Tom's Hardware > Forum > Graphic & Displays > ATI > x1950xt - stock: noisy & hot - which fan?

x1950xt - stock: noisy & hot - which fan?

Forum Graphic & Displays : ATI - x1950xt - stock: noisy & hot - which fan?

Tom's Hardware: Over 1.4 million members in 6 different countries available to answer all your high-tech questions. Sign up now! Its free!
Word :    Username :           
 

The card sounds like a Boeing in-game (Sapphire x1950xt PCIe)

3 questions:

1) Does ATI Catalyst report correct temp? (60º idle currrently)

2) What is a good fan to replace the stock with?

3) See this link for a pic of the stock-fan removed: http://www.tekbunker.com/forums/showthread.php?t=1922

I need to cool the core chip AND the RAM modules outside? - the standard fans only have core-cooling, or am I mistaken?

Thats all for now, any help appreciated.
cheers,
James

Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.

I believe a few of the ram arent cooled, if not all. Idle at 60 is high, but just a lil. Whats your ambient (inside,house) temps? Is your card dirty? Have you cleaned it lately? And how loud is it compared to when you power up your rig? If its just as loud, then your fans running 100% and thats not good unless its your ambient. Try taking the side off your rig, and running it that way. And let more cool air in. Maybe another fan blowing on the card or (with side removed) fan blowing cool air into rig. If you go with a different hsf/cooler, the air will dump into your case heating up all your components, instead of the stock cooler which pushes all the hot air out the back.

------------------------------ I went drifting, thru the capitols of tin, where men cant walk and cant freely talk, and sons turn their fathers in
Reply to jaydeejohn

Inside temps are 21 - 24. Airflow is good, tidy cables etc. OC'd an e6400 from 2.1 > 2.9 GHz and temps are all low, running normal stress tests.

I have done nothing with the card since purchase (its 4 weeks old) - maybe remove the stock, clean and apply new grease as it must've sitting on the shelf for a while now?

The fan isnt running 100% at idle, but I can hear it whine-up when I start playing [any] game. Considering Ive got 4 case fans & 1 CPU fan running pretty fast (just finished My First Fisher-Price OC & havent slowed them yet) it will be even more noticeable when I bring their speeds down?

Reply to jimmytheknife

If its any like my 1900xt, its loud. Reading that link you provided, the guy there says its a lil quieter than the one I have. As long as your temps on the card arent going too high, then this is how loud this card gets, its a loud card and hot. nVidia pushes only half the heat out of the case, the way my 8800GTS is setup, it allows for more airflow or thruput of air. Keeps the card cooler, less noisy, BUT, dumps heat into my case. If you feel this wont be a problem, then go ahead and get a cooler, but for me, I live with the noise. BTW, so not to confuse, I own both a 1900xt 512mb and a 8800GTS

------------------------------ I went drifting, thru the capitols of tin, where men cant walk and cant freely talk, and sons turn their fathers in
Reply to jaydeejohn

Thats a good point about dumping heat in the case. Seems the GPU gets a lot hotter than the CPU, so it could raise temps quite a lot inside if i switch to non-stock cooling.

I guess Ill just have to suck it and see..can always revert back.

Many thanks for your help! :)

Fan suggestions still welcome from anyone! thanks

Reply to jimmytheknife

Don't know if this helps or not, but I shoehorned a Arctic Cooling NV5 onto my X1950pro Agp and am having good results. (Yes you read that right, an Nvidia cooler on an Ati card)

The problem with this approach is that this cooler is no longer available.

I have a hard time understanding why more aftermarket vga coolers aren't designed to exhaust out the back of the case.

Reply to B7X7-900

jimmytheknife wrote :


1) Does ATI Catalyst report correct temp? (60º idle currrently)

2) What is a good fan to replace the stock with?



1) Yes, these cards run hot

2) The HR-03 is the best 3rd party VGA cooler as far as I know. Buy a quiet 92mm fan to go with it and prepare to be impressed.

Reply to ethel

I recently put an aftermarket heatsink on a 9800xt, no fan just a huge heatsink, seemed to do the trick. I only changed this as my cousin's hsf was failing. You would need a decent sized case though as the 'sink is bigger than the card. The model I used was rated for all ati cards excluding the x1950xt.... (And quite a few Nvidia cards as well)

http://www.arctic-cooling.com/vga2.php?idx=138


Message edited by ooral on 07-27-2007 at 03:43:13 PM
Reply to ooral

ethel wrote :

1) Yes, these cards run hot

2) The HR-03 is the best 3rd party VGA cooler as far as I know. Buy a quiet 92mm fan to go with it and prepare to be impressed.



That heatsink looks the business - passive better results than stock? - think I will be buying a fan though :lol:

cheers

Reply to jimmytheknife

Yeah, you will need a fan. Good luck with it.

Reply to ethel

Thermalright HS & fan arrived this morning - Ill post some pics and temps when I get a chance to fit it.

Reply to jimmytheknife

The idle temp is now 44º, with load (ATITool) running just over 70º. This is about a 20º reduction.

I mounted the heatsink around the card (there are 2 fitting methods) and the fan draws the heat up, and out the top/back of my Antec P180.

As a quick reference, I got the temps before and after at the CPU heatsink.

BeforeStock (heat venting out the expansion slot) ~32º
After HR03 (heat venting into case) ~38º

Reply to jimmytheknife

And it's quiet now as well :)

Reply to ethel

Its a lot quieter.

Some pics here for reference [on how not to install!]

http://homepage.ntlworld.com/james [...] s/x1950xt/

Fir st attempt involved mounting the fan at the bottom and blowing upwards [and causing some major air currents]

On my second attempt, switched the heatsink/fan round and drew the air up instead (rig_install_final3&4.jpg) Much better result with airflow and case temps.

However, in both scenarios, the whole thing takes up 4 expansion slots - not bothered at the moment, but I wouldnt have room for any other cards if required. Id like to see this used in a dual-card config :)

Reply to jimmytheknife
Tom's Hardware > Forum > Graphic & Displays > ATI > x1950xt - stock: noisy & hot - which fan?
Go to:

There are 1147 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Please mind

You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.

Add a reply Cancel
Sponsored links
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them