Sign in with
Sign up | Sign in
Your question
Closed

Which is the best cad/cam/cae design software

Last response: in Apps General Discussion
Share
Anonymous
March 10, 2010 6:23:22 PM

PTC Pro/Engineer Wildfire
Score
0

Best solution

a b 1 Email
March 11, 2010 12:31:42 AM

Depends upon what purpose you going to use.

For making just 2D drawings AutoCAD is enough.

If you are a beginner and wants to learn 3D tool means go with Solidworks.

If you are looking for an ultimate professional software with enormous options in surfacing etc. means go for CATIA.

Pro/E is too complicated for beginners. It has more options but will take more time than other tools to learn.

For general usage, I suggest SOLIDWORKS.
Share
Related resources
March 30, 2010 8:15:47 PM

Best answer selected by fahim_09.
Score
0
March 30, 2010 8:20:21 PM

thanks saren

can you guide me in choosing a software which is best for indian companies or which is in demand
Score
0
a b 1 Email
April 4, 2010 8:03:20 AM

As being a mechanical design engineer from india, i would prefer you to go with solidworks as first choice.

Pro E/ Unigraphics both comes as Second.

If you wanna go with automobile based design means, go with Catia.

Thanks for Selecting mine as Best answer! :) 

Score
0
July 22, 2011 8:23:20 PM

fahim_09 said:
fam_1987[at]yahoo.in

hi,

may I suggest you visit TopSolid web site. (Removed by Mod).
you will find a complete CAD and CAM sytem like PTC, Solidworks is limited to CAD and mainly prismatic shape for free form they need outside software like Rhino witch is good for the money but poor in quality.
also I recommande you look at a solution that is integrated it save you from the deasagreement of version realse of the different product witch is never in sync. 1 cant read the other.

Good luck in you quest.
Score
0
July 22, 2011 8:58:28 PM

It totally depends on what type of work you are doing... and how complicated/involved it is.

First, it is very dependant on what kind of design engineering you will be doing. Are we talking about single component designing here (couplings/machinery/etc.) or are we talking whole Plants (Refineries, Mills, Mine Process Plants, etc.)

Secondly, it also depends on whether or not you will be doing mainly 3D or 3D work. I will try and summarize below.

If you are only looking at a design engineering software for 2D work and drawings, then I would suggest Autocad for your use.

If you are looking at software for 3D work then it depends on the first factor of what scale projects you are working on. If you are only looking at single component design then I would strongly suggest Solidworks for you. It is a MUCH easier program to use than Autocad, and like I said is very suited for single components. However, if you are looking at designing an entire mill/process plant/ etc... then I would strongly urge you to not use Solidworks. It simply can't handle large projects and like many other engineering firms, you will find that simply cannot perform. For larger projcts I would suggest Autocad and possibly even CADWorx.. which runs through Autocad. I have used Autocad for large engineering projects over the years and it performs quite well.

I hope that helps... but without any details it's hard to suggest a program for you.
Score
0
July 26, 2011 11:41:07 PM

This topic has been closed by Area51reopened
Score
0
!