Tom's Hardware > Forum > CPU & Components > Other Components > Why do Mac's Weigh More?
Word :    Username :           
 

Every Mac that I pick up is noticeably heavier then PC's that I pick up. Why?

------------------------------ And on the third day, God created the Remington bolt-action rifle, so that Man could fight the dinosaurs. And the homosexuals.
Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.

Because Macs have an heat to energy condenser which is made of steal ( about a pound ) and the warp coils weight a bit too. On the bright side, this allows the system to reach warp 4, faster then and IBM clone system which is limited to impulse.

------------------------------ Handing out A+ certs like they are candy. Want some? Here, take a handful.
Reply to CompTIA_Rep

Can you please support your question with references regarding weight for the computer in question and at least 3 counter examples supporting your claim?

Dell/Gateway/Compaq/Hp???

------------------------------ Handing out A+ certs like they are candy. Want some? Here, take a handful.
Reply to CompTIA_Rep

Yeah... The Dell Optiplex 740, my personal PC, my old PC (a cyberpowerpc build... first and last), dell Optiplex 560, Dell Optiplex 580, I would have to find the old Compaqs (at work we are phasing them out), from what I can understand any home dell, hp, compaq, acer, or e-machine. I am excluding the XPS from this list cause that is heavy as hell.

------------------------------ And on the third day, God created the Remington bolt-action rifle, so that Man could fight the dinosaurs. And the homosexuals.
Reply to spaztic7

So you can use them as a boat anchor

Reply to turboflame

Maybe because there is a brick of Steve Jobs marketing **** in the bottom of every Mac?

Reply to StevieD

darn they censored my word

I thought I modified the word enough to get past the censors

Reply to StevieD

lol, i love you guys. But na, I am seriously woundering why they are heavier. I can understand the older one that is the crt monitor and computer all in one. But even the tower (when they had just towers) is heavy. I know this can't be becuase they use better quality cause my pc has much high quality parts in it then a mac.

I am not trying to flame mac, I am actually thinking of getting a mac book in a few years if they fix their keyboard issue, cat pad (the pad use move your fingure over), and weight problem. I also don't like that they mac book is so heavy. I like the power options and that it just works. I don't like how warm they get... they feel a bit warmer then my vaio.

I am starting to think they have the golden poo brick of steve jobs marketing bs in them.

------------------------------ And on the third day, God created the Remington bolt-action rifle, so that Man could fight the dinosaurs. And the homosexuals.
Reply to spaztic7

Seriously the only Mac that I have actually seen up close and personal had a case that was made from Steel or thick Aluminum where as most of the Hells and Hpooo, Gatewhats and whatever else have had cases made of plastic over thin steel sheeting or plastic with a steel frame.

Maybe it is nothing more than a heavier frame and case being used.

Reply to StevieD

Apple makes their money on selling an image, not a quality product. While PC manufactures design a product that performs the best, Apple designs products that best fit their marketing image. Also, the vast majority of mac owners have little to no computer expertise. While we here would look for an aluminum case with one zillion fans, the mac owner would likely associate weight and swanky design with quality. Building a steel case with steel heat sinks makes sense for Apples' market, for they care much more about the way their product looks than how it performs. Because of this, Apple puts way more money in their case design relative to hardware than say dell or HP. Again, this is why, dollar for dollar, an Apple is an under performing machine compared to virtually any PC, and subsequently why macs feel like a brick compared to a PC.


Message edited by Osa4747 on 09-18-2007 at 06:27:32 AM
Reply to Osa4747

The Mac's i've seen have very sturdy cases made of steel, whereas the majority of IBM clones are aluminum. I know my server case is made of steel, and it's heavy as crap even for it's size.

------------------------------ The smartest people don't know the most but realize what their true knowledge limits really are. -Me
Reply to cyberjock

95% of all PC's I've ever worked on over the last 12 years are made out of steel. Aluminium is only used in high end cases, as steel is cheaper then Aluminium.

------------------------------ First computer Tandy TRS80 (1979)

"Never underestimate the power of human stupidity!"
Reply to martyjs

OK... what about their laptops? Do they use steel in their lappies as well?

------------------------------ And on the third day, God created the Remington bolt-action rifle, so that Man could fight the dinosaurs. And the homosexuals.
Reply to spaztic7

Either produce some weight values for the products you are comparing, or forget about it. Your argument makes no sense without examples.

------------------------------ Handing out A+ certs like they are candy. Want some? Here, take a handful.
Reply to CompTIA_Rep

That does it. I'm getting a scale, and weighing every Mac in the building. Results as soon as I find a scale big enough.

Reply to Sengoku

Look it up online, might save you some time :)

------------------------------ Handing out A+ certs like they are candy. Want some? Here, take a handful.
Reply to CompTIA_Rep

martyjs wrote :

95% of all PC's I've ever worked on over the last 12 years are made out of steel. Aluminium is only used in high end cases, as steel is cheaper then Aluminium.



What machines do you work on? I googled for the price of aluminum and steel, and aluminum is cheaper. I also checked out Newegg.com and looked at the first page of cases they had. Only 3 were steel, the rest were aluminum. Not trying to say you are lying or wrong, but maybe you work on servers regularly(which are usually steel I believe).

Also, is it possible that Macs and clones are made of the same material, but Macs are made out of thicker material?

------------------------------ The smartest people don't know the most but realize what their true knowledge limits really are. -Me
Reply to cyberjock

I work on a Dell Optiplex 740. I think the macs are a few years old. I work tomorrow and I will see if I can get a model off of them. I think one may be a G3.

The mac lappy is a 2007 mac book. It is a 14" screen that weighs as much as my 17" vaio. I just think thats odd.

They could be an aluminium skin with a steel frame. That could explain why it is so heavy.

And for the scale, I have one that we can use to see if they are heavier then a duck.

------------------------------ And on the third day, God created the Remington bolt-action rifle, so that Man could fight the dinosaurs. And the homosexuals.
Reply to spaztic7

CompTIA_Rep wrote :

Because Macs have an heat to energy condenser which is made of steal ( about a pound ) and the warp coils weight a bit too. On the bright side, this allows the system to reach warp 4, faster then and IBM clone system which is limited to impulse.


Off subject,
Why do Mac graphics cards SUCK?
Apple markets itself as a company for graphics and audio professionals. So why all the grapics cards suck in all Macs except the the most high-end?
The games suck to, but that is a different problem.
Any ideas will help me sleep better.
OK, thanks!

Reply to enewmen

cyberjock I am was a qualified Fitter and Turner before becoming a Computer Tech. Mild steel is generally cheaper because it's easier to find and turn in to a end product.
I don't follow market prices, because they don't always show the true value and cost of getting the metal out of the ground.
When I worked for Ford Motor Co of Australia, we were involved in making Aluminium Alloy doors for the V8 Super cars we race in Australia. The Aluminium Alloy doors were much harder and dearer to make.
Most of the cases we use are cheap mild steel cases.
I've only sold 3 or 4 case that were Aluminium, including the one I'm building at the moment and it's a Thermaltake Xaser II case. Some plastic on the front but the rest is all Aluminium http://www.neoseeker.com/Articles/ [...] aser6000a/

I've also sold a Basic Soprano Case which was steel and cheaper. http://www.xoxide.com/thermaltake- [...] black.html
Cold rolled steal

------------------------------ First computer Tandy TRS80 (1979)

"Never underestimate the power of human stupidity!"
Reply to martyjs

I am staring at that case right now (Soprano) and the plastic on the front sucks bad. Feels like a cheap case that could break if you lift it.

Hate it for other reasons too.

------------------------------ Handing out A+ certs like they are candy. Want some? Here, take a handful.
Reply to CompTIA_Rep

yeah, i notice the G4 350 we have is also pretty heavy. heavier than any of the pcs ive ever handled anyhow, at least relative to its size (about as heavy as a 17" crt or so). theyre just denser overall i guess, from whatever materials they use in the casing and design (tapping against the side of the case causes more of a thud instead of a more hollow echo). whereas most of the pc cases do infact feel flimsier, but whether they are flimsier or not is a different matter. that mac is also about 7-8 years old, so, things might have changed some between then and now as far as design.

edit: googling took me here http://lowendmac.com/ppc/g4saw.shtml

Size and weight

* Height: 17.0 inches (43.2 cm)
* Width: 8.9 inches (22.6 cm)
* Depth: 18.4 inches (46.7 cm)
* Weight: 30 pounds (13.6 kg)7


newer macs: http://support.apple.com/specs/macpro/Mac_Pro.html

Size and weight

* Height: 20.1 inches (51.1 cm)
* Width: 8.1 inches (20.6 cm)
* Depth: 18.7 inches (47.5 cm)
* Weight (standard configuration): 42.4lbs (19.2 kg)

so, the size increased some, mostly in height, and the weight added another 12 pounds, i guess without any addons, also depending on whatever other materials too.


Message edited by choirbass on 09-19-2007 at 05:00:39 PM
------------------------------ Folding@Home
Reply to choirbass

I have woundered that a little about the mac video cards. Is it that they don't need as much power to perform the same becausae of the OS efficency? But then again, how efficient is that OS? If you take a new MAC and dual boot it with XP, I have heard that the XP partition will load faster. I also don't like how the video cards have to be Steve Jobs Approved... or some BS like that.

I was also going to add that we have a few G4's at work as well. We have power mac G5's not G3's but the G4 seems heavier.

The Power Mac G5 Weight (standard configurations): 44.5 to 48.8 pounds (20.2 to 22.1 kg)
http://support.apple.com/specs/pow [...] _2005.html


Message edited by spaztic7 on 09-19-2007 at 05:18:00 PM
------------------------------ And on the third day, God created the Remington bolt-action rifle, so that Man could fight the dinosaurs. And the homosexuals.
Reply to spaztic7

i think the G3s are probably about the same as the G4s as far as design, and probably weight then too, but the G5s i dunno. yeah, it think the only problem is that the gpus need a bios flash to work in a mac to work with the MB, otherwise youll probably come up with a blank screen or something... dont know why thats needed, probably to help keep tech support narrowed if anything, to a few select pieces of hardware, just like with the OS, support is narrowed to keep troubleshooting and maintainance simpler i would think. and anything outside of that is unsupported. makes things easier... but you dont have nearly as many choices either, unfortunately.

as far as which cards are supported, they have gaming gpus that simply underperform (a 1900xt isnt bad though, tbh)... maybe just due to the smaller selection of games in general, so gaming isnt a top priority, maybe, cant see how it would make sense for them to do that otherwise... ...and the other extreme, they have non gaming gpus, that cost a lot more than any single gaming gpu available. (quadro fx 4500 is around ~$1000-2100+ on google, but its one of their choices too)


Message edited by choirbass on 09-19-2007 at 05:51:15 PM
------------------------------ Folding@Home
Reply to choirbass

who the fu*k cares....??

Reply to chikit
Tom's Hardware > Forum > CPU & Components > Other Components > Why do Mac's Weigh More?
Go to:

There are 1310 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Please mind

You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.

Add a reply Cancel
Sponsored links
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them