My recent experience with ON BOARD NVidia SATA RAID has led me to believe ALL RAID SYSTEMS are vulnerable to complete data loss.
My experience begins with an MSI motherboard purchase 4 years ago with NVidia SATA RAID on the motherboard. I ran my system 2 hard drives mirrored.
6 months after my purchase the motherboard blew up. Not wanting to wait for MSI to repair the motherboard under warranty, I bought a 2nd identical board so I could have my computer running while the original motherboard was being repaired. I simply(that is a misnomer) switched RAM, CPU, DRIVES and up and running.
Last month, about 4 years after my original purchase, the newest motherboard died. So, due to my 4 year rule, I figure it was time to upgrade anyway.
In my mind, the most important motherboard option was SATA RAID. I thought I could just plug in my previous SATA drives, with faster CPU and RAM and I would be up and running.
WRONG. After being unable to get my drives running, and only getting a "YOUR COMPUTER MAY HAVE BEEN INFECTED BY A VIRUS" message from WIN XP, I contacted NVIDIA.
They emailed me back saying the only way to get my drives running was to PURCHASE a board identical to the one the drives were originally in.
WHAT???? ARE THEY KIDDING ME?
Where do you purchase a motherboard that hasn't been made in 3+ years!
Well, fortunately, I still had the motherboard they repaired from 4 years ago. I put it in, with my old CPU, RAM and drives, and up the PC came.
Wow.
I have talked about this with my "tech" friends, and they were astonished to the point of not believing me...until one of their SATA RAID motherboards croaked. They were striping, and could not get the drives to read properly after several motherboard attempts.
Is there anyone out there who can offer a solution to this problem? If not, why is ANYONE recommending a RAID SYSTEM for ANYONE? Wouldn't this be true for an NAS RAID, or external RAID as well?
I understand if you have DOZENS OF RACKS, you probably have other backup systems. But if you are a home/SOHO use like myself, MIRRORED RAID seems like a waste to me. You are protected against a drive failure, but SOL on a board failure.
Thanks...and be careful.
My experience begins with an MSI motherboard purchase 4 years ago with NVidia SATA RAID on the motherboard. I ran my system 2 hard drives mirrored.
6 months after my purchase the motherboard blew up. Not wanting to wait for MSI to repair the motherboard under warranty, I bought a 2nd identical board so I could have my computer running while the original motherboard was being repaired. I simply(that is a misnomer) switched RAM, CPU, DRIVES and up and running.
Last month, about 4 years after my original purchase, the newest motherboard died. So, due to my 4 year rule, I figure it was time to upgrade anyway.
In my mind, the most important motherboard option was SATA RAID. I thought I could just plug in my previous SATA drives, with faster CPU and RAM and I would be up and running.
WRONG. After being unable to get my drives running, and only getting a "YOUR COMPUTER MAY HAVE BEEN INFECTED BY A VIRUS" message from WIN XP, I contacted NVIDIA.
They emailed me back saying the only way to get my drives running was to PURCHASE a board identical to the one the drives were originally in.
WHAT???? ARE THEY KIDDING ME?
Where do you purchase a motherboard that hasn't been made in 3+ years!
Well, fortunately, I still had the motherboard they repaired from 4 years ago. I put it in, with my old CPU, RAM and drives, and up the PC came.
Wow.
I have talked about this with my "tech" friends, and they were astonished to the point of not believing me...until one of their SATA RAID motherboards croaked. They were striping, and could not get the drives to read properly after several motherboard attempts.
Is there anyone out there who can offer a solution to this problem? If not, why is ANYONE recommending a RAID SYSTEM for ANYONE? Wouldn't this be true for an NAS RAID, or external RAID as well?
I understand if you have DOZENS OF RACKS, you probably have other backup systems. But if you are a home/SOHO use like myself, MIRRORED RAID seems like a waste to me. You are protected against a drive failure, but SOL on a board failure.
Thanks...and be careful.