Short story: I have a Lian Li A08B case. It has one 120mm intake and one 120mm outtake fan. The intake fan has a dust filter which works nicely, but also seems to reduce intake air flow a bit.
Right now my E6850 3.0ghz at stock will idle at around 52C and when I ran the most intensive prime95 (small fft) it will shootup to about 68C. This seems way too high. I've verified the stock HSF is properly seated and I'm out of explanations besides poor airflow, but it doesn't seem THAT bad in my base. I removed the sides of my case and my temperatures were not lowered.
I just ordered the artic cooler 7 freezer pro (or whatever it's called) with the vain hope I could score an overclock to 3.6 ghz with reasonable temps (65C or below). If I try to do 3.6ghz on stock, my temps shoot up to 75C and of course, I stop the testing immediately. Most people running e6850 at stock with stock hsf don't seem to have such high load temps. Can anyone with with the same cpu/case or similar chip in?
Thanks.
Message edited by EricVPI on 11-23-2007 at 05:00:38 AM
Seems a bit high, but not too high that the system will become unstable. The first thing I would do is check to see what Vcore you are running at. If you have it set to auto, the MB usually set voltage quite high at stock settings. My P5B on auto had a Vcore of 1.42 or so when it was set to auto on the stock clock speed.
I have and E6420 @ 3.0 (1.355 Vcore with 8+ hours of Prime 95 stable) and with the stock HSF and my Antec 900 (2 front 120's, one rear 120 and a larger exaust on the top) and my system will idle on average at 33-35 depending on ambiant. At load, it will not increase past 57-58 C. Mind you, after switching to the 900, my core temps dropped 5-7 C on average across the board from a generic no fan case.
Let us know what your Vcore is set at, as that would be my first bet for the higher temps.
Message edited by ibanezrg570 on 11-23-2007 at 05:42:21 AM
---------------
Core 2 Duo E6420 @ 3.2 ghz
SAPPHIRE HD2900XT (aka. The Fire Hazard 2)
2 Gigs Corsair DDRII 800 XMS2 DHX 4-4-4-12
Soundblaster X-Fi Platinum
I have it set on auto, but on auto-voltage according to CPU-Z my CPU actually uses less voltage (1.1-1.2v). If I set my voltage manually to 1.3125 (or whatever the default) is the temperatures stay about the same or actually increase a degree or two under load.
I think perhaps I need to replace my 120mm fans with higher CFM ones, but then the noise level will certainly increase. Also how necessary is that dust filter on the intake?
I opened up the sides of my cases, though, and that didn't improve the coretemp readings at ALL. Maybe the thermal interface material on my stock hsf was fubar?
Message edited by EricVPI on 11-23-2007 at 07:48:33 AM
I can do a quick test, using TAT. Keep in mind TAT pushes the CPU harder then anything.
I use an E4400 OC to 3ghz. I use a Zalman Fan controller (up to 6 fans), so my front/rear/CPU/Side fans are adjustable. Turning the fans all down, using TAT:
Ambient temp 78F or 26C
Speed Fan
Tcase - 63-64C
CoreTemp
Core0 - 75C
Core1 - 75C
Ran over 5 mins
Fans on Full Speed:
Speed Fan
Tcase - 58C
Core0 - 68-69C
Core1 - 68-69C
Took another 5 mins to get it cooler. Hope that helps.
Sorry man, I have an AMD system, but I have been working on a similar problem for about a year.
AMD 5600+ AM2
Biostar Tforce 590 SLI
Sunbeam Silent Storm Case
8800 GTS Video Card
My System has 2 120mm intake fans in the front, a side 120mm intake fan, a 120 mm exhaust fan, and my power supply fan exhausting out of the top back.
My CPU temp problem is now under control actually. It was idling at around 45-50C but it is now down to around 35 to 40. I fixed this problem by making a duct in my spare 5 1/4 drive bays to bring in fresh air directly over my cpu.
My Northbridge idles at about 55C all the time. Nothing I do can change this. The problem I am having is that I have no airflow in the bottom of the case and no way to do so without significant case modification. I have 120mm intake fan on the bottom, but do to poor case design the air never reaches the northbridge, GPU, or Sound Card. I do have crashes due to this temperature issue.
I have tried numerous fans, slot fans, and even reseating all heatsinks with AS5 to try ad combat the heat problem. I am now saving up to buy an antec 900 as there is nothing more I can do to try and save this case.
So to answer in your question, in my experience case air flow is very important to control your temps. Without proper airflow, anythign short of a water cooling system will bea waste of money.
Heh, well I forgot to mention, I don't use any dust filters. Front fan is 140mm, side, cpu and rear are 120mm.
I figure I'm going to end up dealing with dust anyways.
I only have one intake 120mm and one outtake 120mm, and as I said the intake has a dust filter. I don't know the specs of the fans because they came with my computer. Right now at stock my coretemps max under load at about 68C. I wonder what they would be like after I install my arctic cooler freezer 7 pro, but with the same case circulation.
Message edited by EricVPI on 11-23-2007 at 09:29:03 PM
Whelp, taking out the filter will increase the airflow. The Freezer Pro should be in line with the rear exhaust, so it should help out even more.
Just play around with it. Take the filter out now and see how it helps. The only real main factor is your ambient temp. My temps on load would be lower if my room was 70F rather.. 78-80F.
@ericvpi: Since your temps with an open case did not go down, it would appear that case cooling airflow is not the problem. If you direct a house fan into the works, do you get the same result?
The stock heat sink is supposed to do an adequate job, but that assumes no overclocking. In my experience, an aftermarket cooler is much better if you are overclocking, or if you want less noise. The thermalright ultra120 extreme is the best one out there right now. Anandtech tests several coolers: http://www.anandtech.com/casecooli [...] i=2981&p=3
As I am now typing this, speedfan shows my E6850(stock) with the thermalright at 34c. I used arctic silver 5.
Message edited by geofelt on 11-23-2007 at 09:45:17 PM
---------------
E8400-stock, GA-P35-DS3R(rev2.1), Corsair 4x2gb 6400C5, EVGA 8800GTS-512-G92, Vista home premium-64-bit, WD velociraptor-300gb, PC P&C silencer-610, Antec SOLO, 2 x Samsung 275T, Samsung-203b-dvd
(B) Masscool Shin-Etsu X23 can reduce CPU temps by ~ 4c compared to Arctic Silver 5, which is far more popular than it is effective. The first link shown below is to a very in-depth Thermal Interface Material (TIM) comparison that was posted 2/2/07 on Tom's Overclocking - Cooler and Heatsinks Forum, which was conducted by DaSickNinja. This 6 page thread is very revealing, however, the review has been moved to the second link shown below, Xtreme CPU.
Note: Due to Tom's servers forcing asterisks in the link below, when clicked it will cause "This page cannot be displayed". Simply backspace the 3 asterisks and type x-c-p-u-s without hyphens, then press enter.
Masscool Shin-Etsu X23 Thermal Interface Material (TIM) can reduce CPU temps by ~ 4c compared to Arctic Silver 5, and is simply the best TIM for CPU cooling.
Silverstone TJ09 case here w/ 5 120mm fans, the QX6850 w/ box cooler reads 28 - 35C, superior case imo. I think the huge difference is that the PS is on the bottom of the case away from the CPU not emitting more heat in that area. Considering that heat rises the 2 fans ontop of the case are very effective at removing heat from the case. It's great having a fan strictly for cooling the video card(s) and one for the HD(s). Besides the fact the case is rather huge, more space for working on components and allowing excellent airflow.
Ever since the 775 socket came out, the 4 push pins on the HSF generally cause over heating problems. In my opinion, the 4 pins just plain suck. The best way to be sure the pins are through, is to take the MB out and look at the backside of the MB: