Ad
News

Microsoft ships first post-beta 2 build of Vista

Published on June 27, 2006

Late Friday, Microsoft shipped Windows Vista build 5456, its first post-Beta 2 version of the next major Windows release. Read more

Microsoft Releases New Build of Windows Vista

Published on September 25, 2006

Microsoft has released an interim build of Windows Vista to its usual testers as well as to some 100,000 of the participants in its Customer Preview Program. Read more

Trend Micro renovates PC-cillin security software

Published on October 31, 2005

Trend announced a new version its home office security solution PC-cillin Internet Security, which now integrates an anti-phishing component. Read more

Sales of home media servers at reach 50 million units by 2010, says Parks Associates

Published on May 31, 2006

Annual sales of home media servers will reach nearly 50 million units in the US by the end of 2010, according to Parks Associates. Read more

Latest Reviews & Articles

Radeon HD 4830: High-Speed, Cheap CrossFire

Published on December 11, 2008

AMD recently launched its Radeon 4830 to take on Nvidia's GeForce 9800 GT. With PowerColor and Sapphire flavors in single- and CrossFire-configurations, we pitch the card against factory-overclocked 8800 GTs and see who is left standing. Read more

Acoustically Manage Your Hard Drive

Published on December 09, 2008

Most modern drives can be set to deliver maximum performance or to operate quietly. We looked at how performance, acoustics, and power requirements change when switching from fast to quiet using Hitachi’s Deskstar 7K1000.B. Read more

Graphics Boosted: 790GX's Side-Port Explored

Published on December 09, 2008

AMD's 790GX and 780G support onboard memory to help improve the performance of integrated graphics. Is it worth paying a bit extra or is the feature a mere gimmick? Read more

PCI Express & CrossFire: Scaling Explored

Published on December 08, 2008

Does your aging CrossFire-compatible motherboard have enough PCI Express bandwidth to make a second card worthwhile? We compare every Core 2-based platform in order to find out. Read more

  Tom's Hardware Forums » Homebuilt Systems » New System Build » mac pro vs home build?
 

mac pro vs home build?




Word :   Username :  
 
Bottom
Author
 Thread : mac pro vs home build?
 
Profile: stranger
More Information

I'm a software developer by profession but the software I write at work doesn't directly relate to what I'm interested in, mainly GPGPU, graphics, and high performance computing. Currently I don't have a computer so I need one so I can start learning. I love building computer systems but my time is limited so I have been looking at boutique stores for systems that I can build, get it running and not have to waste time overclocking, debugging the build, configuring the bios for performance, setting up the operating system for performance, etc. I can do all of that, but the adage goes time is money...

The new Mac Pro, with it's 8 core goodness is about as close to what I want as possible. I would buy it, swap out the graphics card for the HD 3870 or buy the 8800GT from apple. I would also add 2x2GB sticks of DDR2 and use bootcamp to install vista 64, or maybe vista 32 because I hear there are some drive support problems with 64 vista on macs.

Total cost:
$2800 Mac Pro
$189 Vista
$250 HD 3870
$??? 4GB ECC DDR2 800 MHz ram

$3500 ish.

First, I don't think the skulltrail motherboard is available for purchase? Second, the 45nm quad cores are going to be $1000 each, so the $2800 mac is actually a pretty good bargin.

I might have to add a few harddrives, but those are pretty cheap. Oh and I do need a monitor too, probably go with a good 30" display. Anyway, the monitor would be the same regardless of the route I take so we can take that out of the equation.

Is there a boutique store that builds 8 core workstations for about that price that can give similar performance? Would I be able to save money if I try to build it myself?

Thanks in advance.

Related Product

Register or log in to remove.

Forum's resident audiophile.
Profile: Faithful Poster
More Information

If you build it yourself you'll save a heck of a lot of money. Macs are the biggest ripoffs ever.

Profile: stranger
More Information

quantumsheep: please show me how to configure an 8 core system for similar price and performance by homebuild.

Profile: nimble knuckle
More Information

If you go Mac you might want to check video driver availability for those cards.


---------------
I know what I know, and I don't know what I don't know.
Profile: member

The only other 8-core configurations out there cost a heck of a lot more money (around $1000 more) to build yourself. Like tlmck said, just make sure that the hardware is compatible with the mobo. Other than that, looks like a great deal and have fun using way more cores than will ever be needed ;D


---------------
Pentium e2160 @ 3.0 GHz - 4 GB DDR2 800 RAM - 250 GB HDD Seagate 7200.10 - Cooler Master Hyper TX2 cooler - Radeon HD 3850 512 MB
[url=http://valid.x86-secret.com/show_oc.php?id=42
Profile: stranger
More Information
Profile: Faithful Poster
More Information

poached wrote :

quantumsheep: please show me how to configure an 8 core system for similar price and performance by homebuild.

 

My question is what would you use an 8 core homebuilt system for exactly? What could you possibly be doing that would require that many cores? Are you going to play Crysis, work in Indesign, 3D Studio Max, Xara and Maya all at the same time? Just wondering because the video card and amount of main memory you are picking out sure does not fit the bill for an 8 core high performance computer.
I think with 8 cores, you should have at least 64gig of main memory, and a Qaudro FX 5600 very minimum, probably 2 of them.
Add in 4 or 5-147gig 15,000rpm SCSI drives, put them into a RAID setup, and you would have quite a powerhouse indeed.
Of course with these added features, which you really should get to make use of all those cores, will add another $30,000-$40,000 to your total bill.

Profile: stranger
More Information

What on earth are you going to do with 8 cores? Especially if you just going to run your own programmes on it. Global illumination models or what?

Profile: stranger
More Information

good questions from jit and outofdate. I realize 8 cores may be overkill, and jit you are right in that more memory and fast disk access are needed to make this system more balanced, but currently I don't think there is a cheaper way to get 8 cores, is there? I'll check out the xicomputer.com link. More cores = faster compiles. Visual Studio 8 can automatically use all available cores during compile. It will save a ton of time.

Good point about checking for driver compatibility, but I'll be running vista too so I'm sure that'll work.

CTRL-ALT-DE1337
Profile: addict
More Information

poached wrote :

quantumsheep: please show me how to configure an 8 core system for similar price and performance by homebuild.



Hey, poached. I've got your wildest dreams come true (no not the ones with the nympho and the studded collar) :lol: and their right on this forum.

http://www.tomshardware.com/forum/ [...] orkstation

http://www.tomshardware.com/forum/ [...] ore-killer

Everythng youd ever want to know about cloning a MacPro Octopus at half the price!

Profile: stranger
More Information

it looks good until you see that he is using dual 2.3 harpertown vs 2.8 or 3.0 harpertown in the apple system. The 3.0 are around $1000 and that translates into a 600 dollar difference per chip. This is then another $1200 that he should have added to his homebrew, which makes the final price around 4k. Cheaper than mac but that's because apple is charging stupid amount of money for memory and if I buy it from 3rd source I could probably find something cheaper.


  Tom's Hardware Forums » Homebuilt Systems » New System Build » mac pro vs home build?

Go to:
 

Google Ads