Someone please recommend me a good AGP graphics card for under $100 (bang for the buck), with a requirement of 300w PSU or less. I prefer the ATI Radeon or Geforce series. I have looked at Tom's Hardware site already but both the Radeon X1650 PRO (GDDR3) and the GeForce 7600 GS require at least 350w PSU (I'm pretty sure). Thank you for your help . I am not planning on buying a new psu.
Please help
- Thread starter Crisp
- Start date
-
- Tags
- Motherboards PCI Express
mactronix
Judicious
- Sep 17, 2006
- 7,928
- 1
- 32,115
Ok so coulpe of questions.
Im assuming this is a replace/upgrade so what was in it before?
Do you know what the amps on the 12v rail of the psu are? its not that important as the 7600gs should run on a 300watt psu any way but its good to check either google the make and model or take the side of the case off and have a look ther will be a sticker on the side of the psu.
Micromac
Im assuming this is a replace/upgrade so what was in it before?
Do you know what the amps on the 12v rail of the psu are? its not that important as the 7600gs should run on a 300watt psu any way but its good to check either google the make and model or take the side of the case off and have a look ther will be a sticker on the side of the psu.
Micromac
Kawi Saibot
Distinguished
- Aug 9, 2007
- 38
- 0
- 18,530
For safety, try upgrading your PSU first.At least 350 Watt or above.
For graphic card, choose ATI X1650Pro since it used GDDR3.The Nvidia 7600 GS used DDR2 only (depends on brand, such as Asus EN7600 GS TOP uses GDDR3).Also, it depend on what resolution you want to play.
For graphic card, choose ATI X1650Pro since it used GDDR3.The Nvidia 7600 GS used DDR2 only (depends on brand, such as Asus EN7600 GS TOP uses GDDR3).Also, it depend on what resolution you want to play.
double_helix
Distinguished
- Jun 27, 2007
- 92
- 0
- 18,630
mactronix
Judicious
- Sep 17, 2006
- 7,928
- 1
- 32,115
I would say your being a bit premature there emp it kinda depends what the op is upgrading from as to if there is anything out there that is worth upgrading to.
There must be loads of people out there with 2+year old AGP systems that just want one more roll of the dice and a bit more performance before they make what could be a very big purchace for some people in upgrading to a whole new system.
Mactronix
There must be loads of people out there with 2+year old AGP systems that just want one more roll of the dice and a bit more performance before they make what could be a very big purchace for some people in upgrading to a whole new system.
Mactronix
emp
Distinguished
- Dec 15, 2004
- 2,593
- 0
- 20,780
There's nothing "premature" or "immature" about it, Im calling it like it is, if you want to game those 2 year old midrange cards are barely cutting it as it is, Im not saying they are not good cards, Im saying that they are not worth paying for them anymore.
And if you want an HTPC then you're looking probably for a HD 2400Pro, 8400GS, or 8500GT build.
There is life left in AGP systems, but it comes with a cost and requirements, a cost that the OP is not willing to pay. Having a DECENT PSU has nothing to do with being selfish/whiney/immature or whatever you want to call it, it's only the very basic need of a computer.
And if you want an HTPC then you're looking probably for a HD 2400Pro, 8400GS, or 8500GT build.
There is life left in AGP systems, but it comes with a cost and requirements, a cost that the OP is not willing to pay. Having a DECENT PSU has nothing to do with being selfish/whiney/immature or whatever you want to call it, it's only the very basic need of a computer.
mactronix
Judicious
- Sep 17, 2006
- 7,928
- 1
- 32,115
Where on earth did you get "immature" from im only pointing out that as we dont know what base Crisp is starting from then its a bit early(premature)to say that there are no agp cards worth getting for less than $160.
Suppose Crisp has only onboard graphics that would mean that just about any dedicated card would be a worthwhile improvement.
Mactronix
PS
Dont know what your problem is but this.
"Having a DECENT PSU has nothing to do with being selfish/whiney/immature or whatever you want to call it, it's only the very basic need of a computer."
Is bang out of order i never said anything about. "selfish/whiney/immature or whatever you want to call it,". Dont know wher you got it from as i said and Do Not appreciate the implication of your post that i did.
Suppose Crisp has only onboard graphics that would mean that just about any dedicated card would be a worthwhile improvement.
Mactronix
PS
Dont know what your problem is but this.
"Having a DECENT PSU has nothing to do with being selfish/whiney/immature or whatever you want to call it, it's only the very basic need of a computer."
Is bang out of order i never said anything about. "selfish/whiney/immature or whatever you want to call it,". Dont know wher you got it from as i said and Do Not appreciate the implication of your post that i did.
emp
Distinguished
- Dec 15, 2004
- 2,593
- 0
- 20,780
I misread your post Im sorry, thought you implied something else. My mistake.
Anyway, my point still stands, regardless of what he already has, using a PSU of less than 300W (Or even slightly above 300W) in this day and age is not a very good sign of anything. PSUs are the most basic thing on a computer and should never be overlooked.
He should provide more information about his uses then (Im assuming gaming, since he said the best card), but we're not miracle workers here, we have to call it like it is, right now no AGP card except 7900/X1950 is worth buying to inject some life to an AGP system, since the only somewhat acceptable AGPs systems left are probably S939 systems.
Anyway, my point still stands, regardless of what he already has, using a PSU of less than 300W (Or even slightly above 300W) in this day and age is not a very good sign of anything. PSUs are the most basic thing on a computer and should never be overlooked.
He should provide more information about his uses then (Im assuming gaming, since he said the best card), but we're not miracle workers here, we have to call it like it is, right now no AGP card except 7900/X1950 is worth buying to inject some life to an AGP system, since the only somewhat acceptable AGPs systems left are probably S939 systems.
mactronix
Judicious
- Sep 17, 2006
- 7,928
- 1
- 32,115
Appology accepted 
The point you make is valid from a gaming point of view and even if not gaming then it would make sence to do the psu upgrade and get the most performance you can out of an old system ,but crisp did say he didnt want to go that route so i guess we have to work with what we got.
Just have to wait and see if Crisp comes back with some more info.
Mactronix
The point you make is valid from a gaming point of view and even if not gaming then it would make sence to do the psu upgrade and get the most performance you can out of an old system ,but crisp did say he didnt want to go that route so i guess we have to work with what we got.
Just have to wait and see if Crisp comes back with some more info.
Mactronix
Here is some more info:
I am upgrading from a Geforce2 MX/MX 400; I bought this computer more than 5 years ago, and I wish to keep it for a few more years
Mainboard: Intel D845EBG2
Processor: Intel Pentium 4 2000 MHz
768MB Ram
And here is my PSU:
MODEL NO: ATX-300TA
AC input: 115/220-240v~,7/3.5A, 60/50Hz
DC output: 300w (+3.3v & +5v=120w max)
+3.3v.....20.0A (ORG) ,+5v....20.0A(RED),+12v1...8.0A(Yel)
+12v2....14.0A(Yel/black),+5Vsb...2.0A(PUR P),-12V...0.8A(BLUE)
Are there any more specifications I should mention?
I am upgrading from a Geforce2 MX/MX 400; I bought this computer more than 5 years ago, and I wish to keep it for a few more years
Mainboard: Intel D845EBG2
Processor: Intel Pentium 4 2000 MHz
768MB Ram
And here is my PSU:
MODEL NO: ATX-300TA
AC input: 115/220-240v~,7/3.5A, 60/50Hz
DC output: 300w (+3.3v & +5v=120w max)
+3.3v.....20.0A (ORG) ,+5v....20.0A(RED),+12v1...8.0A(Yel)
+12v2....14.0A(Yel/black),+5Vsb...2.0A(PUR P),-12V...0.8A(BLUE)
Are there any more specifications I should mention?
emp
Distinguished
- Dec 15, 2004
- 2,593
- 0
- 20,780
I don't get why you would want to upgrade your graphics card then, you already have dedicated graphics card so you don't have to submit to onboard graphics. Also your PC has zero chance at doing any gaming at this stage. If what you want is to turn it into an HTPC, I'd suggest waiting until (and if) Ati or any of its partners release an HD2400/2600 in AGP flavor, probably add 512mb more of ram for now... best thing you can do. AND GET a DECENT PSU IN THE MEAN TIME!
kpo6969
Distinguished
- May 6, 2007
- 1,144
- 0
- 19,290
joefriday
Distinguished
- Feb 24, 2006
- 2,105
- 0
- 19,810
I use a 250 watt PSU for my Penitum D 805/Ti 200 rig. You're over-reacting.
Crisp :
Here is some more info:
I am upgrading from a Geforce2 MX/MX 400; I bought this computer more than 5 years ago, and I wish to keep it for a few more years
Mainboard: Intel D845EBG2
Processor: Intel Pentium 4 2000 MHz
768MB Ram
And here is my PSU:
MODEL NO: ATX-300TA
AC input: 115/220-240v~,7/3.5A, 60/50Hz
DC output: 300w (+3.3v & +5v=120w max)
+3.3v.....20.0A (ORG) ,+5v....20.0A(RED),+12v1...8.0A(Yel)
+12v2....14.0A(Yel/black),+5Vsb...2.0A(PUR P),-12V...0.8A(BLUE)
Are there any more specifications I should mention?
I am upgrading from a Geforce2 MX/MX 400; I bought this computer more than 5 years ago, and I wish to keep it for a few more years
Mainboard: Intel D845EBG2
Processor: Intel Pentium 4 2000 MHz
768MB Ram
And here is my PSU:
MODEL NO: ATX-300TA
AC input: 115/220-240v~,7/3.5A, 60/50Hz
DC output: 300w (+3.3v & +5v=120w max)
+3.3v.....20.0A (ORG) ,+5v....20.0A(RED),+12v1...8.0A(Yel)
+12v2....14.0A(Yel/black),+5Vsb...2.0A(PUR P),-12V...0.8A(BLUE)
Are there any more specifications I should mention?
A great upgrade for you would be an FX 5200. No, it's not near as powerful or new as the x1650 pro or 7600 GS, but you should be able to snag one off ebay for as little as $15, and it probably won't consume any more power than that old Geforce 2 MX. You'll also be able to play a lot of games you currently cannot due to lack of DirectX 8 and 9. As an added bonus, your computer would then be capable of running Windows Vista with full Aero Glass effects, if in the next few years you decide to upgrade to vista.
An extreme gamer like yourself can't understand the casual gamer. An upgrade to a video card with even Directx8 support would open up a ton more games for him to choose from. Sure, it won't run Crysis, but his rig with a modest video upgrade will allow him to play the entire GTA series, Call of Duty 1 and 2, a lot of the Battlefield titles, Counter Strike, and last but not least, Lego Star Wars. I mean, who doesn't want to play Lego Star Wars? There's a ton of games out there that just won't play on a Geforce 2.
Honestly, I think he could even get away with running a 6600GT on that 300 watt PSU without having to worry, but at that point his old 2GHz P4 would be a major bottleneck.
double_helix
Distinguished
- Jun 27, 2007
- 92
- 0
- 18,630
Exactly the card I said!! nVidia GeForce FX 5200. Maybe I got the FX and 5200 turned around, but meant the same card! I actually used it on an old HP/AMD 866Mhz machine and now have it on my multipurpose P4 2.0Ghz PC!! 6600GT wouldn't be bad card and he should be able to run it off 300 Watts easy.
joefriday
Distinguished
- Feb 24, 2006
- 2,105
- 0
- 19,810
I'm gonna have to disagree with you Cleeve. 6600GT is better than 9800, even besting the 9800 Pro. Also, the prices for the two are almost the same, due to a combination of Ebay being flooded with AGP 6600GTs, forcing their prices down, while the 9800 Pros, for no other reason I can think of other than nostalgia, maintained the prices they had since last year, bringing them both to the $50 mark. I had to decide between the two recently, and ended up going with the 6600GT. I purchased a nice used Leadtek A6600 GT TDH off ebay two weeks ago, still with all its CDs, games, and cables inside the original box, for the paltry sum of $56 shipped (pretty much the going rate for a pristine AGP 6600GT, bare cards can be had $10 less). The 9800 Pros were going anywhere from $45 to $65 dollars, bare cards.
Anoobis
Splendid
- Feb 4, 2006
- 3,702
- 0
- 22,780
The 7600GS is more power efficient than either a 9800 or 6600GT. It may cost more than the either, but it will also outperform both.
However that being said I would agree with Cleeve. A used 9800 Pro off eBay would be the best compromise. The cost would be minimal, which is what you want for a system this old and it's light years ahead of the OP's current graphics setup so their experience will still be enjoyable.
If the OP wants new, the the 7600GS is the way to go but if they want best bang for buck, a used 9800 Pro is the ticket.
However that being said I would agree with Cleeve. A used 9800 Pro off eBay would be the best compromise. The cost would be minimal, which is what you want for a system this old and it's light years ahead of the OP's current graphics setup so their experience will still be enjoyable.
If the OP wants new, the the 7600GS is the way to go but if they want best bang for buck, a used 9800 Pro is the ticket.
TheGreatGrapeApe
Champion
- Feb 18, 2003
- 20,043
- 0
- 50,960
My only reservation about a used R9800, is that while it's good price/performance, those new SM3.0 only games are potentially going to be a sticking point at some time (like Bioshock, RainbowSix Vegas, etc).
For that reason alone a cheap X1600 or GF7600 on AGP would be the way to go IMO.
For that reason alone a cheap X1600 or GF7600 on AGP would be the way to go IMO.
TRENDING THREADS
-
-
News Windows 11 will reportedly display a watermark if your PC does not support AI requirements- Started by Admin
- Replies: 17
-
-
Question Can I plug a docking station to a USB-C 2.0 port to have video output?- Started by jameli
- Replies: 2
Facebook
Twitter
Instagram