Unable to stop users creating new files on shared folder

Archived from groups: microsoft.public.win2000.security (More info?)

"techguy?" <techguy@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message
news:C645B591-A426-4769-807D-2797B55F58BF@microsoft.com...
> I have a shared folder with the following permissions set
> everyone READ ONLY
> Group 1 MODIFY
> Admins FULL CONTROL

> I do not want the users in the group with modify permissions only to be
able
> to create files or folers

Then don't give them Modify on the directories or don't
give them the equivalent (e.g., Change) on the share.


> If i set the permissions of the group to stop creation of new files they
> cannot save their modified files. The files are Word and Excel documents.
> Someone please help thanx

You can approach this two ways (in these cases leave
the share permissions alone -- Change):

1) Go back and change JUST the parent directory
(this controls the adding of new files)
Leave the file permissions as they are so they
can edit and save *

2) Setup the parent directory permissions and then
go to Advanced and edit the Special permissions
to remove create files and subdirectories but leave
append, write etc.

* Problems still occur with some "helpful" (<really> )
programs like Word which technically create a new file
each time the original is modified (to protect against crashes.)