Sign in with
Sign up | Sign in
Your question

External drive, removed from enclosure, still recognized as external?

Last response: in Storage
October 15, 2008 8:32:26 PM

About 4 months ago I purchased a "Western Digital Elements 500GB" external HDD. For various reasons, I decided to void my warranty (by breaking the seal on the enclosure) and remove the drive (SATA) and install it to my mobo internally. It works fine, but it is recognized by device manager as "External Disk 0 ATA Device." Not too surprising, but here is the really weird part. BEFORE I hooked it up via SATA, while it was still in the enclosure hooked up via USB, it was recognized as "WDC WD5000AAKS-..."

So the drive was recognized for what it is (Western Digital Caviar 500GB) while in the enclosure, but now that it is mounted by itself internally, it's recognized as a generic external device?

Any ideas about this one? Thanks!
October 15, 2008 8:41:27 PM

It is an external hard drive. The drive doesn't know the difference whether it's in or out of the case. If it did know I would be scared...very scared.
October 15, 2008 8:57:39 PM

Then why was it recognized as "WDC WD5000AAKS" when inside the external enclosure?
Related resources
February 27, 2013 6:59:41 PM

Currently the drive is hooked up directly to your PC, via SATA connection.

"Your external enclosure contains a USB-SATA bridge board. It is connected as follows:

computer's USB port <-- USB cable --> bridge board <-- SATA cable --> hard drive

The bridge board will appear in Device Manager as a USB Mass Storage Device. "

(from this thread:
a c 878 G Storage
February 27, 2013 7:12:30 PM

some external drives, esp WD & Segates, have modified firmware on them for use in their enclosure. So what you are seeing is the bridge chip reporting the drive name vs what sata is able to get from the drive itself. It should still work fine internally, though not all external drives do.