Tom's Hardware > Forum > Homebuilt Systems > New System Build > Replacing my Dead NOE2 Platinum Going Intel.

Replacing my Dead NOE2 Platinum Going Intel.

Forum Homebuilt Systems : New System Build - Replacing my Dead NOE2 Platinum Going Intel.

Tom's Hardware: Over 1.4 million members in 6 different countries available to answer all your high-tech questions. Sign up now! Its free!
Word :    Username :           
 

Hey all

I am leaving AMD and jumping back onto the the Intel Band Wagon.. :-).. I read the article on the E2160 while I was looking for a replacement for my dead AMD K8N NEO2 Platinum MB. Smoked it after trying out the Koolance memory cooler. It leaked and smoked my memory slots... My advice is don't try it, the bags are to easily ripped. Well anyway I am now looking for a new system and I want to OC. I have a Koolance PC3 720 water cooled case along with another separate full 1/2" system cooling a Swiftech MCW6500-775T CPU TEC cooler (used a 939 bracket for my FX-55), and the MCW60-T GPU TEC cooler on a 6800GT. I know I want to get a MB that has a future like the NEO2 did. I got 4 years and 5 different CPU's out of that board.. " Moment of silence please... :cry: "

Well anyway my plan is to purchase the Best Video card, Motherboard, and ram now along with the e2160 or 2180. I want to make sure though that I will be getting a MB that will be strong when I go to a Quad core chip in the future. Also I wonder if any of the MB's out now will be able to run the newer Intel CPU's with the 12mb cache that are due out soon.
So P35, X38, or 6X0i......?????
I like what I have read on the ASUS Blitz Formula and Extreme MB's, though I think DDR3 isn't for me right now.
The EVGA 680i SLI boards seem good also. So many opinions though.

GPU: I'm thinking about getting a 8800 Ultra card, but which one Im not sure. Depending on the motherboard choice though, maybe a ATI 2900. Hell for the cost of one Ultra I could get two 2900'ds. But I wonder if I would really see a difference? I've never really liked ATI, but then again I used to be a staunch AMD man.......

Memory: I like the Corsair Dominator ram, but don't see a lot of people overclocking with it so Im open to any suggestions.

This PC is just to play on. Gaming and overclocking is all it will be for.

Well I didn't mean to be so long winded. I am looking forward to chatting and learning from you all! :)

Trek6500

Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.

P35 and X38 main differenece is that X38 support Crossfire @ dual 16 mode , i recommend P35 over X38 FOR NOW, because they have the same features and they are cheaper

so if u are going with single card go for ASUS P5K-E , GIGABYTE P35 DS3R , ABIT IP35 PRO

if u are going SLI ,go for ASUS P5N32-E SLI PLUSS


for VGA, instead of 8800ultra , get a 8800gtx and OC it, even if u dont OC a 8800GTX, the difference between it and ULTRA inst noticeable

for RAM, Corsair , OCZ , Crucial ... are good brands

------------------------------ Q6600@3.4+ TT V1 Cooler,SAPPHIRE HD 4870X2,ASUS MAXIMUS FORMULA,4GB OCZ DDR2 800,LG W2452V 1920x1200
Reply to Maziar

what about the ASUS Blitz MB's?? any thoughts? Though hard to find I've read they are great OC MB's

Video wise I wonder what new cards loom on the horizon. I read that Nvidia had something new due out at the launch of Crysis.

Which speed RAM? I'm Ok spending a lofty sum on the MB, Video and RAM. I was gonna go with the e2160 or 2180 and play around with it until the dust settles in the Quad arena. So many RAM choices though. I'm looking for a solid OC capable RAM. Do you think I should go 2 or 4 GIG with Vista Ultimate 64? or stay 2 with win XP SP2?

Thanks for the return..

Reply to trek6500

ASUS BLITZ FORUMULA is a very nice board ,it has very nice reviews , and its one of the few P35 boards which support CrossFire @ dual 8x mode
http://www.pcper.com/article.php?aid=451
http://www.hothardware.com/Article [...] herboards/

If u can get it go for it, also the next nvidia card will probably be 8800GT which according to rumors (STILL NO TRUE BENCHMARKS) it will be a refresh and it may perform closely to a 8800GTS ( again all is rumor , but dont expect something faster than a 8800GTX)

for RAM, DDR2 800 is very good for OC'ng, if u have the money go for 4GB definitely , i recommend RAMs with 4-4-4-x timings , my REAPER is 4-4-4-15 and OCs very nice

------------------------------ Q6600@3.4+ TT V1 Cooler,SAPPHIRE HD 4870X2,ASUS MAXIMUS FORMULA,4GB OCZ DDR2 800,LG W2452V 1920x1200
Reply to Maziar

The art of overclocking to me is to buy the cheapest & get the most out of it. That's just me. Surely there are better overclocking products for premiums. That makes overclocking easier & ergo takes away the joy of overclocking - spending hours after hours to find the perfect combo of numbers for a stable o/c.

You want to pair a cheap cpu with a high end mobo? Why not? It'll be easy to achieve high o/c's. The low cache in the cpu doesn't matter very much for overclocking & gaming. A high o/c compensates for low cache.

I 2nd what Maziar suggested in the 1st reply:

e2180 (higher multiplier, M0 stepping = higher max temp)
ASUS P5K WIFI DELUXE (No contest. The best overall P35 overclocker, IMO)
Any DDR2 with Micron D9 chips (2x1GB is most popular. It's cheaper & faster if you memtest it. heck, some use even less ram like 256mb/512mb to save time on memtesting)
8800GTX (overclock it with rivertuner)

If you wanna leave AMD, do it. **** ATI HD 29*0. **** 'em to hell. Your OP is contradicting yourself. When Intel becomes a monopoly, we all will happily cought up $1000 for a celly. ;)

Reply to akhilles

The best P35 OverClocker is ASUS BLITZ FORMULA, P5K DELUXE and P5K-E are very good too , i recommended P5K-E over P5K DELUX becuase 1 more gigabit lan and one more copper isnt worth the $ ( P5K DELUXE is approximately $80 more than P5K-E )

------------------------------ Q6600@3.4+ TT V1 Cooler,SAPPHIRE HD 4870X2,ASUS MAXIMUS FORMULA,4GB OCZ DDR2 800,LG W2452V 1920x1200
Reply to Maziar

akhilles

I want to hit the ground running persay. As I get older I don't want to mess around as much trying different out MB's, I just wanna get to the meat and taters.. :) . I would stay with AMD, but they aren't showing me much right now. That could and will change Im sure , but now is when I want to build a new PC. No different than when 3DFX shot themselves in the foot years ago. Man I owned every damn card they made until the Geforce cards hit. I still have them sitting in a box. Just dont have the heart to throw history away. Maybe Im just a pack rat.. :pt1cable:

I have come to the conclusion throught the years that stability is everything. So I want to start with the most stable MB I can, thats all. I dont mind starting with a cheaper chip and playing with it. That gives time for the more expensive chips to come down and newer ones to come out.. I want to play games and I like the Eye candy. I have found in the past that OC'n my GPU can post great numbers in 3DMark, but suck ass in real world gaming. So I figure I'll buy the best card out. Just so happens there are a few out that look good so I thought I would ask around.

I guess I should'nt say I'm leaving AMD since I have several other PC's all running A64's. Im just ready for a change.
There are know label loyalties, just the best product for the best price..
Regards


Message edited by trek6500 on 10-24-2007 at 10:05:05 AM
Reply to trek6500

Maziar

Thanks man. I like the Formula board from what I have read, but I cant help but wonder if I'm shooting myself in the foot by getting a board that wont run SLI with a 8800GTX or Ultra. But I dont know if the 2900 is really gonna do it for me. But.... then again I could add another 2900 later on. Thats if the card is still around. Is crossfire still having problems or has ATI worked out the bugs?

Did you have to increase your memory voltage much with the OCZ memory?

Reply to trek6500

I recommend 8800GTX over 2900xt , however new drivers have helped 2900xt alot (both in crossfire and single )

about the RAM, well here is my RAM:
http://www.ocztechnology.com/produ [...] gb_edition

As u see it says 2.1 , and in BIOS i set it to 2.1 and its fine (You have to be careful when setting the voltage of the RAM, anything higher than the specs of the RAM may cause trouble)

Message quoted 2 times
Message edited by Maziar on 10-24-2007 at 12:26:43 PM
------------------------------ Q6600@3.4+ TT V1 Cooler,SAPPHIRE HD 4870X2,ASUS MAXIMUS FORMULA,4GB OCZ DDR2 800,LG W2452V 1920x1200
Reply to Maziar

Well, it's your money. I have no say in how you spend it. I'm still suggesting an Intel build if overclocking is a priority. I have both AM2 & C2D - my family pc. The C2D kicks butt at overclocking & multimedia de/en-coding.

Reply to akhilles

Well Hello to you too Mrs. Bytch.

Ya know, I could go on and on as too my ability with PC's and overclocking, but who cares.
I wont argue with you either, I know my short comings. I have read these forums for many years and finally decided to post. It seemed to me that the folks on these forums like to talk and to bounce ideas off of one another. I guess you are the exception. :)

Reply to trek6500

Maziar wrote :

I recommend 8800GTX over 2900xt , however new drivers have helped 2900xt alot (both in crossfire and single )

about the RAM, well here is my RAM:
http://www.ocztechnology.com/produ [...] gb_edition

As u see it says 2.1 , and in BIOS i set it to 2.1 and its fine (You have to be careful when setting the voltage of the RAM, anything higher than the specs of the RAM may cause trouble)



Maziar

You're probably right about the 88oo vs. the 2900. Guess I'm worried that later on I might regret on not going with an ATI card, or not having purchased a 680i SLI MB for the sheer ability to run dual cards.

I like your ram! I'm adding it to my short list! :wahoo:

Reply to trek6500

akhilles wrote :

Well, it's your money. I have no say in how you spend it. I'm still suggesting an Intel build if overclocking is a priority. I have both AM2 & C2D - my family pc. The C2D kicks butt at overclocking & multimedia de/en-coding.




akhilles

Yeah I agree with your thoughts on the C2D. I wonder if I should just go with the Q6600 and forget the E21xx series. I need to read that article on L2 cache maybe that will give me more direction in my purchase decision. I do very much appreciate your helpful input!! :)

Reply to trek6500

Def. Q6600. I play with my buddy's quad. Except his evga 680i is AR, not A1 which is best for o/cing quad.

The Q6600 at stock is plenty fast. If you o/c it, it smokes everything else. One guy here in o/c forum got it to 4 ghz on water.

Now if you're planning to upgrade the cpu to 45nm due out in Jan 2008, get a cheap cpu to play with for now & as a backup.

http://www.hkepc.com/?id=171

Reply to akhilles

akhilles wrote :

Def. Q6600. I play with my buddy's quad. Except his evga 680i is AR, not A1 which is best for o/cing quad.

The Q6600 at stock is plenty fast. If you o/c it, it smokes everything else. One guy here in o/c forum got it to 4 ghz on water.

Now if you're planning to upgrade the cpu to 45nm due out in Jan 2008, get a cheap cpu to play with for now & as a backup.

http://www.hkepc.com/?id=171



Yeah man thats what I was thinking about originally doing, but it seemed that so many people had one thing or another that they didn't like on the EVGA MB's. I could get the e2180 for now with and EVGA 680i SLI and a 8800gtx or ultra card. Im just not sure which one.

You say the A1 huh?

What about this EVGA Black Pearl MB. Already setup for water cooling..

Reply to trek6500

I had this MB bookmarked at Newegg I wonder if the Black Pearl is just the A1 with water cooling.

http://www.newegg.com/product/prod [...] 6813188013

What kind of temps are you guys seeing on your OC'd Nvidia cards?


Message edited by trek6500 on 10-25-2007 at 05:05:53 AM
Reply to trek6500

trek6500 wrote :

Yeah man thats what I was thinking about originally doing, but it seemed that so many people had one thing or another that they didn't like on the EVGA MB's. I could get the e2180 for now with and EVGA 680i SLI and a 8800gtx or ultra card. Im just not sure which one.

You say the A1 huh?

What about this EVGA Black Pearl MB. Already setup for water cooling..



get tge e2180 with rvga 680i with a 8800GTX, i have told u many times that 8800ULTRA is an OC'd 8800GTX,and u can always OC a 8800GTX to beat a 8800ULTRA (look @ mine ) and even if u dont OC a 8800GTX , the difference isnt noticeable , if u dont believe me , here are becnhmarks :
http://www.guru3d.com/article/Videocards/428/
http://www.pcper.com/article.php?a [...] ype=expert
http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/v [...] treme.html

Lows:
Relatively small advantage over GeForce 8800 GTX;
The cooling system casing may not let you install this solution onto some mainboards;
May be incompatible with some mainboards/chipsets;
Relatively modest accessories bundle;
High price.

------------------------------ Q6600@3.4+ TT V1 Cooler,SAPPHIRE HD 4870X2,ASUS MAXIMUS FORMULA,4GB OCZ DDR2 800,LG W2452V 1920x1200
Reply to Maziar

Maziar wrote :

get tge e2180 with rvga 680i with a 8800GTX, i have told u many times that 8800ULTRA is an OC'd 8800GTX,and u can always OC a 8800GTX to beat a 8800ULTRA (look @ mine ) and even if u dont OC a 8800GTX , the difference isnt noticeable , if u dont believe me , here are becnhmarks :
http://www.guru3d.com/article/Videocards/428/
http://www.pcper.com/article.php?a [...] ype=expert
http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/v [...] treme.html

Lows:
Relatively small advantage over GeForce 8800 GTX;
The cooling system casing may not let you install this solution onto some mainboards;
May be incompatible with some mainboards/chipsets;
Relatively modest accessories bundle;
High price.



Yes I agree I wasnt thinking when I wrote that. What I meant to say was which 8800GTX to get. I have Ultra on the brain for some reason. Heck the money Ill save will go towards the OCZ Reaper 4GB set. :pt1cable:

Reply to trek6500

Sorry the Black Pearl is just out so not many people have experience with it, let alone overclock it. A1 is guaranteed best 680i. Though evga is best at customer service, they will replace the non-A1 with A1. Probably just pay one-way shipping. I'm not sure if a watercooled & used board can be replaced.

Reply to akhilles

Before you set your ideas in stone consider this. Plan for the future 2 years or so.

MOTHERBOARD - Purchase an X38 motherboard. I recommend the ASUS Maximus Formula SE. PCI-E 2.0 slots, x16 in both PCI-E slots. Cheaper DDR2 ram. Matrix RAID(read up on this if you are unfamiliar with it) You can use your cooling system on the northBridge of this motherboard as the block is included. It also comes with a great sound card from what I hear from others - etc, etc, etc. The bundle they give you is quite fantastic.

GPU - Go ATI!!! Their new drivers 7.10 really gave the cards a boost especially in Crossfire. Considering the 2900's are less than comparable counterparts the crossfire setup will give you lasting power. Since drivers are getting better and better from ATI/AMD it is a good reason to help keep them viable when you get something of value in return.

CPU - I would go for a quad 6600 with G0 stepping-That is important. This will allow you to be more dimensional than just gaming. This chip has seen an overclock to 4Ghz by a number of different people. Get good ram with the package.

Price this senario out and see where it fits then look at the performance others have gotten going with the other boards that have been mentioned. I have used all types of boards in the past and now have settled on ASUS as the first place I look, and always come back to them to make my final purchase.

Having first purchased a Dual CPU ASUS board with built in SCSI many years ago I learned that above the other retail brands ASUS was stable, fast, overclockable and would outlast other brands. When I have finished with them and move on, my kids inherit fantastic machines and the boards keep running and running.

(offtopic a little)
I currently have running for myself the following boards
1-P5WDG2-WS-Pro E4300 @ 3.2 Ghz
2-P5W64 E6400 @ 3.0 Ghz

Maximus Formula SE w/Q6600 (Dec 2007) personal christmas present.

Reply to hcforde

Maziar wrote :


about the RAM, well here is my RAM:
http://www.ocztechnology.com/produ [...] gb_edition

 

As u see it says 2.1 , and in BIOS i set it to 2.1 and its fine (You have to be careful when setting the voltage of the RAM, anything higher than the specs of the RAM may cause trouble)

 


Maziar

 

Where did you purchase your OCZ ram from? I have found the HPC version but not in 4gb cas 4


Message edited by trek6500 on 10-26-2007 at 05:38:33 AM
Reply to trek6500

well i am in Iran , and here we dont have many online shops , so i went to a store , but newegg has some :

Get 2 of these RAM :
OCZ REAPER HPC with 4-4-4-15 Timing
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6820227231

Or 2 of these:
OCZ REAPER HPC with 4-3-3-315 Timing
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6820227232

i have 4x1GB of OCZ REAPER RAM with 4-4-4-15 timings and its awesome

------------------------------ Q6600@3.4+ TT V1 Cooler,SAPPHIRE HD 4870X2,ASUS MAXIMUS FORMULA,4GB OCZ DDR2 800,LG W2452V 1920x1200
Reply to Maziar

hcforde wrote :

Before you set your ideas in stone consider this. Plan for the future 2 years or so.

MOTHERBOARD - Purchase an X38 motherboard. I recommend the ASUS Maximus Formula SE. PCI-E 2.0 slots, x16 in both PCI-E slots. Cheaper DDR2 ram. Matrix RAID(read up on this if you are unfamiliar with it) You can use your cooling system on the northBridge of this motherboard as the block is included. It also comes with a great sound card from what I hear from others - etc, etc, etc. The bundle they give you is quite fantastic.



Yes the Maximus looks nice! The PCIe 2.0 slots don't mean much to me though. I will already have purchased my video card or cards and as far as I know there aren't any 2.0 cards due out any time soon. Matrix RAID seems interesting, its been around for some time now from the few articles I have read. Do you use it? If so how does it act when overclocked?

hcforde wrote :


GPU - Go ATI!!! Their new drivers 7.10 really gave the cards a boost especially in Crossfire. Considering the 2900's are less than comparable counterparts the crossfire setup will give you lasting power. Since drivers are getting better and better from ATI/AMD it is a good reason to help keep them viable when you get something of value in return.


I still love AMD, I have a Opty 165 with a CoolIT FreeZone on it Overclocked to 2.34Ghz. Would go higher, but its my MEDIA PC and the wife likes her shows to be recorded without a system lock-up.. :p As far as ATI is concerned maybe it because I have never truly embraced them, but they have never made me go oooh. I understand and have read that they are doing much better with there driver updates, but I don't want to be a driver tester for ATI. I wish there was something that could really show me that ATI will not crap out and forsake there customers by not keeping up with driver and card support like they have done in the past.

hcforde wrote :


CPU - I would go for a quad 6600 with G0 stepping-That is important. This will allow you to be more dimensional than just gaming. This chip has seen an overclock to 4Ghz by a number of different people. Get good ram with the package.



I like the Q6600 too, but what about the new 6 and 12mb cache chips coming out in Nov-Dec? I figured I'd get the E2180 and play with it till mid 08 and make a decision then. Thats where picking the right MB really worries me.

hcforde wrote :


Price this senario out and see where it fits then look at the performance others have gotten going with the other boards that have been mentioned. I have used all types of boards in the past and now have settled on ASUS as the first place I look, and always come back to them to make my final purchase.


You're right, it would be cheaper for me to get two 2900XTs, or a little more for the 1GBs than it would to buy one 8800 Ultra. Though as Maziar says, the Ultra is just an ocd GTX. This is the conundrum I have. If I pick the wrong MB I could be shooting myself in the foot next year if per say I went Nvidia on a Crossfire MB and ended up wanting to go SLI. Sigh decisions decisions... :??:

hcforde wrote :


Having first purchased a Dual CPU ASUS board with built in SCSI many years ago I learned that above the other retail brands ASUS was stable, fast, overclockable and would outlast other brands. When I have finished with them and move on, my kids inherit fantastic machines and the boards keep running and running.



You and I have a lot in common. I too have used several Asus boards in the past, but for some reason I have spent the past few years with MSI. "don't ask me why" all my Asus MBs were solid performers. My kids are already fighting over who gets the FX-55 and the Geforce 6800GT. :lol:

(offtopic a little)
I currently have running for myself the following boards
1-P5WDG2-WS-Pro E4300 @ 3.2 Ghz
2-P5W64 E6400 @ 3.0 Ghz

hcforde wrote :


Maximus Formula SE w/Q6600 (Dec 2007) personal christmas present.



I enjoyed your post. It is good food for thought, but it has just put me further on the fence in my decision making process. :cry:


Message edited by trek6500 on 10-27-2007 at 12:22:10 AM
Reply to trek6500

akhilles wrote :


ASUS P5K WIFI DELUXE (No contest. The best overall P35 overclocker, IMO)



No contest? Hardly, the board is somewhere in the middle for overclocking capability.

Maziar wrote :

The best P35 OverClocker is ASUS BLITZ FORMULA, P5K DELUXE and P5K-E are very good too , i recommended P5K-E over P5K DELUX becuase 1 more gigabit lan and one more copper isnt worth the $ ( P5K DELUXE is approximately $80 more than P5K-E )



Do you guys even read this site? Gigabyte makes the best-overclocking P35 motherboards. Read the E6750 overclocking article, it compares a few top boards.

Reply to Crashman

I didn't have time to read ALL the posts, but if you're not going to SLI two graphics cards, your best bet is the P35. Loads of stuff on the P35 can be found on this site, look to the E6750 overclocking article and the P35 motherboard comparison article for ideas.


Message edited by Crashman on 10-26-2007 at 10:29:11 PM
Reply to Crashman

Hey Crashman

I hope you take the time to read the rest of the posts. I really appreciate all the information these guys and hopefully you can share with me. Though I must make the purchase decision on my own, its nice talking to folks that have the same interests as I do helping to put things into perspective.

Im just being wishy-washy I guess. I know I had originally stated that I did not want to go SLI. Something inside me keeps eating at me not to close the door on the idea.

Thanks again and I will check out the articles.

Reply to trek6500
Tom's Hardware > Forum > Homebuilt Systems > New System Build > Replacing my Dead NOE2 Platinum Going Intel.
Go to:

There are 790 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Please mind

You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.

Add a reply Cancel
Sponsored links
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them