I temporarily opened this thread to make a comment about the subject, I'm not overriding the moderators decision to close it, that said.
There seems to be much discussion on the right and wrong of the thing.
If the operating system is successfully installed, and Microsoft OKs activating it, well whether its a OEM Dell, Gateway, HP, Compaq, Emachines, doesn't matter in the least.
Microsoft is the owner of the operating system, if Microsoft activates it, I don't see how that could possibly be illegal, maybe they should sue themselves for activating it in the first place.
I've transferred many, many, OEM brand specific WinXP licenses to completely different hardware configurations, and Microsoft through a telephone call has activated every one of them, Microsoft has not refused to activate any of them.
So wheres the illegality in Microsoft activating their own product, when they simply could refuse to do so.
This topic is reclosed. Ryan