Tom's Hardware Forums » Storage » NAS/RAID & Technologies » NAS or Windows Home Server?
 

NAS or Windows Home Server?




Word :   Username :  
 
Bottom
Author
 Thread : NAS or Windows Home Server?
 
Profile: stranger
More Information

Hi,

My sister recently lost all the stuff on her laptop and I've convinced my parents it is time for them to get something to do backups with properly. Apart from myself no-one in our house is tech-savvy so it needs to be simple and automated. There are 3 desktops (2 Vista + 1 XP) and 2 laptops (1 Vista + 1 XP) on our home network.

I have priced up a Windows Home Server using Dabs.com and ebuyer.co.uk for the parts. Using the Shuttle KPC as a basis it is possible to build the following system for approx £320:

Shuttle KPC
Celeron 420 1.6 GHz
1GB Ram
2x Samsung 500GB
WHS OEM

My question is this: Do you think the added expense of the WHS above compared to a simple NAS Hard drive is worth it? If not can anyone recommend a good networked hard drive? All those on amazon, for example, seem to get pretty mixed user reviews.

Thanks. Matt

Related Product

Register or log in to remove.

BAM!
Profile: Faithful Poster
More Information

You much better off with the WHS, as its more upgradable, and more configurable.

WHS is apparently the simplest OS for backing files up on a home network.


---------------
"The MB is 31 C and the CPU is 109 C. I think it's the CPU overheating."
Profile: enthusiast
More Information

My ½p : http://www.qnap.com/pro_detail_feature.asp?p_id=93

chookman's reasons for getting WHS are all valid. I've been there and if I had to do it all again I'd go for a QNAP TS-209 - cheap(ish), small, simple and low power usage. The downside of the QNAP is that it is not as expandable as WHS. If you do go for a WHS box don't use a "Shuttle KPC" case as they are very small so you'll be limited in the number of hard drives you can add.

Cost wise you're looking at about +- £250 for the unit + £360 for drives (2 X Seagate Barracuda 7200.11 1TB SATA2 32MB 7200RPM @180)

UD.

p.s - go for the biggest drives you can get whichever way you go.
pp.s - have a look at scan.co.uk I've been using them lately and been pretty happy.

Profile: stranger
More Information

Thanks for the suggestions. The QNAP TS-209 would seem to be a better solution than a WHS for what we require. Incidently my motivation for suggesting the KPC was that it was small. Long term expandability isn't really a major issue. My parents last PC (replaced last year) only had a 12 GB hard drive!

Why so SeRiOuS?
Profile: old hand
More Information

Hehe, that means their next pc will come with a standard 2 terrabyte hardrive and maybe a 16 core cpu, lol.

Profile: addict
More Information

This is easy:

http://www.netgear.com/Products/St [...] px?for=All

Portability, speed, redundancy, value...NAS wins on all counts.

Profile: enthusiast
More Information

Glad to hear that we've been able to offer you some ideas. Please let us know what you do and how it turns out.

UD.

Profile: stranger
More Information

Hello again.

Upon discussion with my parents we have decided to go for a dual hard drive NAS solution since they won't need any of the advanced features a server provides. I have a budget of c.£200.

I have narrowed it down to 3 choices and I would be very grateful for any advice choosing between the three. All cost approx £195 at Scan.co.uk.

- Netgear SC101T plus 2 x Samsung 500GB Hard drives
- Buffulo Linkstation pro Duo (includes 2x 500GB)
- IcyBox IB-NAS4220-B plus 2 x Samsung 500GB Hard drives

I am edging towards the Netgear since it appears as a local hard drive as opposed to a mapped hard drive. Backup software is included in all three the quality of which is largely irrelevant since Norton 360, which we have, can back up to network hard drives. Speed, special features etc.. are not important since it will be used solely as backup storage for our other pcs.

Thanks. Matt.

Profile: enthusiast
More Information

For my ½p they all look much the same - unless anybody has a specific recommendation or warning I'd go for the cheapest.

UD.


Go to:
 
  Tom's Hardware Forums » Storage » NAS/RAID & Technologies » NAS or Windows Home Server?

Google Ads
Ad
News

CES 2007: Bill Gates announces Windows Home Server

Published on January 08, 2007

You probably have computers with gigabytes maybe terabytes of pictures, songs and videos, but how do you manage it all? In his traditional CES opening keynote, Microsoft chairman Bill Gates announced the Windows Home Server and explained how the technology automatically backs up your data and makes it available through the Internet. Read more

Intel and Novell announce virtual Windows to run unmodified on Linux

Published on February 14, 2007

Novell and Intel have announced the availability of paravirtualized network and block device drivers that will allow Microsoft Windows Server 2000/2003/XP to run unmodified in Xen virtual environments on SUSE Linux Enterprise Server 10 from Novell, operating on Intel-based server platforms featuring Intel virtualization technology. Read more

Intel to restructure 1-way server product range

Published on September 20, 2006

Intel will redefine its 1-way server product range into high-end and entry-level lines in order to tune to the growing adoption of servers for personal or home office use, according to industry sources. Read more

Sales of home media servers at reach 50 million units by 2010, says Parks Associates

Published on May 31, 2006

Annual sales of home media servers will reach nearly 50 million units in the US by the end of 2010, according to Parks Associates. Read more

Latest Reviews & Articles

Part 4: Avivo HD vs. PureVideo HD

Published on September 29, 2008

The 780G chipset/Radeon HD 3200 and the MCP78S chipset/GeForce 8200 provide the first integrated graphics solutions that can accelerate Blu-ray playback. We dig deep into how well they work with high-quality Blu-ray 1080p video playback. Read more

Four GeForce 9600 GT Cards Compared

Published on September 26, 2008

Manufacturers really love the first Geforce 9. The graphic chip is fast, the cards are inexpensive, and some retailers offer more than ten variations. Read more

Maxtor's Shared Storage Does NAS At Home

Published on September 25, 2008

What do you do with all the data you collect at home? Network attached storage is the solution. We test Maxtor's Shared Storage II and find that it is also suitable for use in small businesses. Read more

SLI & Centrino 2: Gaming Laptops Battle

Published on September 24, 2008

Take four gaming laptops. Arm two of them with SLI and make the others Centrino 2-compatible. You're looking at a high-end collection of the latest mobile technology battling it out for benchmark supremacy and your hard-earned dollars. Read more