling a 19, it's just 1x damage. Adding damage from
dice result 19 and 20, we have 4x damage. Taking a greatsword, we have 2x
damage on both 19 and 20, wich also sums up to 4x damage.
Mathematically, they are equal, considering only the threat range and damage
multiplyer.
Even when taking the improved criticals feat and keen weapons, they will
remain equal. 15-20/x2 sums up to 12, just as 18-20/x3 + 15-17/x1 does.
Ok, the greatsword has an slight advantage, as ist does 0,5 points of damage
more in average. But when it comes to strike through damage resistances, the
higher criticals of the greataxe will make your day.