Tom's Hardware Forums » Storage » Hard Disks » raid 1: chance of two drives failing in power outtage
 

raid 1: chance of two drives failing in power outtage




Word :   Username :  
 
Bottom
Author
 Thread : raid 1: chance of two drives failing in power outtage
 
Profile: stranger
More Information

In my home i have had over time two drives failing. Once probably due to wear and tear when i was still powering down systems each day, and once after a power outtage (head crash probably).

Now I am planning to build a xen virtualized home gateway | file server | workstation. This system will be on 24/7 so the power on wear and tear doesn't apply. I am thinking of buying two Samsung Spinpoint F1 single platter 320GB drives and put them in a matrix raid configuration having the last 133GB or so in Raid 1 mirroring. The itunes library it will be serving will be backed up on an usb drive but the idea is to avoid down-time in case of drive failure. I want to avoid that the family is without internet while the system is reinstalled.

I was wondering however what the chance is of both drives crashing in case of a power outtage. If this chance were fairly high it would make the raid 1 idea moot. it might still protect in case of another random drive failure wich could always happen, though i couldnt tell the likelyhood of that either.

any thoughts?

Related Product

Register or log in to remove.

Profile: old hand
More Information

If the power goes out or the psu blows there is a chance it can take hardware with it. So yes....If a PSU blew or a pretty bad power surge hit your rig it could end up frying any amount of your hardware...

 

Your best bet would be to get a surge protector for your rig. Buy a power tap surge protector and have your rig powered by it. Also make sure you get a tier 1 or 2 power supply for reliability. It costs a bit more then cheap PSU's but it at least guarantees a reliable PSU running the rig. Those are really the only 2 choices....Raid 1 is mostly for wear and tear dying..If a drive happens to fail you have a backup..But power surges and dying psu's are a different story...they can just take out a few pieces of hardware...none...or your entire rig...you just happen to get lucky or unfortunately unlucky...

 

Hope that helps...


Message edited by Kamrooz on 09-22-2007 at 06:10:36 PM
Profile: journeyman
More Information

If you're worried about power outages I'd get a UPS for the computer.

Profile: addict
More Information

I believe both the previous posters have valid points and that your reasons for looking into raid are also valid. If you're experiencing power outages then you're most likely also getting inconsistent voltage and frequency. Look for a UPS with line conditioning to keep both voltage and frequency within limits as well as provide backup power. As far as RAID, if power fluctuations cause problems with hardware, it can also fry your motherboard. Since most of us at the consumer level use the onboard RAID controller, a motherboard failure means we need to find a motherboard with the exact same RAID controller in order to reconstruct the array.


  Tom's Hardware Forums » Storage » Hard Disks » raid 1: chance of two drives failing in power outtage

Go to:
 

Google Ads
Ad
News

RocketGuard 100 monitors temperature, alerts about failing PSUs

Published on February 07, 2006

HighPoint Technologies, makers of RocketRAID line of RAID controllers, has released the RocketGuard 100 monitoring card which keeps track of chassis temperature, fan and power supply health. The little card can be mounted anywhere within the computer case and has connectors to HighPoint's RocketRAID cards and chassis alert LEDs. Using the included software, users can set alert limits and be emailed when a fan fails or when the case reached a certain temperature. Read more

WD Updates 7200 Rpm 2.5" Hard Drives

Published on June 02, 2008

WD today announced its Scorpio Black series of 2. Read more

Thermaltake introduces NAS-RAID drive storage system

Published on July 28, 2006

Thermaltake introduced its Muse N0001LN NAS-(Network Attached Storage-) RAID drive storage system. Read more

Hitachi Aims Low-power Hard Drives At Consumer Electronics

Published on May 28, 2008

San Jose (CA) - We have been hearing a lot lately about low-power hard drives and Hitachi GST is only the latest company to continue the trend. Read more

Latest Reviews & Articles

Atom, Athlon, or Nano? Energy-Savers Compared

Published on October 03, 2008

We compared Intel’s Atom 230 and VIA’s Nano L2100 processors hoping to find the best product for low-power applications. VIA is in the vanguard of performance. Is this enough to beat Atom? Read more

Interview: Bigfoot's Killer NIC, Exposed

Published on October 02, 2008

Since its release, the Killer NIC has garnered a reputation for being an extravagant and largely unnecessary add-on for the do-it-yourselfer. Seeking additional insight, we approached the card's designer. Read more

Seagate's 1.5TB Barracuda: Bigger And Better?

Published on October 02, 2008

Seagate is the first hard drive vendor to offer a 1.5 TB drive in the 3.5” form factor. Meanwhile, WD sent us its RAID Edition 3 (RE3) drive. We tell you which is the best HDD choice today. Read more

Updated CPU Charts 2008: AMD Versus Intel

Published on October 01, 2008

The processor is the heart of your PC, and our updated charts for Q3 2008 show 54 of them competing in terms of performance. Using our updated suite of benchmarks, compare your favorite AMD and Intel CPUs after reading this introduction. Read more