Tom's Hardware Forums » Overclocking » CPUs » Unsure about C2D temperatures
 

Unsure about C2D temperatures




Word :   Username :  
 
 Page : 1 2
Previous
Author
 Thread : Unsure about C2D temperatures
 
Profile: newbie
More Information

Sorry about this, I know there is a temperature guide, I read it plus a few threads, but I am still confused... Here are the details of my setup:

Gigabyte GA-965P-DS3 BIOS F9
C2D E4300
2 Gig G-Skill DDR2-800 (2x1GB) @ 5-5-5-15
Thermalright XP-120 heat sink with silent 120mm fan (sunon I think) intalled with Artic Silver 5
Antec Sonata 2 with the rear 120mm fan set to lowest speed (the sound is annoying at higher speed, but if I have no choice.... but REALLY, if I have no choice)
BFG Geforce 7600GT OC with a Zalman VF700-Cu

Now, the BIOS/OC settings. FSB is at 320, multiplier x9, my C2D E4300 is at 2.88Ghz, all voltages stock except Vcore at 1.3375 abd FSB set to +0.1V. CE1, CIA2, EIST, spread spectrum and "limit CPUID max 3" are disabled, CPU fan is connected directly to PSU, so always 100%.

The system has been tested stable with 10h30 Ortho. It does not even boot at 230 Mhz FSB without the +0.1V FSB. It does boot with Vcore at 1.32500 or 1.33125 and is stable with almost anything but eventually reboot when running Ortho.

Now, here are my reading:

CPU-Z:

Core speed 2880 Mhz
Rated FSB: 1280 Mhz

IDLE Readings:

SpeedFan:

Vcore1: 1.31V (which would mean my CPU is actually undervolted... This seems to be due to my PSU giving lower voltages than supposed to (Antec 450 Watts), my %v is at 4.81V)
Ok, temperatures now, tell me if I am wrong at some point:
Temp1: 34C
Temp2: 26C (this is supposed to be Tcase right?)
Temp3: -2C (this would actually mean an ambient temp of 21C)
Core0: 22C
Core1: 31C (those 2 are suposed to be Tcase for each core)

TAT:

CPU 0: 38
CPU 1: 45

Core Temp:

Core 0: 22C
Core 1: 29C

Now, under load (Ortho for 10h30 min)

SpeedFan:

Temp1: 34C
Temp2: 50C (24C higher than Idle, do I have a problem??)
Temp3: -2C
Core0: 46C (Those are Tcase right?, the C2D Temp Guide says 50C is safe, so I am safe right? But delta between Idle and Load is higher than 15.... what's that supposed to mean?)
Core1: 46C

TAT:

CPU0: 59C
CPU1: 61C (this is Tjunction, where 65C is safe, am I right, but still more than 15C delta between Idle and Load)

Core Temp:

Core 0: 44C
Core 1: 45C

If I understand all this correctly, my temps are safe, but still somehow high for a e4300 @ 2.88 Ghz with almost no Vcore boost and a thermalright XP-120 and a 120mm case fan.... And I have a big temperature difference between Idle and Load and it would be supposed to be much smaller since I have a great heat sink.

I would really really appreciate to hear what you guys think about this.
Thanks
Mike

Related Product

Register or log in to remove.

Profile: journeyman
More Information

Allow me to try to answer a bit. You are a bit confused.

You have 2 Tjunctions (1 in each core) and 1 Tcase. Looks like TAT is getting your Tjunctions correct. Core 0 and Core 1 in Speedfan are Tjunctions. Your Speedfan and CoreTemp readings are clearly offset. You can adjust Speedfan with offsets, but I personally don't see the need. All that I am worried about at this point are my TAT readings of Tjunction.

15-degrees is the difference (roughly) you should see between Tcase and Tjunction. One of those temps in Speedfan is your Tcase...but again, I'm not sure that it's really necessary to worry about Tcase. 25-degrees is the max difference you want to see between Tjuncction at idle and Tjunction at 100% TAT load. Your load temps are from Orthos, which are not as high as you will see with TAT loading.

Also I think it's very strange how big of a temperature difference there is between your two cores at idle.

Profile: newbie
More Information

what should I do about this big temperature difference between idle and load???

Profile: newbie
More Information

I dont know if any of you is familiar with the thermalright socket 775 adapter for socket 478 CPU cooler... It's an "X" that is screwed on the backplate of the motherboard. It's hard to explain (especially for a frech guy who has to write in english).

You can see a big picture of what this adapter is there: http://www.pc-look.com/boutik/prod [...] ts_id=1788

Now, my questions is, do you guys think my high temperatures difference between idle and load are because the screws that attach the backplate to the 2 plastic retainers are not tight enough? I'm not sure how to say this in english, but, does the CPU-Heatsink contact need to have a high pressure? I am worried about tighting this too much, so I would like to be a bit more sure before I do this.

Thanks guys!

Profile: newbie
More Information

Howdy ThereMike,

Quote :

I dont know if any of you is familiar with the thermalright socket 775 adapter for socket 478 CPU cooler... It's an "X" that is screwed on the backplate of the motherboard.



I had a Zalman 7700(?) that required the adapter as well. If you mean the two screws that affix the heatsink/fan to the adapter top plate, then yes, they require tightening sufficient enough to bend the retainer "ears" down toward the cpu heatspreader. Test by pushing down on the heatsink (down=toward cpu) while the computer is running and warmed up. If your Coretemp readings decrease within a minute,you need to reset your heatsink. That would also explain the difference between cores; which I would be more concerned with.

TonyB.

MSI P6NSLI Platinum, ver, 1.0
E6400 @2.14; idle=36c load=46-50c NOW=42/43c
(free air)
SJN1100b?, SytheNinja rev.B w/120mm sythe fan
2x1GB PDC6400LLK @800MHz
Antec TP430
XFX Fatal1ty 7600GT

Profile: newbie
More Information

Applying a manual pressure to the heat sink dosent seem to change anything to temperatures.

About the difference in temperatures between the 2 cores, I find it strange too, but it's only different when idle, at load, temps are the same (+/- 1C).

Today, the difference between the 2 cores is "only" 5-6C. Maybe it's the artic silver 5 that wasent spead evenly and it starting spead better now.... I really have no clue what's going on. you guys would be worried with these temps or .... ?

The 4 major questions I have are:

What do these temps tell you (is it too hot, is it safe, is it more than safe and I have some more room for OC while keeping CPU to a safe temp)?

Do you think the difference between idle and load is too much and what could cause that?

Same question but for the diff in temp between Core 0 and 1 at idle.

Do these temps looks normal to you for a e4300 at 2.88 Ghz 1.3375V Vcore with a thermalright XP120 (with a 120mm fan at about 2000 RPM) in a case with a 120mm case fan (Antec Sonata 2 case fan set at low speed)?

Profile: journeyman
More Information

I think you are about maxed out on the OC imho. Some places you see people with the 'if it doesn't reboot it's OK' attitude. Around here everybody seems to want to keep their TAT 100% load temps under about 70 (some 65, some 75, you get the idea).

BUT, we don't know what your TAT 100% temps are. Run TAT at 100% for 10 minutes and report the temepratures read on the cores via TAT.

You temp between idle and load is not big (see the Core 2 Duo temp guide sticky) but that is because you are not reporting load temp from TAT 100% load.

I have never seem a temp difference between 2 cores as large as your (mine is uaully 2-3 degrees at tidle) but then I haven't been around here for very long.

Profile: newbie
More Information

Ok, I've tested with TAT both cores at 100% for 10 minutes and my MAX temps was 68 for CPU 1 and 71 for CPU 2.

Profile: journeyman
More Information

I'm at about the same place as you. I'm scared to turn up the speed any higher. In fact I think I will be lapping my cpu this weekened...damn concave e4300's.

Profile: newbie
More Information

Quote :

I'm at about the same place as you. I'm scared to turn up the speed any higher. In fact I think I will be lapping my cpu this weekened...damn concave e4300's.



Please, keep me posted about the result of this!

Profile: enthusiast
More Information

Before you lap, it appears that TAT and the latest Core Temp build (0.95) assume a tjunction max of 100c on this chip. Intel has not made it clear whether the actual tjunction max is 85c or 100c or something else. IF the tjmax of the e4300 is 85c then TAT is overreporting temps on this chip by an average of +15c. Until Intel gives us more (oh I gotta :D ) intel, hold on to your warranty. Your chip is probably fine.

Tenacity & Attention to Detail
Profile: Faithful Poster
More Information

From the Core 2 Duo Temperature Guide:

Quote :

Specifications

Intel's Thermal Specification: http://processorfinder.intel.com/d [...] Spec=SL9S8

Thermal Specification:

* The thermal specification shown is the maximum case temperature at the maximum Thermal Design Power (TDP) value for that processor. It is measured at the geometric center on the topside of the processor integrated heat spreader.

X6800 = 60.4c, Vcore max = 1.3525, TDP = 75w
E6700 = 60.1c, Vcore max = 1.3525, TDP = 65w
E6600 = 60.1c, Vcore max = 1.3525, TDP = 65w
E6400 = 61.4c, Vcore max = 1.3525, TDP = 65w
E6300 = 61.4c, Vcore max = 1.3525, TDP = 65w
E4300 = 61.4c, Vcore max = 1.3250, TDP = 65w
** For processors without integrated heat spreaders such as mobile processors, the thermal specification is referred to as the junction temperature (Tj). The maximum junction temperature is defined by an activation of the processor Intel® Thermal Monitor. The Intel Thermal Monitor’s automatic mode is used to indicate that the maximum TJ has been reached.

Desktop C2D's = 85c
Ambient Temperature = 22c
Idle to Load Delta Max = 25c
Tcase + 15c = Tjunction
Thermal Sensor Accuracy = +/-1c



At 200 Mhz FSB, Core Temp may detect an E4300 as a Mobile C2D, which is Tjiunction 100c, as are the Quad Core's.

Hope this helps,

Comp

Profile: enthusiast
More Information

Thanks compu :D . This means that TAT and Core Temp 0.95 do read high on the e4300 by an average of +15c because they assign the tjunction max of 100c to this chip. 8)
(heres the actual e4300 link)
http://processorfinder.intel.com/d [...] Spec=SL9TB
Check out the Vcore numbers. I think I'm going to do some more undervolting :mrgreen:

Profile: journeyman
More Information

CoreTemp 0.94 for my e4300 listed Tjunction as 85 and core temps were 15-deg below TAT. CoreTemp 0.95 lists Tjunction as 100 and temps agree with TAT.

I though the consesus was that TAT was reading e4300s correctly?

Profile: enthusiast
More Information

:D

Profile: journeyman
More Information

Right now my e4300 is at 2.7-GHz and 1.325 volts.

It is idling at ~44 according to TAT.

If your 15-deg offset were true...then my core would be idling at 30-deg C. According to Compu, the Tcore to Tcase temp difference is roughly 15..which means my Tcase would be 15 deg...maybe 20 deg. But that's less than the ambiant of 23-deg in the room.