budget box under $350, already have a few things...

pianoplayer88key

Distinguished
Dec 4, 2006
101
0
18,680
I'm looking to build a budget box. I'll mostly be doing multimedia-related things (audio, video, photos) and the like. I may do a little light gaming (mainly 3+ years old), but nothing really fancy. Could you guys rate (for the price it looks like I'll have to pay) the system specs below? How much better is it than what I've been using (not my own PC though) - Athlon 1.4MHz, K6T266 Pro2 Mobo, 256MB DDR-266MHz RAM, GeForce MX400 Video, etc...

CASE: Broadway 808PA ATX with 450W PS - $29.99
MOBO: Gigabyte GA-M61SME-S2 AM2 NVidia GeForce 6100 Micro ATX - $46.99
CPU: Ath64 LE-1620 2.4GHz AM2 45W 1core - $47.00
RAM: Kingston 2GB ddr2-667 - $39.99
HD: WD5000AAJS 500GB 7200rpm SATA 3G/s - $99.99
DVD: Samsung 20X DVD+-R Lightscribe SATA - $29.99

Price with shipping & tax before rebates = $334.82
Is there any way I can save money (besides a smaller HD, which, knowing how I use it, is NOT an option) without sacrificing performance, quality, or expandability?

I don't like only having 2 memory slots on the mobo, but the ones that have 4 slots are more expensive. I could save a couple bucks by going with a Celeron 420 combo, but I don't know that it'd be worth it.
Also, with the MicroATX board, will I have a problem later when I want to add a high-end sound card (the kind that audio professionals use that have 24-channel inputs and things like that), 16 DVD drives and hard drives, 2 video cards, and other peripherals? I'd like the board to last me until the AM2 (or LGA775) socket CPU is obsolete, but if I have to upgrade (not within the next year though) I'd be willing to consider that. I DO expect, knowing my HD space usage habits, that I'll need to add another HD in a year or two. I may consider an external drive then.
Also, I'll want to keep the case and PSU for as long as possible. After a year I may be willing to consider upgrading the PSU, and the case after maybe 3 or 4 years.
I don't anticipate overclocking the current setup.

Is there anything I'm missing? I already have:
a Windows 2000 disc (I plan to get XP Professional (2-6 months) later. MAYBE Vista Ultimate or Leopard :) after service pack 5 if all the bugs have been worked out by then.)
2 western digital IDE hard drives - 250GB and 80GB, both of which are getting quite full. Also I have upwards of 75GB (and counting - I do a lot of video and audio recording and photography) on my parents' 200GB HD, of which only 127GB is allocated due to the LBA limit.
standard keyboard and optical wheel mouse - not mine, but they're not currently being used.
Viewsonic P95F+ monitor - has a magnitization problem on one side of the screen (a magnet was held too close to the screen one time and the color is permanently a little distorted on the extreme right side), but I can live with it for now. When it dies completely, or in a couple years, I'll want a high-resolution (at least 1000-1500 lines) LCD.

One thing I forgot to mention - I'm comfortable buying from NewEgg, but I'd prefer to buy from a local store in San Diego, CA, just in case (and to save on shipping).
 

teh_boxzor

Distinguished
Aug 27, 2007
699
0
18,980
looks great but windows 2000 will have the LBA limit on your 500gb hard drive so i recommend getting windows xp sp2 (if you can) or get a copy as soon as possible. also if you could, get a retail x2 3600 or x2 3800 most media software have multi-core support now so it would benefit you and dual core am2's run around 50-60 dollars...
 

pianoplayer88key

Distinguished
Dec 4, 2006
101
0
18,680
You sure the latest 2k service pack will still have the LBA limit?
Also, I'm trying to keep this as budget as possible, hence going with a low-end CPU for now. I tried to pick a socket type & board with which I could upgrade later.

BTW, that CPU I picked is a retail box version. There's a X2 3800+ OEM (but doesn't come with heatsink or fan) for $47.99 (vs the 47.00 for the CPU I picked). Also there's this X2 3600+ for $55.99 - would that work?

Also, is there a way to get XP Pro for under $100 legally?

Another thing... my credit limit is $300, and the build I'm proposing is a bit over that (and I've already spent $110 this billing cycle, which should end on the 18th). I can afford it, though. Should I pay with paypal, send a paper check, or should I limp along for a month with my current HD (dumping the 500GB HD for now will bring me down into the range I can pay with CC)?

In my original post, I said I would like to buy local. Well, I may have just changed my mind - the local prices are considerably higher than what NewEgg's charging.
 

tlmck

Distinguished
A dual core processor alternative. The dual core will help with encoding, etc... http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16819103774

A better deal on ram, albeit after rebate. Gigabyte compatible. http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16820211066

Lastly, the PSU in that case is of miserable quality. If it even boots up, I would plan on replacing it sooner than later. Since you are going with on board video, this might be a better option. http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817256019
http://www.microcenter.com/single_product_results.phtml?product_id=0247229

The case is uATX, but is very good quality, and is a lot roomier than it looks. Two 5 1/4" bays, and five 3 1/2" bays. Also has excellent airflow with the metal mesh front.

Your chosen MB will handle the addition of a sound card just fine.
 

random1283

Distinguished
Oct 26, 2007
222
0
18,680
Just get xp home edition and you should try to get intel as there is more head room to upgrade I put together this
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16819116037
[Much] more power than the AMD (dual core) $74.99
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813131162R
I had one like that very good quality $34.99
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16827118003
Still 20x but IDE which allows for the second hard drive for later on $23.99
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814127296
This graphics card isn't much, but is a hell of a lot better than onboard $37.99

the total is $171.96 plus p+h and rebates $173.28
Build would then be 361.47 (including everything) but much much better.
 

pianoplayer88key

Distinguished
Dec 4, 2006
101
0
18,680
Hmm... if I go with the original setup, that's $193.96, not including tax & shipping, before rebates (I ALWAYS price things before rebates - I almost never get around to sending them in anyway), and without the hard drive (I'd use my current 80GB and 250GB for a month or two if I can last that long.

Price with the substitutions you suggested, not including tax & rebates, and before shipping, is $244.94, again dropping the hard drive.

I could consider buying the computer in two stages, seeing that my credit limit is $300, and I've already spent $110 this month on non-computer-related things. But, I want it to be usable with the first batch of components I get, and I don't want to replace something I just bought a month before. (Note: I can afford to pay a little more than that, but I prefer, if buying online, to pay with CC, and the local prices are upwards of 20-35% more.)

Also, that case you suggested doesn't have nearly enough room for the add-in cards, hard drives and DVD burners that I will inevitably eventually be adding later.

And, are there any PSUs that come with cases under $45 that are good, or do I have to get the PSU and case separately?


Or, as another option... pick a PSU at least 480W under $20 before MIR from this list, and..

Would this Rosewill R218-P-BK case for $17.99 be ok, or would it be worth it to splurge on this Rosewill R5604-BK for $39.99?

Also, could I keep the single-core CPU for now (and upgrade maybe a year later to one that today might cost upwards of $400-700 (but will hopefully be cheaper then))?

Also, as a reference to my parents' computer, which I'm currently using, how much of an improvement is it? For example...
2.4GHz Athlon 64 vs 1.4Ghz Athlon
2GB DDR2-667 RAM vs 256MB DDR-233 RAM
? vs probably a 300W (I don't remember) PSU that I think came with the case
GeForce 6100 onboard video vs GeForce4 MX400 card



Oh, and 1283, I didn't see your reply until AFTER I had posted mine (which took a while to put together). Just as a quick note, I'd like to keep this as low of a price as possible for now, with an eye toward upgrading some components (not including the case and mobo) later.



Also, I plan to wait on the 500GB HD for a month or two, and I'll try to limp along with my current 80GB and 250GB drives, both of which are IDE. Even if Win 2k has the 127GB LBA limit, the 250GB is split into 2 equal size partitions and I'm running it just fine on my parents' computer (although it may be hooked up to a controller card - I'd have to open the case and I don't feel like doing that right now.) When I get the 500GB (unless 750GB or 1TB has dropped in price) in a couple months, I'll get XP Pro at the same time.

Also, my parents are planning to upgrade their system and get XP. Is there a way we can save $ if we're both buying XP at the same time, for installation on two different computers, running simultaneously?
 

random1283

Distinguished
Oct 26, 2007
222
0
18,680
ok then instead of the Dual core just get a celeron d 420 save $30 and onboard video is really not worth it trust me. the 8400gs that I recommended is really the minimum you want these days.

Try this order of buying parts
CPU-Mobo month 1
Ram-Graphics-DVD month 2
HDD- month 3
should be fine
 

vochtige

Distinguished
Jan 11, 2008
499
0
18,780
I'm looking to build a budget box. I'll mostly be doing multimedia-related things (audio, video, photos) and the like. I may do a little light gaming (mainly 3+ years old), but nothing really fancy. Could you guys rate (for the price it looks like I'll have to pay) the system specs below? How much better is it than what I've been using (not my own PC though) - Athlon 1.4MHz, K6T266 Pro2 Mobo, 256MB DDR-266MHz RAM, GeForce MX400 Video, etc...

it will be a much better system, but try to go for a cheap duo core (athlon 64 bit x2) doesn't cost that much!
and that geforce 6100, it may run your older games, but there are better ones, who arent expensive. like an 7300GT or 8500GT. good cards for video and stuff.

 

pianoplayer88key

Distinguished
Dec 4, 2006
101
0
18,680






For the most part, at least for the next few months, things I'm running on my parents' computer (1.4GHz Athlon, 256MB RAM, GeForce4 MX400 video, etc, will be what I'll be running, at least until I get some upgraded parts at least 6-8 months from now.
Also, month 1 should have enough to have a usable computer - minimum CPU, Mobo w/video, RAM, maybe DVD (unless I network to my parents' DVD burner then I can wait).
I have a 250GB and 80GB HDs I can limp along with for now, and I may be able to network (but I'll need to figure out how to do that) with my parents' DVD burner (but I will want to get my own sooner rather than later). Probably the next purchase, after the initial outlay, will be a 500GB (or 750GB if the prices come down in the next month or two) HD and Windows XP. Later on down the road, as needed (but I don't anticipate any of this being within the next 6-8 months), a dedicated graphics card, better PSU, faster processor, more hard drives, extra DVD burners. In something like 4-5 years or so when I'm looking at upgrading the mobo and case, it'll probably be better at that time to get a whole new system.

So should I switch over to the Intel, or keep the AMD? If so, what Intel board/CPU should I go with, while keeping the same price, performance, and connectivity as with the AMD setup I have proposed?

Also I would like to keep the initial purchase price under $300, so I can put it on my CC (which reminds me I should see if the CC company will let me pay my CC bill before I receive the paper bill in the snail mail), AND have a usable computer from the start. I will plan to add more components later as they're needed, though.
 

tlmck

Distinguished

The case I suggested can handle all the addin cards your chosen MB can supply. It is actually as long, front to back as just about any mid tower, it is just shorter. This means 2 drive bays for optical as opposed to 3. It does have room for 5 hard drives. If you need a standard mid tower, here is a good deal with free shipping. A little flashy, but it will work. http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16811208009

As a general rule, the only "included" PSU's that are any good are Antec Earthwatts. However, their combos are out of your budget. None of the PSUs you suggest are worth the tin they are stamped out of. PSU's are not a "budget" or "afterthought" item. If they do not work, then it really does not matter what other components you choose. They will be collecting dust assuming the cheap PSU does not fry them. The PSU I listed was the best "quality" deal I could find for your proposed build. It will handle just about anything you can throw at it except for a high end video card.

You could keep the single core, but would be better served with the dual for your intended tasks. Either way, that motherboard will not be upgradeable to the newer processors you mention.

The onboard 6100 video chip is good for everything but gaming.

As far as I know, you can only run 1 copy of Windows on 1 machine at a time. Microsoft is getting pretty good at sniffing out duplicates. Many places like Newegg sell just the additional license(no disk) for less money. You can get 1 OEM copy, and then just buy an additional license for the second machine.
 

pianoplayer88key

Distinguished
Dec 4, 2006
101
0
18,680

I prefer a standard mid tower over a uATX. Actually I'd like a full tower but they're way over budget. The taller, the better, and I want decent ventilation, and at least 1 fan included (more could be purchased later as I get higher end components that need better cooling).
Would this Rosewill R5604-BK case work? It's the same price as the one you suggested (I don't count the MIR), and the side panel window and lighting doesn't matter to me.


So I can't get a PSU under $20? Also, that one you suggested is only 350W. For $40, I expect AT LEAST 600W, or is that unreasonable?


Is there another board with preferably more slots & connectors that WOULD be upgradeable? I'd like to keep the board+CPU combo under $100 base price, though, if at all possible. If I splurge on the board, I'll have to (for now) skimp on the CPU.


Would Half Life 1, Scorched Earth 3D, and Total Annihilation run ok on it? They run good enough for me on my parents' computer (GF4-MX400).


How much less would it cost? If I could get the 2nd copy for, say, 10-15% of the price of the 1st one, with permission to make myself a copy of the install disc (so we have 1 disc for each license, but alas it's probably copy protected), I would like that. But if I'm only going to save $10 or so, it's probably better to just buy the two copies, I think.
 

random1283

Distinguished
Oct 26, 2007
222
0
18,680
At the moment you should switch to the intel and mobo as the mobo has room (1066mhz fsb) to even take a quad q6600 and with the new chips coming out intel is going t get cheaper in about 2-3 months time
 

vochtige

Distinguished
Jan 11, 2008
499
0
18,780
at my own experience, pick asus! and a p5k serie (c2d and quad) or the p5b for c2d! i think for the perpuse you are you should take the pentium c2d E6750 2.33 ghz, it's stronger than the best amd duocore (look at the charts here on tomshardware). and if you can wait the E8 series is coming up, and prices don't change a lot, but performance will!
 

tlmck

Distinguished
The Rosewill case will work, although the shipping cost is a bit steep. They also tend to have cheap noisy fans. The case quality is decent though.

You can certainly buy a PSU for under $20. You just cannot get a quality one that cheap. You can even find a 600w for $20 if you really look. Just explain that to the fire department when they show up. Quality PSU's in the 600w range start at about $90. Based on your system specs 600 watt would be overkill. Also, more watts does not mean better quality. The best price I could find on a higher power unit was this. http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817371002 I did not mention it before as it was out of the budget, and overkill for your needs. The only reason you would need this is if you plan to add a high end gaming card later.

The only MB/CPU Combos you will find for under $100 are old, and not upgradeable. For extra slots, you would need a standard ATX board, which further drives up the cost.

You might be able to run those games on the 6100, depending on the resolution. Once again, on board video is just a different animal since it does not have it's own dedicated memory. At best, it would be equal to the MX 400.

Apparently they do not sell the license only things anymore. At least I could not find them. Used to be around $50 or so. The cheapest OS upgrade path I can see right now would be to get a copy(s) of Vista Home Basic Upgrade from Amazon for about $50 ea. A friend got me one for about $42 I think. At any rate, with your current version of Windows you would have to use this procedure to do a "clean install". http://www.winsupersite.com/showcase/winvista_upgrade_clean.asp

The Home Basic version of Vista will run on just about any machine that XP will run on. It does not have the Aero interface, but I don't care about such stuff anyways. The one drawback may be that it would not like your old games. I have a couple that simply would not run, and they are newer than yours. http://www.amazon.com/Microsoft-Windows-Vista-Basic-UPGRADE/dp/B000HCZ9AC/ref=pd_bbs_sr_2/104-9891449-7379147?ie=UTF8&s=software&qid=1200229655&sr=1-2





 

chuckm

Distinguished
Nov 7, 2007
970
0
18,980
After reading thru this I think the best thing for you to do at this time is to look in the For Sale section. There are quite a few upgrades being done and parts are being sold thru the different forums. You might be able to get some good deals on used parts. The only other thing is your obsession with cheap power supplies. Do whatever you have to do, but get a good one NOW and you won't have that problem later. Get a 450 watt like this;

http://www.buy.com/prod/Corsair-VX-450w-Power-Supply/q/loc/101/205466485.html
 

pianoplayer88key

Distinguished
Dec 4, 2006
101
0
18,680
So looks like my proposed parts don't cut it...

So looks like I'll wait till at least next month to buy one.. :(

I really don't want to pay $∞ for -∞, which is what it's looking like I'd have to pay if I bought top-of-the-line quality. I'm willing to pay a little more than bargain basement to avoid buying parts made in China, but, for example paying $80 for a 350W PSU vs $25 for a 600W PSU - what's the justification if you're not an avid hard-core gamer?

Or, get my dad to upgrade his computer so I can get an external 500GB USB2/eSATA/firewire800 hard drive. (His computer currently has USB 1.1 for external and PATA for internal.)

I think I've said before, but my dad's PC is an Athlon 1.4MHz on a MSI K6T266 Pro2 mobo, with 256MB of RAM, currently Windows 2000 (He wants to upgrade to XP Professional), a 200GB HD of which only 127GB is allocated.

So... whether it's for my own computer, OR my dads.... I guess I need some pointers on what to look for, for example using NewEgg's power searches - cases, CPUs, RAM, AMD/Intel mobos, etc.

4 example, for the case, we would like something well ventilated, front (or top) USB+audio (firewire & esata may be optional), plenty of fans - 120mm, 200mm, 300mm, etc (btw I saw a case at Fry's that had a fan on the side that was bigger than my hand! (which can stretch a 10th (octave+3rd) on a piano), plenty of room for expansion (cards, optical & hard drives, etc). One problem is possibly limited physical space in the computer desk to put it, though. I don't have the measurements off the top of my head, but I think it's less than 8" wide and 27" tall or something like that, I don't remember.
On the CPU, for me, I'm willing to settle for low-end single-core, but it must be either Socket AM2 or LGA 775. I think my dad might want at least a mid-level dual core, though. (Note: we're not both buying (me getting new, him upgrading) at the same time - either he's upgrading (and I'm getting a bigger HD), OR I'm buying new (and he's holding out).)
RAM - minimum 1GB. 2GB or 4GB would be preferred. CNET forum users say Kingston and Crucial are good quality. Any other suggestions?
MOBO - plenty of expandability. Would like minimum 2 or 4 IDE device support, 4 SATA drive (more like 6 or 8), Socket LGA775 or AM2/+, 6 or more expansion slots (although I don't remember how many, if any, legacy (PCI/AGP) devices we have. (I'm sure the GeForce4 MX400 video card would get upgraded, possibly.)

Also, just because I don't get my own computer right away doesn't mean I'm not running out of hard drive space, and QUICKLY (and no, not due to a virus - it's because of all the stuff I put on it from my digital still/video camera, mp3 recorder, etc. So I'll need pointers on picking out an external HD (so I can take it with me and plug it into other computers occasionally). For 500GB, for example, I'd prefer to pay no more than $100-120 before rebates, tax & shipping (and I will be charged tax if I order from NewEgg - I live in California.) I'd also be willing to consider an internal drive + external enclosure.

Also, how would you back that data up? We do have a DVD burner, but I don't want to use ∞ discs to back up our HDs, nor do I want to pay the same price per GB for the backup media that I pay for the main storage. I have a personal rule that anytime I pay the going rate for main media storage (HD), that is used for primary storage, NOT backup. (for example, $100 for 500GB.)

Another thing I may have not mentioned earlier, but I will eventually be doing with my computer (although I'm willing to wait until I get an add-on device later) is archive some 100s to 1000s of old cassettes / reel-to-reel / LPs into uncompressed digital format, for long-term (50+ years) archival and frequent playback (maybe a few hours a day or more, although that may be on portable devices like mp3 players / iPod / etc) purposes. So this may not be the place to ask what would be good quality players (I want to get every last micro-bit of quality possible out of the old media - I'd be happy with 99.999% of the original quality when it was new), but what are some good sound cards, especially with multiple inputs (so I could have, say, 4 to 16 tapes recording at once)?

*GASP* I feel like I'm out of breath! I didn't know my post would get THIS long!! :ouch:
 

chuckm

Distinguished
Nov 7, 2007
970
0
18,980
Why don't you want to back up data to DVD or CD. It's a very low cost way to free up that hard drive if there is already a burner in the system. Depending on the burn software you have, it's very easy to do, just drag and drop, hit burn.
As far as power supplies, the justification is system stablilty and simply having enough AMPS on each rail, particularly the 12V. Good power supplies are best sellers for a reason, no matter what else you decide to get, do not go CHEAP on the power supply. Pay attention to amp ratings and how many 12 V rails the unit has, it used to be multiple rails were better , but now you want a single 12V rail.
You do NOT have to go top of the line to get a great performing system but you will need at least $400-$500 and personally go with an Intel 21XX CPU and go from there. I have not built myself an new system since my PIII and probably could spend $1500 but so far it looks like around $700 will have me very satisfied. I've done builds for others for a long time, and most of the people that spend a little less are more satisifed than the ones that spend more.
 

tlmck

Distinguished

Once again, you are confusing quantity with quality. More watts does not equal better quality. I could go to the local Fry's, buy a bag of parts for ~$25, and build you a 1000w PSU. I would, however, be conveniently in another country with no extradition treaty when you fired it up. :lol: And, the 350w PSU I recommended is $39.99 with free shipping, not $80.

You are certainly free to buy whatever you wish. I just cannot, in all good concience, recommend such products.
 

pianoplayer88key

Distinguished
Dec 4, 2006
101
0
18,680
Ok, so rather than getting my own computer, I'm thinking about getting an external 500GB HD for ~ $100-125 to plug into my parents' computer. (Also, external, because I want to be able to take it with me when I need to plug it into another computer and use it. I'd be willing to consider internal plus an external enclosure, too.)

Also, my dad wants to upgrade to Windows XP. And, he would like a better way to cool the computer. Our CPU (or something - I don't know how to interpret this SpeedFan 4.25 program my dad has) sometimes runs upwards of 52°C

One thing... I want that ext HD to be forward compatible to current technology. Thing is my dad's computer doesn't have SATA or Firewire, and only has USB 1.1

I've already mentioned most of the specs, but now I got a few pics...

Place where Tower Case is (with the case in there for reference) - this may limit how big of a case we can get. Would it be better not to put it there?


Side of case, with custom-made side air vent courtesy of my dad


Rear of case. (click and browse the album for a couple closer shots of the bottom and top)


PSU


Inside overview looking toward drives


Inside overview of mobo (view album for a couple closer shots)



Oh, and the internal IDE controller (the one that's not built into the mobo):



So.... btw my parents have a 200GB HD, Windows 2000 SP4, the pictured components, etc. What gives, with only 127GB formatted?

And, anything I would need to watch out for with plugging in a 500GB (or, if I can find a good deal on ebay, 750GB (a few completed around $125+20S&H) or 1TB (a couple completed around $160+14S&H) USB 2.0 hard drive into a USB 1.1 port? (I'm leaning toward USB, because the chances of my friends (when I may need to use it there) having USB is much greater than them having firewire or eSATA.)