Hello all,
I'm looking to build a giant storage system and I'm deciding between the 3Ware 9650SE-24ML, Areca 1280ML, and Adaptec RAID 52445 for my RAID card.
After looking at it, I have no strong feeling for any one of them, maybe against 3ware since it did not outshine its competition in any particular area.
-The Areca initially has 256MB memory, compared to 3ware’s and Adaptec’s 512MB, but Areca has the ability to expand to 4GB DDR2 DIMM.
-The Adaptec has a dual core 1.2 GHz processor while Areca only has a 800 MHz, 3ware did not announce its processor speed.
-Also, Adaptec claims to have 3Gb/s Data Transfer Rate (380 MB/s), compared to Areca and 3ware’s 300MBps.
-All other features were comparable – similar software configuration solution, etc. They all cost about $1,100.
Between all 3, what do you guys think is the best spec'd? Is the advantage of buying 3.5 extra DDR2 DIMM (700% increase) greater than having 400 MHz speed of the Adaptec (50% increase)?
I guess all I'm really asking is: If I ran each card with RAID 6, which one do you think is the most stable and compatible with motherboards/hard drives, and what does the processor speed and the ram do for the RAID card?
Thank you for your help!
I'm looking to build a giant storage system and I'm deciding between the 3Ware 9650SE-24ML, Areca 1280ML, and Adaptec RAID 52445 for my RAID card.
After looking at it, I have no strong feeling for any one of them, maybe against 3ware since it did not outshine its competition in any particular area.
-The Areca initially has 256MB memory, compared to 3ware’s and Adaptec’s 512MB, but Areca has the ability to expand to 4GB DDR2 DIMM.
-The Adaptec has a dual core 1.2 GHz processor while Areca only has a 800 MHz, 3ware did not announce its processor speed.
-Also, Adaptec claims to have 3Gb/s Data Transfer Rate (380 MB/s), compared to Areca and 3ware’s 300MBps.
-All other features were comparable – similar software configuration solution, etc. They all cost about $1,100.
Between all 3, what do you guys think is the best spec'd? Is the advantage of buying 3.5 extra DDR2 DIMM (700% increase) greater than having 400 MHz speed of the Adaptec (50% increase)?
I guess all I'm really asking is: If I ran each card with RAID 6, which one do you think is the most stable and compatible with motherboards/hard drives, and what does the processor speed and the ram do for the RAID card?
Thank you for your help!