Tom's Hardware > Forum > Graphic & Displays > Graphics Cards > Will r600/n8900 outrun an E4300?

Will r600/n8900 outrun an E4300?

Forum Graphic & Displays : Graphics Cards - Will r600/n8900 outrun an E4300?

Tom's Hardware: Over 1.4 million members in 6 different countries available to answer all your high-tech questions. Sign up now! Its free!
Page:    Previous 1 2 Next Bottom Search this thread
Word :    Username :           
 

I am asking this because I really, really want to buy a new system but want to futureproof as best as possible.

I am still running an AGP board, so unfortunatly, if I go with the processor I want now, I HAVE TO buy a PCIE card.

My plan is to buy processor/mobo and buy a mid-range video card in anticipation of dropping more coin on the r600/n8900 cards.

However, will these cards outrun an o/c'd 4300? Will my best laid plans only end up bottlenecked at the CPU (requiring yet another upgrade).

What do you guys think?

Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.

Any modern dual core is fine.

You shouldn't worry, since getting a top-line CPU, like a X6800 might only bring a couple more framerates.

Reply to prozac26

at stock, yes, but not if you take the cpu to 3ghz, that's what most tests have shown with conroes and the 8800 series

Reply to I_Love_Tacos

for now get you a 76gt or x1650 pci-e card.

then later,say 3 or 4 months get what ever pci-e card you want.

the sli/CF cards or the 8800,s can bottleneck most cpu,s.
but this is at extreme resolutions.

Reply to sirheck

Quote :


the sli/CF cards or the 8800,s can bottleneck most cpu,s.
but this is at extreme resolutions.



Actually its quite the opposite.

Reply to RobsX2

Quote :

at stock, yes, but not if you take the cpu to 3ghz, that's what most tests have shown with conroes and the 8800 series




Taco Is right on the money and I have confirmed this myself with both the 8800GTX and my E6400 tested at different speeds.

You cant simply just pair up any modern dual core cpu with a 8800GTX and expect it to work well, its not that simple at all. An 8800GTX will smack around any of AMD's current CPU's pretty easily.

You have to get a good 3+ghz overclock and that is with a conroe to remove bottlenecking from a 8800GTX.

My friends Opteron 175@3ghz with his 8800GTX did not play as fast as my system when all I had was a single 8800GTX and my E6400 was clocked at 3ghz as well.



Now with my SLI'd 8800GTX's I am seeing gains all the way up to 3.7ghz on the cpu. 8O

Reply to RobsX2

so I'm assuming you got better cooling recently with your new board then, because I remember discussing the tuniq and how it could take a 6400 to 4ghz, but not necessarily safely

Anyways, that sounds about right (which 650i board was it again, the plus or regular?)

Reply to I_Love_Tacos

What on earth did you buy a second 8800GTX for? You've been telling us about your 60 fps with max details and 16XAA. Have you started gaming at 3840x1024 or something?

Reply to pauldh

so he can play Taco Bell: your first taco at 2560*1600 with 32xhdr so he can see the tacos so vibrantly he can differentiate from the types of cheeses :lol:

Reply to I_Love_Tacos

Quote :

Now with my SLI'd 8800GTX's



jeez man wasnt one enough :lol:

ANIMAL 8O

Reply to sirheck

are you still on the cent 5 case?

how do the 88gtx,s fit in that sucker?

Reply to sirheck

you never know, future dx10 games under vista (although not crysis, and linux with dx10 shall be interesting to try if any of you knows how to recode a game to work with linux) may require 3 8800gtxs and 8gis of ram with an 128 intel/amd infinito core cpu

Reply to I_Love_Tacos

Quote :

for now get you a 76gt or x1650 pci-e card.

then later,say 3 or 4 months get what ever pci-e card you want.

the sli/CF cards or the 8800,s can bottleneck most cpu,s.
but this is at extreme resolutions.



nah, i'd say just don't buy anything now and then have more money later on for a better card. wait for like a month, and then whenever the r600 comes out (should be around that time i believe), you can pick up an e4300 for $113 :D do you NEED an upgrade now? or can you save the ~$100 to $200 on a card that you'll just replace in a short bit?

i'm going for a similar build, and i'm just going to wait.

Reply to lordaardvark2

see, what I would do, is get an extremely cheap 3600 for $85, then, I would buy me a nice board like the crosshair I have with 2gigs of ram and a high end gpu. Finally, with the money I have saved on the cpu, I'd buy nice cooling for it, possibly water or ocz's upcoming phase change and take that up to 3+ghz like how the inquirer got a 65nm 5000 to 3.5ghz (validated) and then your bottleneck will be for the most part gone. Then once the k10 cpus come out, if you really need more speed, I'd get one of those, and vuala, eel supra of computers la cheepo

Reply to I_Love_Tacos

Quote :

see, what I would do, is get an extremely cheap 3600 for $85, then, I would buy me a nice board like the crosshair I have with 2gigs of ram and a high end gpu. Finally, with the money I have saved on the cpu, I'd buy nice cooling for it, possibly water or ocz's upcoming phase change and take that up to 3+ghz like how the inquirer got a 65nm 5000 to 3.5ghz (validated) and then your bottleneck will be for the most part gone. Then once the k10 cpus come out, if you really need more speed, I'd get one of those, and vuala, eel supra of computers la cheepo



yep. i have heavily considered going AMD for this build, simply because i have such a shitty system now, anything will be amazing in comparison. however, the reason i want to go c2d is because my friend got one first and i have to prove who has a bigger e-penis....! :twisted: :twisted: :twisted:

just kidding.

the biggest selling point of AMD is that their motherboards are SOOOO perfectly cheap... its amazing. those are the kind of prices i was hoping 775 mobos would drop to, making my cheap, bottomfeeding ways pay off, so to speak... but thats not the case.

oh well. we'll see how it goes. i kinda need money though before i can build with EITHER proc as the brainz. :lol: :cry:

Reply to lordaardvark2

exactly, you can pull off the major upgrade (still k6?) with even one of the cheapest dualies on the market

well, I'm off to bed

Reply to I_Love_Tacos

Quote :

exactly, you can pull off the major upgrade (still k6?) with even one of the cheapest dualies on the market

well, I'm off to bed



yeah, thats the beauty of it: because EVERYTHING in my system is dated*, ANY rebuild/upgrade will knock my socks off. i just don't really wanna get limited future-wise, for obvious reasons. oh well. i think i may jump on an AMD deal. we'll see. i just need a better computer, i'm not pulling enough frames in minesweeper...!


:wink:


i think i'll go to bed too. your bed, that is. just kidding. you'd probably smell like tacos. heh. kidding again. damn, i'm hilarious. :|

*my rig:
skt. A sempron @ 1.9 ghz
768 megs ddr1 266 8O
agp radeon 9550 128meg

Reply to lordaardvark2

Orwell,

I too was in a similar predicament and wanted to keep my agp card and upgrade to C2D, so i could wait for r600 and dx10 games to come out.

I went with an ASROCK LGA 775Dual-VSTA motherboard. It allowed me to keep my 9800pro and DDR400 Ram while upgrading from my AMD64 3200+ to a E4300. I was even able to overclock it to 288FSB(which seems to be close to this board's limit) @ 2.6Ghz!!! The overclock was very simple to, never had to mess with any settings except for FSB freq.

When
you do get your r600/8900; upgrade to a Gigabyte DS3 mobo and then overclock the E4300 to 3Ghz+; which i'm sure would keep either card happy.

I only spent like $230 at Newegg for the upgrade and am certainly glad I did; I can run 1080p quicktime trailers, run Tversity for the xbox360 at 720p, and even game above 100fps in CS:Source( but not all at the same time unfortunately!!)

Hope this helps

Reply to lazyvenki

gee, don't feel special, I've only been at this forum for a few months, and already people are wanting to sleep in my bed 8O heh, but I'm kinda used to the taco comments by now, still, I'm not really that into tacos, I just wanted a funny name

Reply to I_Love_Tacos

Quote :

so I'm assuming you got better cooling recently with your new board then, because I remember discussing the tuniq and how it could take a 6400 to 4ghz, but not necessarily safely




Taco Im not jumping on you but please pay attention to what I said because this is how things get taken out of context and is also how flame wars get started. I said can get it safely up to 3.7ghz, not 4ghz. Anything after 3.7ghz and I need crazy voltages.

Also note that 3.7ghz was just for benching purposes, my 24/7oc is now 3.4ghz because I only need 1.38vcore to get it dual Prime stable for 14+hrs.

Quote :


Anyways, that sounds about right (which 650i board was it again, the plus or regular?)



I have the PLUS because both PCI-E lanes operate at the full 16X speed 8)

Reply to RobsX2

Quote :

What on earth did you buy a second 8800GTX for? You've been telling us about your 60 fps with max details and 16XAA. Have you started gaming at 3840x1024 or something?




Most games I can run at 60+FPS with a single 8800GTX at 1680X1050 using 16XAA. However that is not the case games such as Oblivion, Call Of Juarez, R6 or even Tombraider Legends.


I have gained more than double the performance in the Above listed games by going SLI and will post a new thread real soon with before and after shots to prove it.

Just for example Oblivion at 1680X1050 with 16XAA and 16XAF on a single card would drop down to 30fps in the thick of the forest. I have tested those same places with SLI and my FPS is 60-70 in the same locations.

Call of Juarez got even a bigger gain, Same settings with a single card and I would be at 35fps in a couple of places and now I am at 90+fps in those same locations. It is Fukin unreal :twisted:

I absolutely am having a hay day right now with my SLI'd rig :wink:

Reply to RobsX2

Quote :



jeez man wasnt one enough :lol:




NO :twisted:

Reply to RobsX2

Quote :

are you still on the cent 5 case?

how do the 88gtx,s fit in that sucker?



PICS soon bro :wink:

Reply to RobsX2

Quote :

are you still on the cent 5 case?

how do the 88gtx,s fit in that sucker?



PICS soon bro :wink:

That would be cool. Cant wait to c pics of a case with the front cut out :P

Reply to choknuti

Quote :

are you still on the cent 5 case?

how do the 88gtx,s fit in that sucker?



PICS soon bro :wink:

That would be cool. Cant wait to c pics of a case with the front cut out :P

LOL. I didnt have to mod the case at all. :wink:

It fits perfect.

Reply to RobsX2

I'm in the process of modding my p180b, that should turn out nice if anyone wants pics of those when it's done, then again skyguy (whom I got the instructions from) already posted his modded case pictures on a thread

Reply to I_Love_Tacos

Could you provide a link? I am a case mod fan my self and luv to look at other peoples work for inspiration :)

Reply to choknuti

I'd go with the antec 900, or a thermaltake armor, either of those are good and easier to work with the p180b, but I'll try find the thread

Reply to I_Love_Tacos

Actually the harder the task the more interesting the solution is. I would really appreciate it if you can locate the link.

Thanks in advance!

Reply to choknuti

found it, my buddy made this thread, and provided tons of photos to easily know how to do so
http://forumz.tomshardware.com/har [...] 17#1542817

Reply to I_Love_Tacos

Stupid me!!! (or lazy???) should have guessed that it is in the case mods section :oops:

Thanks anyway!

Reply to choknuti

If stupid photobucket would hurry up I have a couple of pics to show.

Reply to RobsX2

you could always try imageshack if you wanted

Reply to I_Love_Tacos

Here is a couple of pics with both Call of Juarez and Oblivion running on both a single 8800GTX and SLI for comparison purposes.

Later when I get more time I will start a new thread with a whole crap load of pics and after I find my digi cam I will take a pic of my new setup.



Settings used for both games are 1680X1050, 16XAA and 16XAF+HDR and all in game options set to the max.



Call of Juarez on a single card.
http://i161.photobucket.com/albums/t234/dfghsdfgsdfg/untitled.jpg



Same Location but with SLI

http://i161.photobucket.com/albums/t234/dfghsdfgsdfg/SLI.jpg



Oblivion with a single card-very demanding spot.


http://i161.photobucket.com/albums/t234/dfghsdfgsdfg/ScreenShot0.jpg



Same location with SLI.


http://i161.photobucket.com/albums/t234/dfghsdfgsdfg/ScreenShot1.jpg

Reply to RobsX2

Just wondering, can you tell a difference from one gtx to two yourself, I can tell a very slighty one, but not enough to justify $500

Reply to I_Love_Tacos

I don't notice anything at all :( Guess I need to get my eyes checked 8)

Reply to choknuti

probably theres a more smooth gameplay with the second gtx, because I know rob well and he wouldn't buy something he doesn't need/can't make use of. I can tell a slight difference with dual gtxs, but it's just a slighlty more detailed image that's all

Reply to I_Love_Tacos

Quote :

I don't notice anything at all :( Guess I need to get my eyes checked 8)




WTF are you guys talking about!? is FRAPS not showing in the pics?

Reply to RobsX2

The FPS gain I uiderstand and is expected but I really don't c a difference in the images but my eyesight really is bad so I'll trust u on that one.

Reply to choknuti

Quote :

probably theres a more smooth gameplay with the second gtx, because I know rob well and he wouldn't buy something he doesn't need/can't make use of. I can tell a slight difference with dual gtxs, but it's just a slighlty more detailed image that's all



Ok first of all there is no diff in image quality with one 8800GTX vs Two 8800GTX's, they are both using the same graphics settings. I thought I made that pretty clear. A second 8800GTX doesnt make the graphics any better, all it does is speed up the Frame Rates and that was the whole purpose for me posting those pics with FRAPS so you could see how much faster it is with SLI.

2nd of all I dont think you guys can see the FRAPS for some reason so I will tell you the numbers.

Call Of Juarez
Pic 1 is 43fps
Pic 2 is 81fps


Oblivion

Pic 1 is 28fps
Pic 2 is 64fps

Reply to RobsX2

Ahh, I thought you had a reason for posting this and buying a second gtx. As I thought, the gameplay is a lot smoother with the second gtx, fraps was just a very light white color, so I didn't notice it at first

Reply to I_Love_Tacos

Quote :

The FPS gain I uiderstand and is expected but I really don't c a difference in the images but my eyesight really is bad so I'll trust u on that one.



I didnt post the pics for an image quality comparison as there is no difference in image quality from one 8800GTX to two 8800GTX's. I really dont understand why anyone would think there would be.

Reply to RobsX2

Quote :


I didnt post the pics for an image quality comparison as there is no difference in image quality from one 8800GTX to two 8800GTX's. I really dont understand why anyone would think there would be.



My fault I misunderstood taco when he said

Quote :


Just wondering, can you tell a difference from one gtx to two yourself, I can tell a very slighty one, but not enough to justify $500



my bad :? or is it Taco is bad :roll:

Reply to choknuti

Quote :

Ahh, I thought you had a reason for posting this and buying a second gtx.




Well I didnt post the pics to justify my purchasing a second 8800GTX as there is no need for that. I bought it because I can :wink:




Quote :

As I thought, the gameplay is a lot smoother with the second gtx



Thats the whole point. 28fps to 64fps in Oblivion makes a hell of a difference in smoothness. Thats more than a double gain.

Reply to RobsX2

that's understandable for any current games, though for say supreme commander, or a poorly coded game like flight simular X or nfs carbon, you might notice a difference for image quality too

Reply to I_Love_Tacos

Quote :

that's understandable for any current games, though for say supreme commander, or a poorly coded game like flight simular X or nfs carbon, you might notice a difference for image quality too



I have to disagree. If anything with a poorly coded game the diff will be an increase in FPS, not image quality.

Image quality will be the same with one 8800GTX vs Two 8800GTX's regardless of the game.

The difference is in the Frame rate.

Reply to RobsX2

increase? Then how come so many people complain about those two games only getting 25fps on high end systems?

Reply to I_Love_Tacos

Maybe the CPU is the culprit in supreme commander? I mean with the amount of units on a map and the map size. It's not always the poor graphic card that slows a game

Reply to choknuti
Previous
1 2
Tom's Hardware > Forum > Graphic & Displays > Graphics Cards > Will r600/n8900 outrun an E4300?
Go to:

There are 1139 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Please mind

You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.

Add a reply Cancel
Sponsored links
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them