I was thinking the exact same thing. I ended up buying the GT yesterday and it plays all my games on max so I'm happy. I bought it at a local store, so I have 30 days to make up my mind. If it turns out something better comes out at a competitive price I suppose I'll return it. But I have a feeling I'll just hold onto it.
I think gettin the EVGA version will make it worth it, that way if a better card comes out at same price within next three months you'll be able to step-up. Plus the free game is like $50 off.
I just stepped up from a 8800GTS 320 to the GTS512. If I had started from scratch, the card I would have gotten would have been the GT, but I couldn't stand the idea of "loosing" cash on a step-up [down?]. So there ya go. I agree with most assessments that put the GT at the sweeter price/performance ratio, but man, I like having 15,000 3dmarks, too.
The newegg version actually is $30 more expensive, when you consider the game is $50. Again, to me the card is at an actual cost of $300 since I'd buy the game anyway.
You can find a GTS for an even $300 after rebate at Newegg.com (leadtek) But if you need a copy of crysis, that one at tiger isn't a bad option.
Which to buy? At $240 for a 8800GT (512mb) which is a good price they have there at tiger, it is a pretty close match (and probably wins) in price to performance with the 8800GTS at $300. Either card will do just fine, but obviously the 8800GTS is higher performing, by a noticeable mark, especially when both cards are taking to their maximum overlcocks. The GTS will on average OC much higher, and you won't need to buy a ridiculous 3rd party cooler then (like you might need to get a good OC on the GT).
I guess it depends on what your budget is, both cards are good at those prices ($240 and $300). Do you want to play crysis very high at 15fps or 20 lol? =D
(w00t! My 200th post!, I need to get a life huh? =0)
Message edited by gamebro on 01-13-2008 at 08:55:04 AM
I thought about buying that 8800GT for $240, but wasn't sure on the brand. Is KFA2 a reliable brand? I haven't heard of them before. Last time I bought a card was a 7600GT and I didn't see anything of their's then, so the company can't be more than a year or two old.
Also, interesting deal on the leadtek card. Unfortunately it includes a rebate which I really hate But I'll definitely consider it.
Message edited by josiah30 on 01-13-2008 at 06:14:55 PM
(As an 8800GT owner who used a quiet & cool 320MB 8800GTS before that)I just have to say the 8800GT reference cooler is crap. Go for the 512MB GTS with crysis since you want the game anyway.
---------------
MSI P6N SLI Platinum, Q6600, 2GB Crucial Ballistix Tracer PC8000,
SLI BFG 8800GT OC 512MB, SB X-Fi Fatality, Antec TruePower Trio 550W, Windows XP pro
I have the 8800GTS G92 (the same one you are looking at, and with Crysis too) and the fan is whisper quiet even up to 50%. If you plan to overclock, definitely go with the GTS. If not, but you are concerned about heat/noise, go with the GTS. If none of these concern you, go with the GT.
I've left price out of this because your OP said you were fine with spending $300-400. This card is definitely the best in the price range. I just figured out I was having a problem with my memory that was causing games to crash so I was holding off on OCing the card, but I am planning to try soon. From what I've heard it OCs very well. I'm more than happy with it.
Sorry to hear that, pauldh. Are you at least noticing a serious speed improvement?
Oh yeah, I like the cards, just not the coolers. It seems a must to use ntune or riva to control rpm with these cards. The stock coolers are very loud when manually set to provide good cooling. I really think the 8800GT is an outstanding performer, but NV goofed on the reference cooler. In the OP's case, factor in $40 anyway for Crysis and the GTS 512MB looks like a good option. If noise isn't a concern, then the 8800GT is OK.
---------------
MSI P6N SLI Platinum, Q6600, 2GB Crucial Ballistix Tracer PC8000,
SLI BFG 8800GT OC 512MB, SB X-Fi Fatality, Antec TruePower Trio 550W, Windows XP pro