Sign in with
Sign up | Sign in
Your question

Which one of these two is better?

Last response: in Components
Share
October 30, 2007 12:14:30 AM

I'm building a new midrange gaming PC this weekend.
I am not sure which one of these to get:
Corsair VX 550W CMPSU-550VX or Corsair HX 520W ATX 2.2 (CMPSU-520HX)
My components so far are:

  • Core2 Quad Q6600+Tray 4x2,40Ghz 2x4MB G0-Stepping SLACR
  • CPZ Thermalright Ultra-120 eXtreme div.Sockel
  • DDR2 2048MB KIT PC 800 A-DATA Extrem CL4 4-4-4-12
  • Fan 3x 120x120x25 Scythe S-Flex 1200
  • S775 ASUS 4xDDR2 P5K FSB1333 P35
  • DVDB SATA NEC AD-7170S
  • MIDI Sharkoon Rebel9 Economy
  • Asus 8800gt (ordered)

    The HX is supposed to be better, from what I've read, my concern is noise level. I'm planing to OC at 3ghz (or less)
    Also should I get more fans, the case doesn't have any. It can handle 2*120mm front, 1*220 rear, 2*220 side. Noise level is also a problem here. I would love a relatively silent PC.
  • More about : question

    a b ) Power supply
    October 30, 2007 12:48:37 AM

    The HX series is made by Seasonic, the VX series is made by a company called CWT. I think CWT has been making good OEM PSUs that are rebranded (Thermaltake for example) for quite some time.

    Therefore, the HX is not only quieter, but also higher quality.

    However, you can buy the Corsair 550VX for just $63.90 at ZipZoomFly after a $20 rebate which expires on 10/31/07 so make your decision quickly.

    http://www.zipzoomfly.com/jsp/ProductDetail.jsp?ProductCode=10006757

    Corsair 550VX review from JonnyGuru.com

    There is no mention of noise level. You may need to read reviews from newegg.com to see if any users had complaints about noise.
    Related resources
    October 30, 2007 1:08:52 AM

    Where I am the HX cost about 10 Euro (14 Usd) more than the VX. Does the added expence pay off? I have found some reviews of the 550 VX, they were quite positive, but I can spare 14 bucks for better quality. So should I get the HX?
    a b ) Power supply
    October 30, 2007 1:31:22 AM

    Sorry, I didn't notice you were in Germany.

    As a current owner of a Seasonic S12 500, I can definitely say that spending the little extra for the Corsair 520HX (which Seasonic makes) is worth it.

    I'm considering another Seasonic S12 or the Corsair when I build a new HTPC.
    October 30, 2007 2:06:02 AM

    The HX is also modular, which is quite convenient to have.
    October 30, 2007 6:35:41 PM

    Thank you all. This is one fine Forum, have never dealt with such helpful people over the intraweb:) . I just ordered the HX. I really look forward to my new PC. The Asus 8800gt is also on its way. I was really lucky with that one, the shop were I got it from is out of stock till 30.11. I'll let you know how it goes, if anyone cares...:) 
    !