Tom's Hardware > Forum > Graphic & Displays > Nvidia > What 8800GTX to get?

What 8800GTX to get?

Forum Graphic & Displays : Nvidia - What 8800GTX to get?

Tom's Hardware: Over 1.4 million members in 6 different countries available to answer all your high-tech questions. Sign up now! Its free!
Word :    Username :           
 

i am thinking of getting a 8800gtx, but not sure what i should get, the MSi the Asus or the XFX one, wich one is the best?

Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.

i went for the pny one it was the cheapest on newegg. works like any other stock non OCed reference card

Reply to azshe

My guess would be get an XFX or an ASUS.

XFX has been making graphics cards for years and have plenty of experience, while Asus is new to the business but are rising pretty fast.

the two will be the same, unless u buy an overclocked card.

Personally, i think XFX is better cuz they tend to use a better cooling structure (but i'm not sure)

Reply to red_devil

there is also the gigabyte and leadtek verson of this card, personally im leaning towards the gigabyte one i think. anyone have an opinion on these two brands?

Reply to HotStepper

My choice eVGA - life time warranty (even when you oc), step up program.

1.eVGA

2.BFG

3.XFX

Reply to sarsoft

What PSU do you have?

You will need a good quality PSU to run one 8800gtx. You will need min of 34-36 amps on 12V+ rails. Remember PSU is the most overlooked component in a system. Spend wisly.

What is the rest of your system?

Reply to sarsoft

Quote :

i am thinking of getting a 8800gtx, but not sure what i should get, the MSi the Asus or the XFX one, wich one is the best?



They should basicly all be the same.
I like XFX myself as unless you change parts on them or run them over with a truck they will fix/replace or give you the next modal up and they don't care how many people owned it befor you send it in to them.
Of all the "lifetime warrentys" they have the best.

Asus is way overpriced.

Reply to ZOldDude

Hold onto your pennies a bit longer, R600 will be out soon enough and Nvidia will have to try and take the crown back with the 8900 series, better off waiting for that, you've come this far a couple of months wont hurt.

Reply to chameleon101

Was looking for the graphics card for the system im planning on putting up
Motherboard: Asus Striker Extreme
Processor: Intel Core2 Quad Extreme QX6700
Graphics Card: 8800GTX (undecided on build yet)
Memory: Kingston PC2-6400 (800) HyperX [KHX6400D2LLK2/2G](2x1024 or 4x1024)
HD:WD Raptor
Optical Drive: PX-760SA
Chassis: TT Soprano DX
Power Supply: TT Toughpower 700W (because of the detachable cables)

by the way, will the 88''gtx fit in TT Soprano? i see a lot of warning everywhere regarding the card's size

Reply to Blademasterpt

Quote :

Was looking for the graphics card for the system im planning on putting up
Motherboard: Asus Striker Extreme
Processor: Intel Core2 Quad Extreme QX6700
Graphics Card: 8800GTX (undecided on build yet)
Memory: Kingston PC2-6400 (800) HyperX [KHX6400D2LLK2/2G](2x1024 or 4x1024)
HD:WD Raptor
Optical Drive: PX-760SA
Chassis: TT Soprano DX
Power Supply: TT Toughpower 700W (because of the detachable cables)

by the way, will the 88''gtx fit in TT Soprano? i see a lot of warning everywhere regarding the card's size



Your going to be drawing alot of power...it would be wise to avoid a PSU with detachable connectors or multi 12 volt "rails".
The least I would buy would be a Silverstone if I could not use a PC Powercooling.
All your other parts are top shelf so why skimp on the most important item?

Reply to ZOldDude

Quote :


Your going to be drawing alot of power...it would be wise to avoid a PSU with detachable connectors or multi 12 volt "rails".
The least I would buy would be a Silverstone if I could not use a PC Powercooling.
All your other parts are top shelf so why skimp on the most important item?



This man is right. A good PSU with a stout single 12v rail would be your best choice and the one you are going to use is not the best one in the world, especially when pairing it up with a high power draw GPU like the G80. The amps on the 12v rail are most important now a days, not the total wattage.


Either of these would do a much better job and are affordable.


http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6817103437



http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6817163111

Reply to RobsX2

Quote :


Your going to be drawing alot of power...it would be wise to avoid a PSU with detachable connectors or multi 12 volt "rails".
The least I would buy would be a Silverstone if I could not use a PC Powercooling.
All your other parts are top shelf so why skimp on the most important item?



This man is right. A good PSU with a stout single 12v rail would be your best choice and the one you are going to use is not the best one in the world, especially when pairing it up with a high power draw GPU like the G80. The amps on the 12v rail are most important now a days, not the total wattage.


Either of these would do a much better job and are affordable.


http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6817103437



http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6817163111


IMO go XFX if you have the power and a properly cooled case
I recommend the XFX brand, though they are a tad more expensive than regular brands, XFX over clocks the standard Nvidia drivers for you, and they compensate the cooling as well. This is great because with cool bits auto over clock you can over clock with hardly any temp difference!!!! and if you really want to go crazy, you can over clock them really easily provided you cool your case properly!

Quote :

I would go with this card if it can fit in your motherboard.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6814130082



If your going to spend that much money IMO get this card XFX version

Its faster and for only about $39 more[/u]

Reply to frenchbread

What do u mean "They overclock the nvidia driver"?

Reply to red_devil

Quote :

My choice eVGA - life time warranty (even when you oc), step up program.

1.eVGA

2.BFG

3.XFX




Just wondering why you choose the BFG over the XFX version :P Also, i saw a OCZ version of the card also :P

Reply to Trunkz_Jr

Quote :

What do u mean "They overclock the nvidia driver"?



They over clock the standard Nvidia 8800 chipset for you. Like the Standard CPU is 550MHz, XFX takes it to 580MHz, the standard Memory is 1500MHz, XFX's version is 1800MHz

[I think those are the exact specs, but dont quote me on it]

Reply to frenchbread

Quote :

My choice eVGA - life time warranty (even when you oc), step up program.

1.eVGA

2.BFG

3.XFX




Just wondering why you choose the BFG over the XFX version :P Also, i saw a OCZ version of the card also :P

XFX has a track record for some of the most problems (DOA'S ETC...)out of any other GPU manufacturer.

Reply to RobsX2

Really??? hmmmmmm good to know lool I was leaning towards getting the XFX version, guess i'm gonna go with the EVGA kos3 edition [or whatever] or at the very least the BFG one.

Reply to Trunkz_Jr

Quote :

Really??? hmmmmmm good to know lool I was leaning towards getting the XFX version, guess i'm gonna go with the EVGA kos3 edition [or whatever] or at the very least the BFG one.




Yup, just do some searching around on the net and you will see. My friend bought an XFX 7900GTX when they first came out and his first one was a DOA and then his replacement one was also a DOA. :lol:

I have the BFG 8800GTX myself and it has been running at 650mhz core and 2030mem since day one back in Nov 8)

Reply to RobsX2

Quote :



XFX has a track record for some of the most problems (DOA'S ETC...)out of any other GPU manufacturer.



I definitely own an XFX, HAVE HAD ZERO PROBLEMS and have successfully over clocked it as well in both auto-over clock, and manual, unless you've owned one Rob you shouldn't comment, and I'm about to buy another that will probably have ZERO PROBLEMS

also on a side note XFX IMO tends to lead the industry, like for instance when they came out with the 7950gt many companies put a 3-speed fan on it that 'wined' instead of beefing up a fan XFX made it completely silent, a passively cooled card, that was faster and cooler than the stock version

Besides if you were gonna buy an XFX, say on newegg just look at what other people said, and weather or not they have had problems

Reply to frenchbread

I would suggest the:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6817703005

Not worth spending all that money on that hardware and cheaping out on the power supply. I have this power supply and the voltages are dead on.

Reply to jayrm14

Quote :



XFX has a track record for some of the most problems (DOA'S ETC...)out of any other GPU manufacturer.



I definitely own an XFX, HAVE HAD ZERO PROBLEMS and have successfully over clocked it as well in both auto-over clock, and manual, unless you've owned one Rob you shouldn't comment, and I'm about to buy another that will probably have ZERO PROBLEMS

also on a side note XFX IMO tends to lead the industry, like for instance when they came out with the 7950gt many companies put a 3-speed fan on it that 'wined' instead of beefing up a fan XFX made it completely silent, a passively cooled card, that was faster and cooler than the stock version

Besides if you were gonna buy an XFX, say on newegg just look at what other people said, and weather or not they have had problems

I dont really see why I would need to own one in order to make a comment on it and I never said that all of them were bad either.

All one has to do is some research online and they can find out for themselves, also after personally seeing what my friend went through with two DOA 7900GTX'S back to back you couldn't give me a XFX card.

Bottom line is there are better choices than XFX.

Reply to RobsX2

Quote :


also on a side note XFX IMO tends to lead the industry



Lmao since when? because they made a GPU with a passive cooler on it? LMAO :lol: They certainly were not the first to come up with that idea and even if they were it doesnt make them the leader in the GPU industry. :roll:

Quote :


Besides if you were gonna buy an XFX, say on newegg just look at what other people said



Worst advice someone could possibly give seeing as half the reviews from newegg.com are just plain out retarded.

Reply to RobsX2

Hmmmm Maybe I should wait for the 8900's, i heard it makes alot of heat x_X

Reply to Trunkz_Jr

Quote :

What do u mean "They overclock the nvidia driver"?



They over clock the standard Nvidia 8800 chipset for you. Like the Standard CPU is 550MHz, XFX takes it to 580MHz, the standard Memory is 1500MHz, XFX's version is 1800MHz

[I think those are the exact specs, but dont quote me on it]


I know the cards are pre-overclocked, but that's from the hardware, they don't overclock the driver (but it would be cool though :))

Reply to red_devil

BFG all the way!!!
Overclocks like crazy!

Reply to TheProfiler

its down to personal opinion really, if you search on the internet you will find lots of problems with cards from all mnufacturers....people post problems not congratz for making great cards.


IMO

1. XFX
2. BFG
3. EVGA

but take alook at the warrenties and decide which is BEST FOR YOU, they are all about the same, in price and performance. dont not go for a card becuase someone says they break all the time, take a look at the forums you will find problems with BFG and EVGA as well as XFX, it just comes down to luck.

Reply to Flakes

Quote :

Hmmmm Maybe I should wait for the 8900's, i heard it makes alot of heat x_X



Not any more than say the X1900XTX cards from ATI, my last card was a X1900XTX and that thing ran almost identical temps to the 8800GTX yet you hardly ever hear of anyone complaining about the ATI X1900XTX temps :roll:

Honestly the people that have problems with the temps are usually the same people that lack the common sense to having a case with good airflow design. If you have good case air flow it makes all the difference in the world.

Now I took it a step farther and made an addition cooler for my 8800GTX. With my Card Overclocked to 650mhz core and 2030 mem my idle temps are just 49c and load temps after gaming for hours are just 57c.

My temps are as good as my friends water cooled 8800GTX :lol:

Thats a big difference from the typical load temps which is usually in the high 80's.


http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w305/jimjohn_2007/Picture030.jpg

Reply to RobsX2

Damn that looks sick, i think im gonna get a Full tower forsure now :D

Reply to Trunkz_Jr

I'm off to the store right now, gettin' this:
http://www.links.hr/index.php?nazi [...] 52.605.035
(giggle, giggle)

Reply to TheProfiler

Get the Black edition :D

Reply to Trunkz_Jr

Quote :

Hmmmm Maybe I should wait for the 8900's, i heard it makes alot of heat x_X



Not any more than say the X1900XTX cards from ATI, my last card was a X1900XTX and that thing ran almost identical temps to the 8800GTX yet you hardly ever hear of anyone complaining about the ATI X1900XTX temps :roll:

Back when the 1900s were first released, there were plenty of complaints about heat and noise, along with reviews of aftermarket GPU HSFs that discussed it in detail. The topic raised its head again when the 1950 series was fitted with a quieter cooler with equal or better cooling performance.

Reply to clue69less

Quote :

Hmmmm Maybe I should wait for the 8900's, i heard it makes alot of heat x_X



Not any more than say the X1900XTX cards from ATI, my last card was a X1900XTX and that thing ran almost identical temps to the 8800GTX yet you hardly ever hear of anyone complaining about the ATI X1900XTX temps :roll:

Back when the 1900s were first released, there were plenty of complaints about heat and noise, along with reviews of aftermarket GPU HSFs that discussed it in detail. The topic raised its head again when the 1950 series was fitted with a quieter cooler with equal or better cooling performance.

Yeah I remember the stock fan on my X1900XTX being pretty noisy so I replaced it with a accellero X2 which was dead silent even at 100% fan speed. I also still had the two 120mm fans under it just like I have my 8800GTX.

I think I had one of the coolest running X1900XTX'S around that was on air. I idled at just 38c and loaded at 55c after hours of gaming and all this was with the card overclocked to 730mhz core and 1660mhz mem.





Now with the 8800GTX noise at least is not an issue at all even with the fan at 100% speed. The stock cooler actually does a good job you just need to use ntune to crank up the speed.

Reply to RobsX2

Quote :

I'm off to the store right now, gettin' this:
http://www.links.hr/index.php?nazi [...] 52.605.035
(giggle, giggle)


Sta ima care. Odakle si iz hrvatske?

Reply to sarsoft

Quote :

My choice eVGA - life time warranty (even when you oc), step up program.

1.eVGA

2.BFG

3.XFX

Sarsoft gave you the best advice. Take that one.

Reply to XrayMan

Quote :

I'm off to the store right now, gettin' this:
http://www.links.hr/index.php?nazi [...] 52.605.035
(giggle, giggle)


Sta ima care. Odakle si iz hrvatske?
Originalno iz Siska, sad u Zagrebu. Al je svijet mali, a? A ti?

Reply to TheProfiler

Zivim u Chicagu zadnje 13 godina. Rodzen sam u Sarajevu, BiH.

Nice to meet you. Will see you around in this forum http://www.freesmileys.org/emo/cool05.gif.

Reply to sarsoft
Tom's Hardware > Forum > Graphic & Displays > Nvidia > What 8800GTX to get?
Go to:

There are 485 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Please mind

You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.

Add a reply Cancel
Sponsored links
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them