So is the nvidia 8800GTX in pcie x16 faster than 2x 3870’s in CF on pcie 2.0? This is assuming I’m running at 1680x1050 rez. What I am thinking about doing is buying a cheap motherboard and running the 8800gtx on it until I need to upgrade, where I will then buy another 8800gtx and a new motherboard probably the 780i or something whenever it comes out so I can run them in SLI. Is this wise? I’m afraid of the 2 8800’s hogging each others bandwidth and therefore creating a bottleneck, could this bottleneck be solved by a pcie 2.0 board even though the 8800GTX’s are pcie 1?
or could anyone post a link to a topic explaining graphic card bandwidth? I'm still not 100% sure what’s going on in that department.
Often one 8800GTX would beat two 3870's as crossfire won't always work or scale that well. I'd think more often than not, if working, the two 3870's would win.
As far as bandwidth, at 16x10 I don't think dual 8800's would chew up 8x/8x like on the 650i mobos'. From what I have seen, It seems it takes high res and/or AA levels to make the 16x/16x 680i mobos beat the 650i mobos in SLI. Here is a review I looked at when deciding what mobo I wanted for dual 8800GT's. I went with a MSI P6N SLI platinum (650i) mobo for $120.
http://www.techspot.com/review/45- [...] page4.html
Message edited by pauldh on 11-30-2007 at 12:37:38 AM
Personally i would take the single card over the two in crossfire as there is less chance of problems like compatability and as has been said some games dont support it that well if at all.
Heres another review to look at.
http://www.hardwarecanucks.com/for [...] eview.html Mactronix
Crossfire isn't working in Crysis. neither is GF8 SLI really as you get a fps boost but useless choppy gameplay. Look at the incrysis forums and you'll see multi gpu support in crysis is supposed to be imlemented in a game patch and further improved by drivers. Both NV and ATI are working with crystek on this.
Message edited by pauldh on 11-30-2007 at 11:27:27 PM
Actually crossfire scaling seems to have never been better tehn how it is atm, it works in most games and scales MUCH better on average than SLI indicated by recent reviews, Ill try to find that one.
Im pretty sure that 2x 3870's in CF should beat out a GTX most of the time.. where buggy drivers dont intervene anyway.
As said about crysis Crytek should be very close to releasing a patch if they keep to their deadline, which of corse would mean new drivers from nvidia/ati needed, hopefully this will let us quad core users to exploit what we were told would be very important in Crysis, so far quad core is useless..
Agreed hatman.
It's safe to say 2 3870's beat a GTX, in all cases where drivers are not severely bugged. And since multi GPU setups will become more important for both AMD and nvidia, drivers to support these setups will improve.
Didn't 2* 3850 allready beat a GTX in some cases?
As i said, 2 HD 3870 beat a 8800GTX in some games, but again not all games support MULTI-GPU ,
there are some games that a 8800GTX beats 2 HD 3870 :
http://www.hothardware.com/Article [...] 5nm_RV670/
In Crysis SP Demo , QuakeWars and COH , a 8800GTX beats 2 HD 3870 , if u read some artilces (including the giude i made) u will see that MultiGPU doesnt always give u performance boost
------------------------------Q6600@3.4+ TT V1 Cooler,SAPPHIRE HD 4870X2,ASUS MAXIMUS FORMULA,4GB OCZ DDR2 800,LG W2452V 1920x1200
Reply to Maziar
That statement belongs to the bug/current limitation of CF drivers at the moment. If patch from game maker or from ATI will be released CF will have obviously effect on these games. Since the game was already made before 3870 appears and the ATI havent tested its video card to all games so such limitation may arise. It is just a software problem not a hardware.
It seems rather irrelevant to mention games that weren't made ready for CF yet when talking about 2* 3870 vs 8800 GTX.
It makes most sense to look at games in which the 3870's do very well, as those games show the potential of the 3870's, while just about every game allready shows the potential of the 8800 gtx and not much performance increase will be seen in future driver versions.
That statement belongs to the bug/current limitation of CF drivers at the moment. If patch from game maker or from ATI will be released CF will have obviously effect on these games. Since the game was already made before 3870 appears and the ATI havent tested its video card to all games so such limitation may arise. It is just a software problem not a hardware.
It is very clear 2 Cards is better than 1.
With lots of benchmarks i am telling u that 2 cards arent always better than 1, and u insist on your words, then bother myself and telling u, when u dont listen to anything?
With Nvidia 2 cards are not always better than 1.AMD/ATI are now depending on there drivers to do the rest of there magic.Thats the reason for quad Xfire.The R680 will be 2 gpus on a card,the R700 will have up to four.AMD/ATI intend to make really good drivers to make these future boards work.
With lots of benchmarks i am telling u that 2 cards arent always better than 1, and u insist on your words, then bother myself and telling u, when u dont listen to anything?
This man is telling you the truth ! And don't ever expect twice the power from 2 cards . It won't happen .... it usually increases the res output and does improve the video to an extent and some framerates but make sure the extra cost and pain in the rear is what you want to use 2 .... check out all the tests with that setup first before wasting alot of money . Like stated before there are still alot of bugs in both dual card setup drivers ..... especially Crysis .... which I am totally disapointed with " CRYSIS " ... great video effects but to me lousey gameplay really . Did'nt impress me at all . Man was this game over-rated ! Oh well all those bucks I spent just to play it ..... looking for something better already ..... any suggestions ? ---- ----
You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months. If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.