Tom's Hardware Forums » CPU & Components » CPUs » Any sensible upgrade for a 4200+ ?
 

Any sensible upgrade for a 4200+ ?

Add a reply



 Word :   Username :  
 
Bottom
Author
 Thread : Any sensible upgrade for a 4200+ ?
 
Profile: addict
More Information

Buying a house soon :D , so I don't plan on upgrading anything for a while.

So I've got my 8800 GTS 320, 2 gigs ram, Gigabyte AM2 mobo (no OCing), and the CPU. For better or worse.

However - I might be cough up a little $ to upgrade my CPU if the upgrade is noticable.

Is there an AM2 upgrade that would be worth the money out there? I troll sites and am always tempted to trade up CPUs but I always assume the real world improvement wouldn't be worth it (for the other components I have).

Or is the 4200+ good enough to last until the entire system is trashed?

PS - or maybe I should buy a mobo that allows OCing and keep the 4200+?

Related Pr oduct
Register or log in to remove.

Profile: member
More Information

i think that only sensible upgrade for 4200 is x2 5000+ black edition. It works at 3,0ghz without raising FSB (200MHz x 15-unlocked multyplier). It cost about 135$, and that will be enough before real barcelona "comes to town".


---------------
"You can call me Lood, Robin Lood" (Lood means crazy on my language).
I'm proud of myself,because i'm from IRAN
Profile: Eternal Poster
More Information

X2 4200 is a very good CPU, i say get a good motherboard and OC it.
What is your budget ?


---------------
XPS M1730,IntelCore2Duo T9300@2.5GHZ,2x8800MGTX in SLI,4GB DDR2 667 RAM,DUAL 250GB 7200 RPM,VISTA HP with SP1,17" with 1920x1200 resolution

"RUINED"
Profile: addict
More Information

Thanks for replies. This has been nagging at me. Do I stay with 4200+ or do I make a cheap upgrade?

My budget is flexible, but I don't want to spend more than maybe $100-$150.

I would top out at around $200 for something that would buy me some good time. But I'd rather stick to $150 or less.

@torcida - you really think a 5000+ is $135 better than a 4200+?

Message quoted 1 times
Message edited by ananan on 10-18-2007 at 11:11:32 AM
I'm proud of myself,because i'm from IRAN
Profile: Eternal Poster
More Information

X2 5000 runs @ 2.6
X2 4200 runs @ 2.2

for that $ , u have 2 options :

1_Get X2 5600
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6819103771

Or x2 6000:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6819103773

X2 5600 is cheaper and also it 200mhz doenst have noticeable difference

2_Get a new motherboard and OC


Message edited by Maziar on 10-18-2007 at 11:57:16 AM

---------------
XPS M1730,IntelCore2Duo T9300@2.5GHZ,2x8800MGTX in SLI,4GB DDR2 667 RAM,DUAL 250GB 7200 RPM,VISTA HP with SP1,17" with 1920x1200 resolution

"RUINED"
Profile: addict
More Information

Will a 5600 give me a noticeable boost in 3d intensive games?

If it won't I'll stick to th 4200.

I'm proud of myself,because i'm from IRAN
Profile: Eternal Poster
More Information

as i said x2 4200 runs @ 2.2 and x2 5600 runs @ 2.8 , 600mhz will make a noticeable difference , check out the becnmarks too :

1_http://www.firingsquad.com/hardware/amd_athlon_64_x2_5600/

2_http://www23.tomshardware.com/cpu_2007.html

3_http://www.anandtech.com/cpuchipsets/intel/showdoc.aspx?i=3038&p=7


---------------
XPS M1730,IntelCore2Duo T9300@2.5GHZ,2x8800MGTX in SLI,4GB DDR2 667 RAM,DUAL 250GB 7200 RPM,VISTA HP with SP1,17" with 1920x1200 resolution

"RUINED"
I'm proud of myself,because i'm from IRAN
Profile: Eternal Poster
More Information

as i said x2 4200 runs @ 2.2 and x2 5600 runs @ 2.8 , 600mhz will make a noticeable difference , check out the becnmarks too :

1_http://www.firingsquad.com/hardware/amd_athlon_64_x2_5600/

2_http://www23.tomshardware.com/cpu_2007.html

3_http://www.anandtech.com/cpuchipsets/intel/showdoc.aspx?i=3038&p=7


---------------
XPS M1730,IntelCore2Duo T9300@2.5GHZ,2x8800MGTX in SLI,4GB DDR2 667 RAM,DUAL 250GB 7200 RPM,VISTA HP with SP1,17" with 1920x1200 resolution

"RUINED"
Profile: addict
More Information

I checked it out. Theres no way replacing a 4200+ with a 5600+ for that $ makes sense. I can rest at ease.

Thanks again.

Profile: nimble knuckle
More Information

Yep. I would hold tight and wait til the budget allows for a new quad AMD system.

I'm proud of myself,because i'm from IRAN
Profile: Eternal Poster
More Information

no problem , so u might want to get a a new motherboard and OC it


---------------
XPS M1730,IntelCore2Duo T9300@2.5GHZ,2x8800MGTX in SLI,4GB DDR2 667 RAM,DUAL 250GB 7200 RPM,VISTA HP with SP1,17" with 1920x1200 resolution

"RUINED"
Profile: old hand
More Information

If you want a fast ass cpu then go for a 6000+ it is getting very cheap now that the 6400+ is out.

Profile: member
More Information

As i told you, 5000 black edition has a unlocked multyplier, so that makes him more "overclockable" for you. My friend OC 5000 black to 14x240=3360 with a stock cooler, and it works perfectly at 55-60 degrees. Even 6400 black edition can't work at that frequency on that low temperature. Think again. I agree with maziar that 5600 is good choice, but i stay at my choice, and thats 5000 black edition.


---------------
"You can call me Lood, Robin Lood" (Lood means crazy on my language).
Profile: member
More Information

ananan wrote :

Thanks for replies. This has been nagging at me. Do I stay with 4200+ or do I make a cheap upgrade?

My budget is flexible, but I don't want to spend more than maybe $100-$150.

I would top out at around $200 for something that would buy me some good time. But I'd rather stick to $150 or less.

@torcida - you really think a 5000+ is $135 better than a 4200+?



maybe we didn't understand each other. Not x2 5000+, => x2 5000+ black edition


---------------
"You can call me Lood, Robin Lood" (Lood means crazy on my language).
Profile: member
More Information

Only thing why 5600 is better than 5000 black is L2 Cache (2MB instead 1MB), but i don't think that will give you much more performance, unless you'll do some video editing or something like that. In games that don't matter


---------------
"You can call me Lood, Robin Lood" (Lood means crazy on my language).
Profile: addict
More Information

Is it a 4200+ or X2 4200+?

Profile: addict
More Information

Original poster:

 

You have 300 posts and you don't realize going from an AMD X2 to another AMD X2 is idiotic?

 

You want better performance buy an 8800GTX and OC your 4200+.

Message quoted 2 times
Message edited by Noya on 10-19-2007 at 12:21:31 AM
Profile: addict
More Information

Noya wrote :

Original poster:

You have 300 posts and you don't realize going from an AMD X2 to another AMD X2 is idiotic?

You want better performance buy an 8800GTX and OC your 4200+.



I apologize profusely for trying to learn about CPUs.

I know games, GPUs, and PSUs (thanks to more friendly members of this forum). Just trying to add CPUs to the list.

Besides - read my entire OP before calling me an idiot. I have no scratch to buy a GTX you dope.

Profile: member
More Information

Noya wrote :

Original poster:

You have 300 posts and you don't realize going from an AMD X2 to another AMD X2 is idiotic?

You want better performance buy an 8800GTX and OC your 4200+.



We're lucky to have you on this forum. We would be lost in space without you.
Idiotic is to call yourself "Noya", but nobody didn't mention that.


---------------
"You can call me Lood, Robin Lood" (Lood means crazy on my language).
Profile: member
More Information

do ypu belive me now? Did you see test from tom about x2 5000+ black edition. 3,3GHz for 130-135$ ?!?


---------------
"You can call me Lood, Robin Lood" (Lood means crazy on my language).
Profile: Ancient Poster
More Information

Please Read ..............
http://www.tomshardware.com/2007/1 [...] erclocker/

Lean back while reading so you don't drool on your keyboard.

You will also likely be able to eBay your old chip to make up some of the price difference.