Sign in with
Sign up | Sign in
Your question

Asus p5b-deluxe or p5b-del/wifi

Last response: in Motherboards
January 28, 2007 4:32:27 AM

Is it better to buy a wifi pci adapter or just go with the deluxe/wifi motherboard (it's cheaper, marginally, but I heard there were problems with the integrated wifi).

Could you give me your opinions, and experiences with these motherboards,
Thank you

ps: and if you have any suggestions on alternative motherboards please say,
(e6600 and need firewire)
January 29, 2007 12:43:45 AM

Well nobody answers so I guess I will go with wifi.
If it turns bad I can always buy a separate pci card
January 29, 2007 1:17:38 AM

I think that most on-board features (audio, LAN, wifi) put a load on the CPU more than stand-alone cards.
Also, a stand-alone card will probably have a better signal strength than the onboard.
I am getting the P5B deluxe

Anyway, I'm not using wifi. wired LAN is faster and more reliable
Related resources
January 29, 2007 1:40:48 AM

One thing I noticed with the P5B-WIFI is that it comes with a wired antenna about 1m long, this would be great IMO as Use a dlink PCI card that has a screw on hard antenna about 70mm long and as my PC sits under a hardwood desk the reception isnt as good as I would like it to be, I plan to get the WiFi version of the P5B and then put the PCI card in another PC that's a bit closer to my router.
January 29, 2007 2:36:33 AM

the p5b wifi also has more fan power sockets. good if your case has 5 holes for fans,
The wifi model gives you one less occupied slot.
Don't bother with descrete cards unless you really care about the performance. Even with my old P4 I didn't notice a performance impact.