Unfortunately, while Corsair's premium lines are top-notch, their ValueSelect line is no better than generic RAM (except for the good warranty). They just contract it out to the cheapest bidder and then slap a Corsair label on it.
I'd say the Patriot is definitely better.
I won't disagree on this. In that case, the similar offer from Kingston would be more interesting: same warranty, similar prices, and all the chips I have tested were very good and stable.