Tom's Hardware Forums » Graphic & Displays » Graphics Cards » HD3870 Crossfire Vs. 8800GT SLI review
 

HD3870 Crossfire Vs. 8800GT SLI review

Add a reply



 Word :   Username :  
 
Bottom
Author
 Thread : HD3870 Crossfire Vs. 8800GT SLI review
 
Profile: enthusiast
More Information

http://en.expreview.com/?p=53
 
 
Im surprised the Crossfire did so well! I was expecting it to suck as everywhere I read they say the drivers need improvement? 100+% scale in 3dmark?  Anyone care to question the validity of this review?
 
*please no price gouging comments

Message quoted 2 times
Message edited by wirelessfe nder on 11-27-2007 at 10:55:58 PM
Related Pr oduct
Register or log in to remove.

Profile: Honorary Veteran of THGC
More Information

I seriously considered dual 3850's or 3870's, but have concerns with compatibility/stability.  This review paints a prettier picture of crossfire than other reviews. I don't doubt potential fr large gains, but how much frustration will there be inbetween.  Thye sure got decent gains though.  


---------------
MSI P6N SLI Platinum, Q6600, 2GB Crucial Ballistix Tracer PC8000,  
SLI BFG 8800GT OC 512MB, SB X-Fi Fatality, Antec TruePower Trio 550W, Windows XP pro
Profile: Honorary Poster
More Information

F&#*$ price gouging... heh, j/k
 
Seriously though... I didn't expect such gains from Crossfire vs. Single. Crossfire even faired pretty well vs. SLI.


---------------
* Athlon 64 x2 5000+  *  8800GTS 640MB * ASUS M2N-E SLI *
* Silencer 750 Quad    *  2x1GB PC6400   * Creative X-Fi Extreme Gamer 7.1 *
* Antec 900 (Sexy)    * LG GGC-H20L (Blu-ray / HDDVD-ROM) * Razer Lachesis
BAM!
Profile: Faithful Poster
More Information

That looks awesome... i was looking at HD3850's has anyone seen Crossfire scalings on these?


---------------
"The MB is 31 C and the CPU is 109 C.  I think it's the CPU overheating." - Faromic THF's
Profile: journeyman
More Information

chookman wrote :

That looks awesome... i was looking at HD3850's has anyone seen Crossfire scalings on these?


 
http://www.anandtech.com/video/showdoc.aspx?i=3151
 
2 3850s = the performance of 1 8800GTX 768MB/384-bit
179.99 x 2 = $359.98                                 $500.00
 
I am going to put 2 3850's for my last upgrade on my A8R32-MVP Deluxe (S939) AMD Opteron 165 @ 3.0ghz & 4gigs of Patriot CL 2-2-2-5 1T and see how it handles Vista & DX10 (I hope physics processing will be possible..)
 

Profile: nimble knuckle
More Information

I found LOTS of links about the 3870 X2s !!  The r700 is closer than I thought.
It will be available in February...So rumors say.
The 10.1 also makes the ATI cards a little more future proof as well.
I'm itching to upgrade my X1950XT !!

Message quoted 1 times
Message edited by enewmen on 11-28-2007 at 01:01:21 AM
Just my two frames' worth.
Profile: Graphic Gorilla
More Information

wirelessfender wrote :

http://en.expreview.com/?p=53
 
 
Im surprised the Crossfire did so well! I was expecting it to suck as everywhere I read they say the drivers need improvement? 100+% scale in 3dmark?  Anyone care to question the validity of this review?


 
I wouldn't question the vaidity as it seems similar to what many others were reporting, but it is still a semi-iffy site, but there's nothing gravely out of whack, the single numbers on the HD3870 are still lower than the single numbers on the GF8800GT, and the Xfire numbers are a little better but nothing wildly so with the GT doing better in some and the HD3870 doing better in others. I'd want a little more supporting evidence before formulating opinions in general, but interesting none the less.
 
I'm with Paul about the stabilty/compatability issues with such setups though, still a bit iffy.
 

Quote :

*please no price gouging comments


 
Aww, C'mon!   :kaola:


Message edited by TheGreatGr apeApe on 11-28-2007 at 01:06:25 AM

---------------
You need a license to buy a gun, but they'll sell anyone a stamp (or internet account) - RED GREEN. GA to SK
HD Freedom: 45 5F E1 04 22 CA 29 C4 93 3F 95 05 2B 79 2A B2

Just my two frames' worth.
Profile: Graphic Gorilla
More Information

enewmen wrote :

I found LOTS of links about the 3870 X2s !!  The r700 is closer than I thought.
It will be available in February...So rumors say.
The 10.1 also makes the ATI cards a little more future proof as well.
I'm itching to upgrade my X1950XT !!


 
Funny thing is I'm already itching to upgrade the new HD2600 mobile solution, but it's more an issue of other factors than just the graphics, but with the possability of a new R700 single core mobile solution by spring/summer when I shop for new gear, that's looking very interesting, especially if it can give me near/above HD3K performance. Otherwise the Hd3K and G92 based mobile solutions may be the attraction.


---------------
You need a license to buy a gun, but they'll sell anyone a stamp (or internet account) - RED GREEN. GA to SK
HD Freedom: 45 5F E1 04 22 CA 29 C4 93 3F 95 05 2B 79 2A B2

"Double quarter pounder"
Profile: Honorary Poster
More Information

Surprising performance by the 3870 to me.


---------------
I wish everyone at my high school could be mature enough to talk PC hardware not just gaming.  You're unique... just like everyone else.

 

OddJob's side-kick!!
Profile: Honorary Poster
More Information

What I can tell from that is that nvidia have seriously rubbish sli drivers for half life 2!
 
And Lost planet!  
 
ATI is kicking ass if that is true... now if only their crossfire 3/4way scaled as well, they'd be on a winner, for once.


---------------
Na na na na na na na na HATMAN!
Profile: enthusiast
More Information

Crossfire really flexes it's muscles with AA and AF. I dunno 'bout you guys, but that makes me a lot more inclined to get two of those cards.

Profile: nimble knuckle
More Information

The CROSSFIRE numbers are good,but you'll notice the SLI setup is still faster.So ya,CROSSFIRE has good potential,but AMD/ATI still needs to beat out NVIDIA.
 
Dahak
 
M2N32-SLI DELUXE WE          
X2 5600+ STOCK (2.8GHZ)          
2X1GIG DDR2 800 IN DC MODE        
TOUGHPOWER 850WATT PSU          
EVGA 7950 GX2 550/1350        
SMILIDON RAIDMAX GAMING CASE          
ACER 22IN WS LCD 1680X1050          
250GIG HD/320GIG HD          
G5 GAMING MOUSE        
LOGITECH Z-5500 5.1 SURROUND SYSTEM      
500WATS CONTINUOUS,1000 PEAK        
WIN XP MCE SP2      
3DMARK 05 13,685    

Profile: enthusiast
More Information

This review definatly made me happy, As a X38 owner the only option for multi GPU's is with crossfire. Im glad that the cards are doing well as I already have a 3870 on the way. My plans are to get the second whenever the prices return to normal.
 
*THAT does not count as a price gouging comment!

Just my two frames' worth.
Profile: Graphic Gorilla
More Information

Dahak wrote :

The CROSSFIRE numbers are good,but you'll notice the SLI setup is still faster.


 
In what game?
 
Seems like they trade blows, and even with AA.
 
HL2 without AA Xfire wins, with AA SLi wins.
UT3 low res SLi wins, high res Xfire wins no AA
COJ DX10 Xfire wins them all including AA
Lost Planet DX10 SLi wins them all  
ETQW Xfire wins them all including AA
COH SLi wins without AA, Xfire wins with AA :heink:
 
So if you don't include the Bungholiomark results then Xfire slightly outperforms SLi on average, but including 3Dmk then they are even.  


---------------
You need a license to buy a gun, but they'll sell anyone a stamp (or internet account) - RED GREEN. GA to SK
HD Freedom: 45 5F E1 04 22 CA 29 C4 93 3F 95 05 2B 79 2A B2

Profile: member
More Information

I dont think people realize that the bench marks of two cards, and not of CF and SLI. The fact that a Slower card (3870) is in most cases keeping up, and sometimes beating a faster card (8800gt) show how much better CF is. The 8800gt is supposed to be somewhere around 20% better than a single 3870. But when you have a dual setup, the 3870's are on par with 2 8800gt's. And knowing that SLI is limited to only 2 cards, and CF can have up to 4 helps even more. 4 3870's would be faster than 2 8800gtx's.


Message edited by RealiBrad on 11-28-2007 at 02:18:21 PM
Profile: member
More Information

Intel's chipsets will be a saving grace to AMD! Theres decent value in getting two 3850's or 3870's and putting them in your Intel box. SLI has yet to be licensed to Intel but Crossfire has been, currently is, and will continue to be. Nvidia isn't planning on licensing SLI to Intel any time soon either. Am I the only one that sees the irony in this?
 
http://www.nordichardware.com/news,7050.html

Profile: old hand
More Information

I wish SLI and Xfire were both cross-compatible since I'm on a SLI board.  I still wouldn't get 2 3870s though but it sure looks enticing.


---------------
E6600 (B3)-HD4850 512MB GDDR3-2GB DDR2-800
"You figured it out. All new CPU's are nothing but overclocked Pentium 1's with a few bells and whistles added, ask any ol timer whose been around."

 

Profile: member
More Information

It is pretty ironic. But i would have to think that amd planed this. As much as people were saying that getting ati was a bad idea, it might just be its saving grace. Rich Arabas dosnt hurt either. Intel is in a pickle though. It wants to push AMD as far out of the market as it can with out becoming a monopoly. But if Intel sells more chipsets that are CF, it helps AMD as well. It was a very smart move to get ATI if AMD knew that there cpu's wouldnt be able to keep up with intel's. This way, they can feed off of the success of intel while they try and fix there company.

Profile: nimble knuckle
More Information

Link is down.
 
I have read other reviews and from what I can tell Crossfire seems to scale just a little bit better than SLI. As usual, it depends mostly on the game, with some games actually taking a performance HIT. Because of this application-dependent nature I still don't count either solution as being practical or cost-effective.
 
I will give my blessing to the first multi-GPU solution that scales almost linearly in EVERY application. I have read that ATI is working on an alternate frame rendering mode that is supposed to be application independent under DX9. I don't think it's ready for prime time yet though.

Profile: member
More Information