Tom's Hardware > Forum > CPU & Components > Power Supplies, PC Cases & Case Mods > One of the most over looked best PSU's for the $$$

One of the most over looked best PSU's for the $$$

Forum CPU & Components : Power Supplies, PC Cases & Case Mods - One of the most over looked best PSU's for the $$$

Tom's Hardware: Over 1.4 million members in 6 different countries available to answer all your high-tech questions. Sign up now! Its free!
Page:    Previous 1 2 Next Bottom Search this thread
Word :    Username :           
 

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6817103437

People looking for PSU's in the 500-600watt range should seriously consider this PSU because for the price it cant be beat and will easily put other PSU's that are within its price range to shame. Particularly multi rail PSU's.


My friend is running this PSU paired up with an opty 175@3.1ghz and an 8800GTX at 650mhz core and 2030mhz mem.


After hours of gaming his 12v rail sits rock solid at 12.5 volts and never once fluctuates.



Before jumping the gun on a PSU be sure to look this one over and give it some thought. :wink:

Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.

Is that a type, or does it really say 0 PCI-E connectors in the specs? As well as no PFC. And the efficiency is only 70%?

Reply to f1nal_0men

Why not get an FSP...$115 buys many PSUs.

For that price I would go for:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6817104014

Reply to tool_462

Why not get an FSP...$115 buys many PSUs.

For that price I would go for:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6817104014

Reply to tool_462

You could also consider this one. Cheaper then the Enermax, but with more amps on the 12V rail, better efficency, and a lower cost. I looked at the enermax and was unimpressed. Too much money for what you get.

Reply to 4745454b

While 432W on a single rail is nice, I suppose my three rails(18A) can deliver something like that over two of the three rails and the third throws the amps up to 40A max. or 480W max.. supposedly. And it only cost me $100 sooo ya, go Corsair.

Reply to diabloazul126

The neo has nasty voltage drops where the cables connect to the psu.

I think a very overlooked, inexpensive, and very good psu is the one that I have in my new system, the Sunbeam NUUO 550.

Here are a few reviews:
http://www.overclockercafe.com/Reviews/other_misc/Sunbeam_Nuuo_PSU/index.html
http://www.extremeoverclocking.com/reviews/cases/Sunbeamtech_NUUO_550W_1.html
http://gruntville.com/reviews/PSUs/sunbeam_nuuo_550/
http://www.ocia.net/reviews/sunbeampsu/page1.shtml

Reply to AdamBomb42

Silverstone ST50EF-Plus
Just the best thing on earth

Reply to Ycon

Quote :

Silverstone ST50EF-Plus
Just the best thing on earth



I thought Snapple was the best thing on earth.

Reply to AdamBomb42

Quote :

Silverstone ST50EF-Plus
Just the best thing on earth



I thought Snapple was the best thing on earth.

Snapple is made from the best stuff on Earth (which is apparently Silverstone power supplies). Good thing I stopped drinking Snapple a couple years ago.

Reply to Chil

I have been looking for a way to hook up a large car stereo amplifier in my house to use for my computer sound. That PSU just might cut it, 36 amps would power a 1000w car amp if I don’t push the volume too loud. Get an equalizer to separate the highs and lows then two of those PSU’s to power a sub amp and a high/mid range amp. Ill see how the ac to dc converter my brother got of ebay the other week works out for him, it can handle 40 amps.

Its been awhile since I have looked for a high amp single rail psu to do this with but I will need to take another look as it seems I may be able to find what I need on the cheap now.

Reply to samir_nayanajaad

Corsair HX520
$109.99 after $10.00 Mail-In Rebate
or
Seasonic S12 550HT
$129.99

In my opinion, there are the 2 best power supplies for the price.

And I regret getting my OCZ now, after reading this.

Reply to f1nal_0men

Quote :

I think the only reason the OP likes it so much is because it has a single high amperage +12v rail. He has a hardon for these single railed PSUs.



Some people seem to forget there is a reason to have at least 2 rails, to keep the power to the motherboard and CPU cleaner to help system stability, I would never recomend a single 12v rail now..

Reply to jamesgoddard

Quote :


After hours of gaming his 12v rail sits rock solid at 12.5 volts and never once fluctuates.



I find that comment funny - you a bragging about it running quite badly out of spec.

Reply to jamesgoddard

Quote :


After hours of gaming his 12v rail sits rock solid at 12.5 volts and never once fluctuates.



I find that comment funny - you a bragging about it running quite badly out of spec.

Deleted by Moderator - poster warned about language and abuse!

Reply to RobsX2

[quote="jamesgoddard"]

Quote :


Some people seem to forget there is a reason to have at least 2 rails, to keep the power to the motherboard and CPU cleaner to help system stability, I would never recomend a single 12v rail now..



A lot of you guys dont know wtf it is you are talking about. A powerful single 12v rail design is by far better than a dual rail psu.

Reply to RobsX2

Sir, 12.05v is not 12.5v and anyway that's starting to get borderline overvolted if you mean 12.5(halfway between 12 and 13 volts). Otherwise, 12.05 is within parameters.

Reply to diabloazul126

Quote :


After hours of gaming his 12v rail sits rock solid at 12.5 volts and never once fluctuates.



I find that comment funny - you a bragging about it running quite badly out of spec.

Your a fukin idiot and I advise you to know your stuff before you run off at the mouth. :roll:

Any 12.05 is well within spec as a PSU is allowed a certain + to - percentage from the 12v rail.

I have owned many psu's in my life time and not one ran at exactly 12v you stupid noob.

I agree 12.05 is within spec, but if I had a PSU pushing out 12.5 all the time I would RMA the unit, not good for the long term health of componants.

Reply to jamesgoddard

I highly recommend this PSU. link

Reply to AdamBomb42

Quote :

I know of much better 600w for about $40 cheaper... :roll:



Oh no, not Mrs"They have ways". Go shove your "much better 600w" where the sun don't shine.

Reply to AdamBomb42

Quote :


After hours of gaming his 12v rail sits rock solid at 12.5 volts and never once fluctuates.



I find that comment funny - you a bragging about it running quite badly out of spec.

Your a fukin idiot and I advise you to know your stuff before you run off at the mouth. :roll:

Any 12.05 is well within spec as a PSU is allowed a certain + to - percentage from the 12v rail.

I have owned many psu's in my life time and not one ran at exactly 12v you stupid noob.

Yeah Rob, but you wrote 12.5v, not 12.05v. Ok, maybe you meant to write 12.05v and it was just a mistake in typing, but don't compound the mistake by flaming the guy for your mistake. Take a good look, he quoted you before he made his comment, and between your quote and your flame, we know who's the real idiot.

Reply to Sailer

jamesgoddard wrote:

Quote :

Some people seem to forget there is a reason to have at least 2 rails, to keep the power to the motherboard and CPU cleaner to help system stability, I would never recomend a single 12v rail now..



You sir do not know what you are talking about. It is alot better to have a single rail power supply, compared to a multi-rail power supply. Plus, if you do a little research, you will find out that there are very few "TRUE" multi rail power supplies. Most of the power supplies that "CLAIM" to be multi-rail, have a single rail that are split up into multiple rails, which defeats the whole purpose of having multiple rails in the first place. The companies that do this know that Noobs like you will buy(pun intended) into the myth that the more rails, the better.

Reply to Criminal89

Quote :

Sir, 12.05v is not 12.5v and anyway that's starting to get borderline overvolted if you mean 12.5(halfway between 12 and 13 volts). Otherwise, 12.05 is within parameters.




Sorry. 12.05 is what I meant the first time.

Reply to RobsX2

Quote :

I know of much better 600w for about $40 cheaper... :roll:



Please enlighten me BYTCH :roll:

Reply to RobsX2

Quote :

jamesgoddard wrote:
Some people seem to forget there is a reason to have at least 2 rails, to keep the power to the motherboard and CPU cleaner to help system stability, I would never recomend a single 12v rail now..



You sir do not know what you are talking about. It is alot better to have a single rail power supply, compared to a multi-rail power supply. Plus, if you do a little research, you will find out that there are very few "TRUE" multi rail power supplies. Most of the power supplies that "CLAIM" to be multi-rail, have a single rail that are split up into multiple rails, which defeats the whole purpose of having multiple rails in the first place. The companies that do this know that Noobs like you will buy(pun intended) into the myth that the more rails, the better.

Well said and someone who actually knows WTF they are talking about. All you dumb noobs thinking split rail PSU'S are better than single rail PSU's :roll:

Reply to RobsX2

My Corsair is not a split rail, it is three 18A rails. It delivers a max of only 40A on the 12v though. :-/

Reply to diabloazul126

Quote :

My Corsair is not a split rail, it is three 18A rails. It delivers a max of only 40A on the 12v though. :-/



This is one of many reasons why a good single 12v rail design is better.

Reply to RobsX2

But that's still 4A more than you can at peak on that single rail enermax. And thus almost another 50W to whatever devices I'm using.

Reply to diabloazul126

Quote :

But that's still 4A more than you can at peak on that single rail enermax. And thus almost another 50W to whatever devices I'm using.



It doesnt work that way. With a dual or triple rail PSU you have a whole entire 12v rail dedicated to the CPU alone and the CPU does not need anywhere near 18amps to operate, more like 5amps. You end up wasting amperage on that Rail because its only dedicated to the CPU.

With a good single 12v rail the Power goes where it is needed the most. In the End the Single 12v rail offers more amps because it does not split up the power draw.


I will guarentee you that the Enermax I posted will run a loaded overclocked system with a high end card such as a G80 much much better and far more stable than your psu.

Reply to RobsX2

After going through a number of multi rail psu's and then finally discovering single 12v rail psu's a silverstone being my first there is no way in hell i would go back to a multi rail psu with a high power drawing system.

Reply to RobsX2

Ok well, I'd have to agree many multi-rail setups are crap much like many high wattage psu's are putting much of that wattage on the 3.3v or 5v rail. But I really don't think a well built multi-rail psu will be put to shame by an equally powerful single railed setup nor will a decent multirail perform better than a decent single rail in any noticeable way.

Reply to diabloazul126

Quote :

Ok well, I'd have to agree many multi-rail setups are crap much like many high wattage psu's are putting much of that wattage on the 3.3v or 5v rail.



I agree. The main focus should be on the 12v rail. Too many noobs look at total wattage.


Quote :

But I really don't think a well built multi-rail psu will be put to shame by an equally powerful single railed setup .




Well that will really all depend upon the type of systems being powered. However its a well know fact that high powered single 12v rail psu's are the preffered choice for systems with high power draw.

Just to give you an example-

My best friend and I have exactley the same setup but only one thing makes us different. Our psu's.

My PSU is a PCpowercooling 750watt psu with a single 60amp 12v rail.
My friends PSU is a 850watt multi rail silverstone PSU.

We both have SLI'd 8800GTX's and are running the same motherboard and CPU.

His 12v rail while under load drops to 11.70v while mine remains at 11.85v.



That may not be a big difference but it still implies that stout single 12v rail PSU's are superior for these kind of systems.

Reply to RobsX2

Some Linkage ... I posted this before ...

Warning: (May be biased)

Quote :

8. ARE MULTIPLE 12-VOLT RAILS BETTER THAN A SINGLE 12-VOLT RAIL?
With all the hype about multiple 12-volt rails (ads claim that two rails is better than one, five is better than four, etc.), you’d think it was a better design. Unfortunately, it’s not!

Here are the facts: A large, single 12-volt rail (without a 240VA limit) can transfer 100% of the 12-volt output from the PSU to the computer, while a multi-rail 12-volt design has distribution losses of up to 30% of the power supply’s rating. Those losses occur because power literally gets “trapped” on under-utilized rails. For example, if the 12-volt rail that powers the CPU is rated for 17 amps and the CPU only uses 7A, the remaining 10A is unusable, since it is isolated from the rest of the system.

Since the maximum current from any one 12-volt rail of a multiple-rail PSU is limited to 20 amps (240VA / 12 volts = 20 amps), PCs with high-performance components that draw over 20 amps from the same rail are subject to over-current shutdowns. With power requirements for multiple processors and graphics cards continuing to grow, the multiple-rail design, with its 240VA limit per rail, is basically obsolete.

PC Power and Cooling is once again leading the industry. All of our power supplies now feature a large, single 12-volt rail. The design is favored by major processor and graphics companies, complies with EPS12V specs (the 240VA limit is not a requirement) and is approved by all major safety agencies such as UL and TUV.



Source: PC Power & Cooling

Reply to Jake_Barnes

Quote :

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6817103437

People looking for PSU's in the 500-600watt range should seriously consider this PSU because for the price it cant be beat and will easily put other PSU's that are within its price range to shame. Particularly multi rail PSU's.


My friend is running this PSU paired up with an opty 175@3.1ghz and an 8800GTX at 650mhz core and 2030mhz mem.


After hours of gaming his 12v rail sits rock solid at 12.5 volts and never once fluctuates.



Before jumping the gun on a PSU be sure to look this one over and give it some thought. :wink:



This ToughPower from ThermalTake is the same price, but in addition to the EnerMax PSU, it has dual 12-volt rails, 2xPCI-E connectors, 80% efficiency, and a 3 yr warranty...

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6817153032

Comparatively, I would choose this Thermaltake over that Enermax...

Reply to RichPLS

or the ThermalTake Toughpower 550watt PSU for $115 at NewEgg!?! :roll:

Reply to RichPLS

Quote :

or the ThermalTake Toughpower 550watt PSU for $115 at NewEgg!?! :roll:



ThermalTake PSU's are about as sh1tty as it gets and I see your one of the noobs that thinks 2 rails is better than 1 solid rail since you compared it that way to that enermax I posted. :roll:

Reply to RobsX2

Quote :

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6817103437

People looking for PSU's in the 500-600watt range should seriously consider this PSU because for the price it cant be beat and will easily put other PSU's that are within its price range to shame. Particularly multi rail PSU's.


My friend is running this PSU paired up with an opty 175@3.1ghz and an 8800GTX at 650mhz core and 2030mhz mem.


After hours of gaming his 12v rail sits rock solid at 12.5 volts and never once fluctuates.



Before jumping the gun on a PSU be sure to look this one over and give it some thought. :wink:



This ToughPower from ThermalTake is the same price, but in addition to the EnerMax PSU, it has dual 12-volt rails, 2xPCI-E connectors, 80% efficiency, and a 3 yr warranty...

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6817153032

Comparatively, I would choose this Thermaltake over that Enermax...

You must have not read any of the replies b4 posting this nonsense. ThermalTake power supplies are crap in the first place and having 2 rails does not count for a hill of beans, because ThermalTake is one of the companies that use split rails off of a single rail. :roll:

Reply to Criminal89

Quote :


You must have not read any of the replies b4 posting this nonsense. ThermalTake power supplies are crap in the first place and having 2 rails does not count for a hill of beans, because ThermalTake is one of the companies that use split rails off of a single rail. :roll:



As I read through this, and also the somewhat biased reported from PC Power & Cooling ( its from them and not from an independent tester), the general take as I understand it is that a single rail is better then multiple rails. This is because with a single rail, no wattage is "trapped", but all wattage is free to power whatever needs the power. I am not sure that this represents any real advantage, as long as sufficient wattage is provided to all power draws.

If the Thermaltake is really using a split rail coming off a single rails, then it would have the same advantage as the PC Power & Cooling psu, from what I read here. No wattage is trapped, because it all originates from a single rail. I myself use a Thermaltake 700wt and take comfort that its in mpilchfamily's list of good psus. I don't think its "crap" at all, and it has provided good service.

Reply to Sailer

But, my whole point was that it is NOT better because it "claims" to have multiple rails like the other poster mentions. And as far as it being crap.... well that is based on personal experience. Plain and simple, buy a PC Power & Cooling power supply and you do not have to worry about any of the nonsense associated with other power supplies. :)

Reply to Criminal89

I have to agree that silverstone makes some great psu's. i picked up the one below for like 135 and it is doing great in my system

http://www.silverstonetek.com/prod [...] _spec.html

Reply to big_tuna

:arrow: True,I have a Seasonic S12 550HT and its super quiet,runs cool always,would'nt really consider anything else,very pleaseed with it.

Reply to gloppppp

12.5v isn't out of spec.

Quote :


+12 VDC ± 5%


http://www.formfactors.org/develop [...] ic_br2.pdf

11.4v - 12.6v is all within ATX v2.2 voltage tolerances. Kiddies need to spend more time studying and less time flaming. Also, linking to authoritative documents is your friend. It gives you a chance to figure out if you're right or not while you look for a source ;) For example, I actually thought that the tolerance was ±10%, but since I took the time to do a little research I managed to correct the mistake before I posted.

It's not what you know, it's what you know how to look up. Let us now meditate on this truth and end this silly thread.

Reply to flasher702

Quote :

Why not get an FSP...$115 buys many PSUs.

For that price I would go for:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6817104014



Yep. I am an FSP fanboy :oops:

I have a 450watt FSP that I got for $45. It has 36 amps on the 12v rails. Now that is bang for buck!!!

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6817104954

Reply to TSIMonster

Quote :

But, my whole point was that it is NOT better because it "claims" to have multiple rails like the other poster mentions. And as far as it being crap.... well that is based on personal experience. Plain and simple, buy a PC Power & Cooling power supply and you do not have to worry about any of the nonsense associated with other power supplies. :)



I can think of one other advantage of my Thermaltake, the modular cables, which means that I only have the cables I need and therefore have no extra clutter in the case. As best I know, PC Power & Cooling does not offer modular cables. Ok, I know some people believe modular cables increase resistence, but the psu I have is rated over 80% efficiency, and that seems pretty good to me. Also, aircraft use modular cables in their electronics, so its its good enough to keep a 747 flying, I think its good enough for my computer. Other than that, fewer cables in the case means better airflow and cooling, which looks good to me no matter who makes the psu.

Ok, I accept that most people have had some personal experiences that shape what companies they like or dislike. I have those too. I recognize that my bad expeiences are not shared with everybody, so I usually stay silent on them unless there seems to be a general problem occuring with everyone.

Reply to Sailer

Ok... I am sorry I offended your precious Thermaltake power supply. If I hurt its feelings, feel free to aplogize on my behalf. :twisted:

One last thing, if you think that your Thermaltake is in any way as good as a PC Power & Cooling, you are poorly mistaken.

Plain and simple so the noobs can understand as well. You can have your bling, your multiple rails and your modular cables, but for me only PC Power & Cooling will do.

Thanks and good day.

crim

Reply to Criminal89

Quote :

12.5v isn't out of spec.


+12 VDC ± 5%


http://www.formfactors.org/develop [...] ic_br2.pdf

11.4v - 12.6v is all within ATX v2.2 voltage tolerances. Kiddies need to spend more time studying and less time flaming. Also, linking to authoritative documents is your friend. It gives you a chance to figure out if you're right or not while you look for a source ;) For example, I actually thought that the tolerance was ±10%, but since I took the time to do a little research I managed to correct the mistake before I posted.

It's not what you know, it's what you know how to look up. Let us now meditate on this truth and end this silly thread.

I didn't say that 12.5v was out of spec, though I personally wouldn't want a psu that was running that high. My post concerning the 12.5v was directed more because of someone else going on a rant against a second person when the second person had quoted the first about the 12.5v.

Since that time, the posting turned more to a disussion over rail types and psus rather then the original posted question, which has gotten lost or mixed up as time went on.

Reply to Sailer

Quote :

Silverstone ST50EF-Plus
Just the best thing on earth



Id never use an antec in my rig

Reply to amddiesel

Quote :

As best I know, PC Power & Cooling does not offer modular cables..




Yeah and for good reason :lol:

Quote :

Ok, I know some people believe modular cables increase resistence, but the psu I have is rated over 80% efficiency.




No its not, read it more carefully. Its rated UP TO 85% Efficiency[b] That doesnt really tell us jack sh1t as to what the real world efficiency is of that PSU, I mean hell Im sure for the first 5-10minutes it probably is over 80% efficiency but I can also guarentee you that after a few hours of running your PC or some gaming that its well below 80%. Probably more like 70%.

Also Thermaltake is not disclosing the full MTFB like PCpowercooling and Silverstone do.

The full MTFB would include the tested temperature and if the PSU was tested at full load.

The only info your Thermaltake is listing for the MTFB is the ammount of time tested. They purposely left out the most important details such as [b]temperature tested and full load.
Both of those factors play a big role in the true efficiency.

Unfortunatly thermaltake is not the only company that is guilty of purposely hiding this info as there are plenty PSU companies that do the same. Just stay with good brands such as Pcpowercooling and Silverstone and you should be ok.

Reply to RobsX2
- 0 +

Quote :

jamesgoddard wrote:
Some people seem to forget there is a reason to have at least 2 rails, to keep the power to the motherboard and CPU cleaner to help system stability, I would never recomend a single 12v rail now..



You sir do not know what you are talking about.


You sir are even worse for trying to correct while having things backwards.

Quote :

It is alot better to have a single rail power supply, compared to a multi-rail power supply.



The only thing that matters on a dual rail supply is that one of the rails can support what's asked of it, and today that's high end video cards for those that have them. For those that don't, it'd just be stupid to put much thought into # of rails rather than total output, at least till dropping down into the econo-class PSU that have under 16A for the CPU connector.

Quote :

Plus, if you do a little research, you will find out that there are very few "TRUE" multi rail power supplies. Most of the power supplies that "CLAIM" to be multi-rail, have a single rail that are split up into multiple rails, which defeats the whole purpose of having multiple rails in the first place.



THis is funny. You act like it's bad to have more than one then you try to make a second pass at saying it's bad because it isn't more than one. You've argued yourself into a hole.

Half the reviewers out there are truely idiots with no idea about PSU except the rumors they've heard and repeated. They just don't have the background to have assessed the information as they supposedly "learned" it. They see two wire resistor jumpers bridging the output from an LC filter stage and they think "that's just one rail" when the fact is, the whole purpose of split rails was to limit current per rail, exactly what those resistive jumpers are doing!

There is no "one" system configuration, it would be premature to think everyone wants to run SLI'd video cards and equally premature to say a PSU is only good if tailored towards that goal.

If it is the goal, then IN CONTEXT one design may be more appropriate towards that goal, but if you don't mention the context then your statement about single versus multi-rail PSU is false!

Reply to I
Previous
1 2
Tom's Hardware > Forum > CPU & Components > Power Supplies, PC Cases & Case Mods > One of the most over looked best PSU's for the $$$
Go to:

There are 1062 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Please mind

You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.

Add a reply Cancel
Sponsored links
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them