SLI - is it for me?

Forum Graphic & Displays : Graphics Cards - SLI - is it for me?

Tom's Hardware: Over 1.4 million members in 6 different countries available to answer all your high-tech questions. Sign up now! Its free!
Word :    Username :           
 

I currently run 1900X1200 Resolution on my 24in LCD. Im looking at building a new PC and wondering if SLI would be worth the money in my case. I will be running a Intel Core 2 Duo E6600 Conroe 2.4GHz OC'd to 3.1 with 2g of ram. Was looking at getting a 8800gts. I play alot of MMORPG and FPS games.

Would i better off going with 2x8800GTS 640mb in SLI? or a single 8800gts 640mb? or just spend less money on a SLI board and go with the 8800GTX?

I guess what im asking is what is my best bang for the buck solution?

Edit - removed the 8800gts 320mb card as it will not perform as well at the resolution i am running.

Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.

Unless you want to shell out big money for two GTXs in SLi, I'd say skip the SLi board and get a single GTS or GTX. The GTS should be able to handle just about anything right now. Maybe not Oblivion on the highest AA settings but for all intents and purposes it'd be a great gamer.

Reply to jeff_2087

Thanks Jeff. I just heard anything with large resolution gets a big benefit from the SLI. Will the 8800GTS 640mb or the GTX allow me to run most games at 1900X1200 resolution with a great framerate? While i love my 24in lcd, it sucks its native res is 1900X1200. Any other setting just dont look near as crisp.

Reply to forge

rule the 320 out entirely.. SLI or otherwise. At such a high res, your biggest problem is going to be onboard video memory.

Also, remember that SLI does *NOT* double your video memory, only the processing power. With this in mind, I would suggest the GTX, as I believe the highest video memory aperature would be your highest priority. Processing should be more than adequate with only one GTX (as opposed to superior processing power of 2 GTSs), but the memory will allow you to push the boundaries further, which at your resolution, you'd be doing.

Ideally for you, SLI GTXs would be the option, but that's quite an expensive option to consider.


EDIT: further, I suggest you read this review:
http://www.tomshardware.com/2007/0 [...] index.html

Notice how the GTS 320 (especially overclocked) stays right in line with the the 640 GTS and GTX and lower resolutions, but at 2048x1536 and up it DRAMATICALLY decreases. This goes right in line with what I'm saying. The processing power is right up there with the higher end cards, but the memory aperature is it's chokepoint when it comes to resolutions, which is what you are worried about.

In truth, you'd be getting the GTX more for the memory than for the processing power of the card.

Reply to Phrozt

nice read, thank you very much. Ya the 320mb is definatly out for what i need.

So i should prob forget about using an SLI board and use the extra money towards the GTX card?

Reply to forge

Remember that 8950 will be released arround may. That is dual 8800GTS on a single card for 650 dollars.

I will use that for my 2580x1600 display replacing a SLI 7900GTX setup.

Reply to shompa

Why not get a SLI mobo (P5N32-E SLI) and a 8800 GTX now, and another 8800 GTX later when you have saved some more cash and the card is cheaper and the newer games are more demanding? That's my plan, at least, I hope it makes sense...

Reply to dsidious

I don't think you really need the GTX, the GTS should play pretty much everything on max quality settings (but not full AA/AF). But if you can afford the GTX, it'd definitely give better performance. I wouldn't worry about overflowing 640mb of graphics memory, by the time you get there the processing power would almost certainly be handicapping it at that point too.

As for the SLi board for an upgrade later, it's a possibility but don't bet on the GTX dropping in price. The 7800GTX never did when the 7900 series came out, it just became outdated and expensive.

Reply to jeff_2087

I've read somewhere that the 7950 GX2 didn't do well at all in SLI mode, and the 8950GX2 is expected to have the same problem. That is, if you want serious power you are better off with two 8900 GTX in SLI rather than two 8950 GX2. It's all guesswork, of course, maybe the 8950 GX2 won't have the problem. Anyway, can hardly wait to see it :lol: :lol:

Reply to dsidious

Quote :


As for the SLi board for an upgrade later, it's a possibility but don't bet on the GTX dropping in price. The 7800GTX never did when the 7900 series came out, it just became outdated and expensive.



That sucks... But good to know, thanks! I guess it all depends on ATI's R600 now. If it turns out to be horrible then yeah, there's no need for nVidia to drop its prices.

Reply to dsidious

Well for all I know maybe it will drop in price, I certainly hope it does because I want one. I'm just saying, that didn't happen with the 7800 so I wouldn't count on it happening this time either.

Reply to jeff_2087

just thought i'd add my tuppence worth as reference.

i have a crossfired system and a 24" dell. whilst alot of games are fine with it, some like oblivion with max settings can still result in pretty low(around 30's).

also some games like stalker at the moment do not support crossfire(not sure about sli) so buying a dual GPU setup doesn't always work.

IMO one gtx would be better than dual gts's.

JMO of course and i personally would wait for ATI to release their offerings.

which games exactly do you play?

Reply to strangestranger

All the BF series, Oblivion, World of warcraft, Mediviel 2 total war, and rome total war mostly.

Reply to forge

ya that sounds like a good plan. Atleast in the future i have some room for growth. But, like my current system. By the time my video card is getting dated, so it my CPU and Ram, which equals a new motherboard in most cases.

Reply to forge

If you want to sustain your res w/high quality in oblivion, I'd pick 1 EVGA GTX and then step up to the 8900 when it comes out.

Reply to Phrozt

your assuming that it will comes out before the three months are up.

i do agree with the 1 GTX though. at that res you need all the power you can get.

Reply to strangestranger

r600 is predicted to hit in may... so the 8900 would still have a whole month *after* that to come out (even though they would probably release it right at the r600 drop). Either way, EVGA still makes excellent cards... so either you have an excellent card and you're forced to keep it.. or you have an excellent card and you can trade it in. Win win, really.

I did hear that there were rumors that they would extend their step up *past* the 90 days, until they actually *did* release a better version if you bought a gtx though...

Reply to Phrozt

where are you reading that the 89 series are going to be coming out any time soon?

Reply to strangestranger

Quote :

no seriously now.



It's not just me....

Quote :

Looking at this card it would only make sense if Sapphire sticks to its preliminary pricing schedule of $300-350. R600 is due to hit next month and Nvidia is planning the next range of cards between now and R600. The possibility of being able to hook up two cards in a "QuadFire" configuration would be cool. I hope Sapphire can get it working or even better, I hope that AMD would choose to help support it.



http://www.tomshardware.com/2007/0 [...] page9.html

Reply to Phrozt

yes next range i.e 8600 and the like. you know the mid range, the cards where the money is :roll:

jesus your even more stupid than i thought.

Reply to strangestranger

Quote :


jesus your even more stupid than i thought.



*you're


The author doesn't say 8600, he says "next range," meaning anything from just 8600s, to just 8900s, to both at the same time.

Reply to Phrozt

yes, but logic and history, which seeing as how long you have been part of these forums you should know a bit about, dictate that there is always a mid range launched before a next gen or refresh.

nvidia need to lauch a successful mid range to recoup their costs rather than launch a new high reange which will not get them as much money.

seriously. the author's meaning is clear to anyone who follows the news.

Reply to strangestranger

Personally, I think their midrange is already here with the advent of the 8800GTS 320. I'm calling the "range" mentioned in the article their new, top of the line products; to match ATI's top of the line products.

But time will tell.

Reply to Phrozt

Quote :

I currently run 1900X1200 Resolution on my 24in LCD. Im looking at building a new PC and wondering if SLI would be worth the money in my case. I will be running a Intel Core 2 Duo E6600 Conroe 2.4GHz OC'd to 3.1 with 2g of ram. Was looking at getting a 8800gts. I play alot of MMORPG and FPS games.

Would i better off going with 2x8800GTS 640mb in SLI? or a single 8800gts 640mb? or just spend less money on a SLI board and go with the 8800GTX?

I guess what im asking is what is my best bang for the buck solution?

Edit - removed the 8800gts 320mb card as it will not perform as well at the resolution i am running.



If you're not in a hurry I would wait till the R600 is out and see how Nvidia counters their prices. But if you're in a hurry, then get a single 8800 GTX. One excellent card is better than two good cards in SLI. Plus when the 8800 GTX goes down in price, you can always buy another one for SLI :P

Reply to nightscope

if you have the $$$ go sli. if you are asking the question, this means that you are willing to take the plunge. just ask yourself: "is 40-50% more performance worth $550?"

Reply to Chef_Boyardee

8800GTX or wait until R600 or 8900GTX

Reply to darkangelism

if you can, wait. no one knws what will happen in the gpu world. but if you ask me, ati has been dominant since the 9700 came out. nvidia owned all since voodoo happened. long story short: if there is competition, let them duke it out. considering how bad the x1950xtx spanks the 7900gtx, i feel it imperitive to wait for the r600. and i bet you $1.000.000 the 8900 will come out soon after.

just find out which flagship is better. the 8800gtx or the r600. then you will know. other than that, watch some jessica biel movies to tide you over.

Reply to Chef_Boyardee
Tom's Hardware > Forum > Graphic & Displays > Graphics Cards > SLI - is it for me?
Go to:

There are 1048 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Please mind

You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.

Add a reply Cancel
Sponsored links
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them