Is this a good HTPC build spec?

[stan412]

Hi,

I am planning on building a HTPC system, and while I believe my hardware will be sufficient, I am still not totally sure how good it will play-back HD TV and Blu-ray, etc.
My biggest question I suppose is, the more expensive/higher-rated a hardware is (such as a graphics card), will it play movies clearer/faster?

Right now I have a DFI RS482 (mATX) board, with a PC2700 RAM, but it is only 1 GB.
As for a graphics card, I was thinking of the Radeon HD series, but which? Once the HD 3450 comes out, I want that because it's passive cooled, but will it hinder my HD experience as compared to, oh, a HD 3850?

Any other hardware suggestions would be welcome, like a TV Tuner, because I am not too familiar in terms of what's good and bad with those...

Thanks!

 

[Wolfshadw]

While I expect budget based cards like the HD3450 to be able to play HD content, fast moving scenes could be too much for it. I can never really recommend a budget class card. If you're willing to wait for the HD3450, then I would recommend actually getting the HD3650 which should be out around the same time frame.

I'd also recommend doubling your RAM to 2 GB.

You don't mention what type of processor you have installed, but I would recommend a dual-core if you don't have one already. Dual-Core Opterons are still available in a few places.

As far as TV Tuners are concerned, I'd look to either Hauppauge, AVerMedia, or ATI's TV-Pro series with a PCI-Ex1 interface.

-Wolf sends

 

[TeraMedia]

What O/S are you considering? Vista Home Pro? MCE 2k5? Something else?

I second the 2 GB minimum. My HTPC (MCE 2k5) eats more than 1 GB all the time. So will Vista, from what I hear.

Is this going to be in a component rack, a Hi Fi cabinet, or deskside? If it's going to be in the L.R. (you are concerned about sound), you'll want to focus on the coolest-running parts you can find. You might be better off with something like an HD2600XT than a higher-powered card, and you might also be better off with a card with a slow, case-exhausting fan than either no fan (increasing load on your case fan - which can be tough with the HTPC form-factor), or an internal fan (same problem).

 

[stan412]

Thanks guys.

I have an Opteron 146...kinda don't feel like spending for dual-core--but do I really need it?
I was hoping the 1 GB would be enough, cuz I'm either going for a MythTV or Windows MCE 2005...

 

[Wolfshadw]

No, you don't *need* a dual core. That's just a recommendation. Same goes with 2 GB of RAM. If I had to choose between the two, I'd go with the 2 Gig of RAM.

-Wolf sends

 

[stan412]

Thanks, Wolf.

Hopefully the difference between a single- & dual-core won't make much of a difference, to the likes of slower frame rates?...that's more of the graphics card's job, right?

I have a 2 GB pair of sticks of memory laying around, and I have the means to get either the Radeon 2600 Pro/XT or HD 3000/3800s...